If they were actually trying then that child would not have been able to touch the other students much less injure them. |
In my school we have so many kids causing these behaviors. No one ever checks in on the kids. It’s just the norm. |
My kid had a violent classmate in 3rd grade who even punched a teacher. The kid stayed in the class the whole year. It was awful for everyone but special ed kids get priority over everyone else. And before anyone says this is why they want their kids in AAP, this was an AAP class. There’s lots of “twice exceptional” kids in AAP. |
As quoted PP indicated, there's a certain amount of training that goes into keeping students from hurting each other without hurting a student in turn. Can you imagine the hue and cry if a teacher accidentally injured a violent SPED student while trying to keep them from hurting someone? After all those restraint and seclusion articles in the past few years? It would be nightmarish for that teacher. |
I’m familiar with restraint and seclusion, those types of incidents occur when the teachers aren’t trained. Which is exactly the problem with FCPS. |
Yes. The current idea is that you remove the rest of the class. Therefore, there is no one for the child to hit or kick. |
It’s really not the norm but all it takes is 1-2 kids to mess it up for everyone. And then you get the effect of, oh those two can’t be in a class together so we need to separate them, so now fully 2/3 or 2/4 of the ES classes have a behavioral case in them, oh and one of them is AAP too and his parents are fully resisting any more restricting environment … it’s a huge mess. And the self-contained kids won’t be disrupting a general education classroom, but all bets are off at lunch or recess, or before and after school or on the bus or what have you. |
We need more classrooms and teachers for SPED students with dysrequlation issues. But we don't want to pay the teachers the money they need or pay for the increased number of teachers needed. Or pay for the space that is needed. There are no appropriate placement options and the schools are forced to drag out the process because a child needs to get to a certain threshold before the admin outside the school will authorize placement in a specialized classroom.
Parents already complain about the amount of money that goes into SPED, not realizing how much the special programs, reading/math specialists, aides, 1-1 aides, materials, classrooms, and bussing cost. It is a lot. We are losing SPED teachers faster than any other group of teachers because there is not enough admin support, in the form of case workers and people to handle paper work, nevermind actual Admin support, backing the teacher and working to find solutions. It would help if schools could actually discipline kids, but they can't. And it would help if parents reinforced school rules and discipline at home, but many don't. Kids violate class rules, teachers discipline the kid, teachers get in trouble for making the kid feel bad. Teachers send the kid to the office; the kid comes back with a snack or a toy and returns to whatever behavior they had been doing. Teacher calls the parent, who complains tot he principal that the teacher is being mean, and the teacher gets in trouble. It is ridiculous. And so teachers are quitting, less experienced teachers are in classes and it just gets worse. But suggest paying teachers a reasonable wage and allowing for actual discipline and you are crazy. Many of the kids acting out are not SPED, they are poorly disciplined at home and there are no consequences at school. SPED kids who are really struggling need self contained classes to help them develop the skills that they need but those classes don't exist. The system is broken but we don't want to fix it because it costs too much. |
FCPS spent a boatload of money on Ross Greene training when they took away restraint and seclusion. |
Ross Greene training is for basic noncompliance, not severe aggression to others. FCPS simply is not equipped to handle children like this. I don’t understand how they do nothing, it’s a huge liability. |
In the state where I grew up, in the 70s and early 80s we still had "paddling" for grade schools. The parents had to sign a permission form. If a kid did something like OP described and the parents signed the form, the kid would go to the office, bend over, and get 2 seats on the rear with a wooden paddle over their clothes. It hurt and was embarrassing, but it seemed to quickly quell that kind of socially unacceptable behavior. If really bad behavior was a pattern, the kid was expelled from the school and moved to a school for kids who couldn't behave, or if the parents had money, into Catholic schools where the tolerance for that kind of behavior was even lower and discipline was required. |
There is still the issue of causing harm to self or teachers in the room. There is zero excuse not to be trained if that is happening. Removing everyone else isn’t /shouldn’t be a long term solution, it’s what you do in the moment when you have no other immediate solution. However you also have to then go look at the situation and figure out a better plan, this isn’t it. No wonder people don’t want to work there. |
I'm betting all these people who think "training" would fix the problem have never been in a classroom with this issue. |
I’m not suggesting training will “fix” the issues, clearly the issues extend beyond this. I’m stating that you cannot operate in this manner WITHOUT the training. It’s negligent, as without the training there’s a high risk of harm being done the child, other students, and faculty. No training = liability. And yes I’ve worked in very “difficult” classrooms. |
I'm surprised kids don't ever gang up on the troublemakers at recess and sort it out themselves. |