I’m sorry but that’s ridiculous. Obviously an 8 year old knows about a family wedding and may have been to other weddings. No one needs to suggest something to an 8 year old for them to independently have ideas and feelings of their own. Look, it’s fine to exclude children and draw your boundary. Own it. Your niece and nephew may be disappointed and everyone will deal (this family did) — but you don’t get to blame their parents for their feelings, of all things. 🙄 |
DP here. the parents tend to hype things up, in situations such as these. Kids hear you, they are not stupid. Stop trying to make them your puppets. |
+1. Kids do not want to sit at the table and wait out 4-8 hours of speeches and adults trying to dance without getting cake smeared all over their best clothes. GTFOH. I have seen older people trip over running kids at a wedding, it was quite a catastrophe. Kids and weddings don't mix. |
DP here. Genius. Some people can't take no for an answer. I can think of one or two from our guest list that would pitch a fit, in one form or another. I did not think of lying to them about no kids, but would have, had I thought of it. |
Do people think kids don’t notice if their parents leave town for an event? We left our kids behind for the first time when my oldest was 5, and the wedding was in another city. We talked about it as minimally as possible because we knew our 5yo wouldn’t like being excluded. It was all fine and I’m not saying the couple should have done anything different, but my 5yo noticed she was excluded and didn’t like it with us (the parents) saying as little as possible and making her time with grandma as fun as possible. Again this was fine, but I don’t know why it stretches credulity for some people that a child would have feelings about missing out on a family event. |
+1 I am so in love with you. Every word is on point. I want to frame this post. Thank you. Well said, all of it. :Standing ovation: |
Own that it’s your job to manage expectations in your household. A lot if kids don’t care about weddings and don’t want to go. |
Sorry don’t buy it. If you were leaving for a couples weekend you would just do it. Your kid is going to be excluded sometimes. If you can’t bear to be away for a weekend from each other then never go away again. But you’re letting a 5 yr call the shots here and that’s not how all families work. Don’t put this on the bride and groom that you can’t tell your kid no. |
I feel like you did not read what I wrote. This was our first trip away, not everyone does couples weekends on the regular. I absolutely have no problem with the no kids policy on that wedding and we did it and everyone lived. The question was whether children have feelings about being excluded. I’m guessing the parents for whom it is a bigger deal to leave the kids are the ones who don’t do that on the regular. |
Absolutely the parents' job and yes, I'm sure that is true for many but not all kids. Just to be clear: a PP wrote "7 year olds will definitely not remember the wedding, and 10 year olds might barely remember the wedding. If you want the kids in the photos, fine, but don't pretend the kids want to be there, or actually care." That is what I and several others disagreed with. |
Are there adults who want to sit and wait out 4-8 hours of speeches? |
Right, so this was about you and your feelings. It's a HUGE deal for you to go away for a weekend and your kid totally picked up on that. Your kid doesn't know they are excluded if you don't tell them they are. A 5 yr old only knows that you're leaving. Managing expectations better instead of "oh how we wish you could go! It would be so fun! But alas, the bride says you can't go." Your kid felt excluded because you told her she was. |
What does a 7 year old know about a wedding? Have they been to many before? Where did they get the idea this was a party for them that they would even be included in? If my kids asked if they could go I'd just say "Sorry adults only" and they would be find b/c an adults only party isn't something they would be interested in. |
|
What on earth? You're against having kids at weddings - ok. But to act like a normal 7 year old doesn't know what one is and that it's a big deal? |