LOL, right? |
To the OP, we are on a high deductible plan and I routinely decline excess testing for my family that I don’t want to be charged for.
A common example - take child in for sore throat/suspicion of strep. On our HMO, they would also test for flu because why not? On the high deductible I say, no just test for strep. Strep comes back positive, antibiotics given. They can always test for flu after if the strep is negative. But I don’t need to pay for them to throw spaghetti at the wall to see what sticks. |
I read basically every other page, so maybe this was already addressed, but: 1. The procedure was the urine collection. She clearly consented to that. 2. She asked what tests were being run. They told her routine. She said fine. So she DID consent to whatever tests were deemed to be routine by the physician. If she had followed up and asked more specifically, then she would have known. She's young and was in pain - it makes perfect sense that she didn't ask for lots of details. But to now pretend that they were trying to do something sneaky or had misled her somehow is super disingenuous. |
Nice story, but in the OP's case, the pregnancy test is not "excess" and in fact was one of the first things that needed to be ruled out in a young woman presenting with GI issues. |
Also, the issue should be WHY IS A SIMPLE PREGNANCY TEST THIRTY-SEVEN DOLLARS? |
+1 Some of you didn't watch that episode of the Office when Pam and Jim found out that she was pregnant after an injury during the company picnic volleyball game and it shows. |
Why is a Tylenol $20? |
Hahaha, yeah, I posted early on sympathizing with the insanity of urgent care costs because yes, THIS part is definitely a problem. But it has nothing to do with consent and everything to do with the f-ed up healthcare system in the US. |
I feel like this thread is bascially an argument for universal healthcare. You have the Drs saying hey - healthcare is not a regular consumer purchase where you choose what you want from a buffet of options, you come to get treated, you need to let the Dr tell you what the treatment is. But for patients paying out of pocket, you get charged for every little thing, so you are afraid to defer to what the Dr says you need bc you have no idea what it will add up to. And it feels like, ok I came in with a specific problem to get treated and now I am being charged for a million different things I never asked for.
It's why so many Americans delay getting care that they need - it's impossible to predict how much it will cost and they can't afford to take their chances. Healthcare just doesn't work well as a for-profit business. |
I brought my 12 year old to the ER for intractable vomiting and dehydration (from a virus) and they tested her for pregnancy. She attended an all-girls school and had no male friends, so I felt insulted, but let them do the test anyway. They just have to screen all women of child-bearing age. |
So now you aren't complaining that she was tested without consent, you're upset that she wasn't specifically and proactively informed of each and every test that was going to be performed? OK, I guess. |
It's hard to believe this has to be said, but despite your apparent disbelief, many people *do* lie. That fact that you aren't lying is immaterial. Enough people do, and the repercussions of certain tests or treatments are so significant if one is pregnant, that the doctor needs to be absolutely sure before authorizing those treatments. Because someone who swears she isn't pregnant and is, whether she's lying or just ill-informed, absolutely will sue a provider and medical facility if her baby is harmed and the doctor didn't confirm pregnancy status. It's so silly being personally offended by this. And from the tone of your post, I'm doubting that your lack of sexual contact for a year is by choice. Your choice, anyway. |
I have said no to peeing in a cup at the primary care, the ob/gyn yearly visit and at urgent care in the past. I don't have a uterus anymore. Unless they can clearly explain what they are testing for and why, I'm not peeing in a cup.
It's standard and for obvious reasons, but can be a mindless exercise. If every woman who goes in to a yearly ob/gyn visit gets an extra $40 test, wow, that's a good deal for a dipstick that costs 30cents for the provider. Bottom line: Ask and get informed consent. If you didn't call them on it. |
and do you know you get drug tested when you show up at most hospitals to have a baby? Just as a headsup. Marijuana shows up on the tox screen. My sister in law found out the hard way. |
This is the important part where OP's argument falls apart. She did not ask. By the comments, everyone clearly knows routine for a woman includes pregnancy test. I can also bet that OP would be the first to file a malpractice suit if they didn't do the pregnancy test and there was a treatment given that could have harmed a fetus. The medical/health insurance industry sucks for many, many reasons, but patients like OP are exactly why many doctors hate their work. |