But why would a straight A student only score a 1200? That doesn’t make sense unless their school’s 4.0 is useless measure of ability. |
NP. First, achievement and ability are two different things, and neither GPA nor test scores purport to measure ability, although in a fuzzier way, having ability certainly makes higher GPA and higher scores more possible. Second, GPA is not, nor ever will be, a standardized metric, not even within the same high school. Classes and teachers are too different. |
Correct. For most (if not all) schools, this is the case. |
I would interpret these differently--maybe it's just my brain talking to my brain, but it has seemed to predict who makes the shifts in language from "optional" to "aware" -- Test Optional: Scores may be really important or not (see what we put in the check box on the CDS for the importance of SAT scores as well as percent of students submitting scores for more info). Not always, but often schools who have a prior history of high SAT scores tend to have higher percentage of students reporting; schools that had a prior history of lower SAT scores tend to have lower percentage of students reporting. The former are the ones who are more likely to be talking about becoming test aware now. Test Aware: We are one of the former test optional schools who decided to be more forthright--we're one of the schools who when we said test optional we meant if you have a ton of other great qualities we particularly want we'd rather you not send in your low test scores so they don't stand in your way of being accepted, but if you're just a regular applicant and really want to get in we want to see your scores. Oh and we don't mind if a bunch of people apply with no test scores that we don't accept because it helps our yield. |
Some parents play the IEP game.. extra time for tests, repeat tests, tutoring, etc. to keep them grades up. When the kid bombs a standardized test they go, "oh, he's a poor test taker" and push the kid to repeat the test multiple times to crack that 1400 benchmark.. |
Good. The covid nonsense must stop. (but of course we know Who and Why the AOs want to keep TO in place) |
This. I was told a kid from a good school district or private with means --they are going to assume their scores weren't good enough to send in. Our CC joked that nobody is [/i]not [i]sending in a 35-36 ACT, or 1580 SAT. It will be assumed you bombed it. Also, with such grade inflation and professors/universities continually noting students are arriving less and less prepared, having both ACT/SAT and GPA weeds out grade inflation to a degree---if you submit you got all 4-5s on your AP exams, even stronger. |
In 80-90% of high schools in the US, earning a 4.0 is not that hard. My niece was valedictorian of her parochial school and earned a 31 on her ACT. |
Exactly. Then they have to read your essays. I listen to a different podcast not from the Dartmouth admissions Director but from someone else who mentioned that a lot of ivies want the score because it’s an auto reject pile for GPA and Test score They don’t even read anything unless you pass that first stage. |
1400 not hard to crack for mediocre student over 2-3x taking test. 1500 harder for Mediocre student |
We’ve heard of exactly 1 test aware school. The thread is asking if there are others. Anything else is your brain talking to your brain |
This is fairly common |
They aren't reading all the test optional essays. They will also cut you if you're not the top recalculated GPA they have in however they define your region and don't meet any other preferred characteristics. It's not like not having a SAT test score makes you a holistic candidate. |
1400 is 95th percentile 1500 is 98th percentile "Mediocre students" aren't going to hit either no matter how many times they try |
Highly selective schools want you to submit the scores and want you to pay the fee and want you to add to their great application numbers and eventual yield. They want the score bc it’s entered into a data management system (like ptr-Vovid) along with zip code and gpa and school code, for auto sorting. But if your score is below the 50th percentile mark and you do not have something really special… Not great… Not even normal awards… Something magical, and so unique… It’s a waste of time. So for those kids if they are below the 50th percentile, I would say no don’t submit. Because it’s true they don’t even read your application if you were below unless there is some other hook If you do not submit the score, you are automatically put into another pile. Read usually by different people/committee members. Did you notice strangely a lot more test optional kids got into really good schools last year then kids with perfect stats in your circle?!? Maybe just a private school thing but I think not. |