| Replace Umich and ND with Emory and Georgetown |
You still don't get it and apparently never will. Vanderbilt kids choose quality of life prestige hunting. Not a Vandy parent but come on already. |
same w our private, should be 13-15. |
|
| Does Northwestern get top 10% students at STA, Sidwell, GDS? |
+2 |
I generally agree with this, though I’d put Chicago below Brown and Dartmouth at 15. |
Vandy people act like it should be top 5. It has gotten cultish. I think it is a really great school. Perhaps deserves to be slightly higher. But it is basically in the right place. They need to chill. |
| Cornell has solidified itself as the #5 ivy - it's not credible to call it the worst ivy with consistent performance like this |
I said Ivies, Stanford, Duke, CalTech and MIT. That's 12 schools. So being behind those is 13. Though on second thought I might put Northwestern ahead of Chicago and Hopkins - not sure. |
STA is unique in that they publicly announce who is in the top20% (not top 10%). Sidwell and GDS do not so it's just conjecture. Yes, STA top 20% go to NU but not below this. It's a difficult admit. |
|
Chicago is a the one school that is a very difficult admit from public schools but a very easy admit from top private schools for kids who are academically minded but for whatever reason don't have top20 stats.
|
That “ranking” makes little sense if you consider the kids who have gone to these universities from DC’s high school in recent years: the Yale, Dartmouth, Brown, Columbia kids have been mostly (if not all) institutional priorities (URM, legacy, athlete). The UChicago and JHU kids have been among the top students (top ten percent, NMSFs, etc) |
|
Note: The data that inform these rankings usually lag by a few years, so it will be a few years later when the rankings reflect the impacts of the administration's battles with top schools like Harvard and Columbia, along with financial irresponsibility of other schools like UChicago. I expect these schools to drop a few spots in the next few years. 1 - Princeton 2 - MIT 3 - Harvard 4 - Stanford, Yale 6 - UChicago 7 - Duke, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, UPenn 11 - Caltech 12 - Cornell 13 - Brown, Dartmouth 15 - Columbia, Berkeley 17 - Rice, UCLA, Vanderbilt 20 - Carnegie Mellon, UMichigan, Notre Dame, WUSTL |
wrong |