Forum Index
»
Religion
Where is your data for your claim that religious people killed 1 billion people in the preceding millennia? You are obviously just making numbers up. |
OK. The vast majority of people who were responsible for the killings in those wars were religious. Being religious doesn't prevent people from killing others. |
Bubble graphic. The vast majority of people who killed others in the 20th century (and earlier) believed in supernatural forces (various gods). This is 2015. The % of religious people would be even higher in the 20th century. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/04/05/the-changing-global-religious-landscape/
|
What does this prove? You have not one piece of data to prove any of your claims. |
The 1 billion came from an earlier, unchallenged post. The vast majority of the people doing the killing in the preceding millennia believed in some supernatural forces / god(s). |
The vast majority of people believe in supernatural forces / god(s). Does that really need to be proven? |
|
Here’s the thing about atheism:
It’s not one size fits all. And most is if don’t give a hoot what someone else in the group is doing. You want to pray or celebrate Diwali? Cool. I. Don’t. Care. But I also don’t believe. |
If a Christian (or anyone from any religious denomination) killed/murdered, the infographic has counted it under the ideology. This is an infographic about the causes of death in the 20th century, not an infographic that shows who personally murdered or killed someone. Cause of death is different than the identity of the person who killed. For example, John killed somebody. He believed in God but didn’t belong to a church. He killed his neighbor, Mike, because his Mike ran over his beloved dog. That’s not a murder because of an ideology, that is a murder because an old guy really loved his dog. A man who believes in God killed someone, but the motivation for the murder wasn’t from his ideology. You are making up hella numbers without rhyme or reason. It’s really egregious. You can keep spamming your made up stuff, but it’s meaningless. You are taking the infographic and making up numbers randomly. You are making claims about a period in history that we don’t have data from, or extremely limited data, and claims no one could ever begin to possibly prove. Dude, you’re embarrassing yourself. |
BUT THAT DOESN’T mean they killed someone based on their religious ideology. The infographic is Causes of death, not a list of people who killed. If a religious person killed somebody for non-religious reasons, they wouldn’t be classified under ideology on this infographic.They would just be under murder or whatever the data scientists who researched and built this infographic felt was the correct category. You are making numbers up about things you have zero idea about. |
This is why you are spamming made up crap. Atheists here won’t even acknowledge this. Your big acknowledgment is “killing is bad, atheists killed but religious people kill more” and then you pull some numbers out of your butt and claim victory. Atheists will never be trusted by the vast majority and of people worldwide because of the genocides they perpetrated ON THEIR OWN PEOPLE. |
Umm I have never read such a ridiculous desperate thread. Atheists are not a country or a civilization. Who are "they"? The political leadership in those countries that committed genocide don't represent Atheists, in the same way Hamas doesn't represent all Muslims. I'm an Atheist who simply doesn't believe in God. I don't have an "Atheist" community, I have no idea what most of the people I know believe unless they are very overt about it. Either you believe in a God/Gods or you don't. What has popularity have to do with lack of faith?.. |
I never said they did. You are intentionally misrepresenting what I've written. |
So why has every government that mandated atheism perpetrated mass murders (at least 100 million deaths) on their own people? Just a coincidence? |
It's just how the numbers work when the vast majority of people believe in supernatural forces. Let's say 1 billion people were killed in the last millennia. Say that 20% of those were killed by atheists (way overestimating), then that leaves 800 million people who were killed by people who believe in supernatural forces. Look at the last couple hundred years: http://christianityinview.com/religion-statistics.html There just aren't that many atheists. |
You are taking an infographic that shows causes of death for a specific time period and stating that because Christians have a higher population, they have committed more murders because of their deep supernatural beliefs. None of that is reflected or counted or confirmed in the infographic. If Christians killed people because of their Christian ideology, it’s shown of the infographic as the makers judged it as a cause of death. Your guesses about the data are meaningless and you don’t know why the murders in the murder bubble were committed. |