DP So wait -- the ED doc knew there needed to be immediate surgery, and they were going to do it themselves but decided to wait and talk to you a bit first before whipping out a scalpel? |
Well, not quite. The ER doc was essentially following a script rather than using his brain to evaluate the situation. Thankfully, I was moved to the OR in time to save my hand, but an orthopedic surgeon performed the surgery, not the ER doc. |
How did this simple question make a 17 page thread? I don't want to know. |
Because the simple answers were not acceptable. |
Please read what I wrote - The pregnancy test itself is not the issue, it is the lack of it being done without her knowledge. She should at least have the right to consent or decline. She would have consented of course, but should she not be allowed to have that right to decline? And she only found out about the test being run when she got her bill. It is an issue of rights, consent and principle. |
Did she consent to Urgent Care treating her? If so, then she consented to the tests they needed to diagnosis and/or treat the symptoms she presented. Why go to Urgent Care if you have already figured out that the illness is caused by X and not Y? Did she tell them, just test my urine for elevated levels of X but not for elevated levels of Y? There is a whole range of tests performed on a urine sample. Unless she is a medical doctor, who should choose which of those tests are appropriate? Since she did not know the cause of her illness, the medical staff needed to do the appropriate tests for a treatment plan. I'm sure she signed a consent form before they even saw her. |
Why is it so hard to understand that consenting to "the usual tests" does in fact include consenting to a pregnancy test? If she didn't want to consent to/pay for specific usual tests (pregnancy is a very very usual test!) she needed to ask for more details or specifically state "I do not consent to pregnancy test." She absolutely has the right to decline standard of care, and she chose to consent to it without asking for details. She could have asked for details and consented or rejected care based on those details. She did not ask for details but agreed to the tests. She consented. |
Omg the horse is dead. You weren’t even there. I can’t believe you are still claiming she didn’t consent. She DID!!!!!!! |
At the end of the day this is about the doctor's right to make sure they don't inadvertently kill a baby. You might not be lying, but a LOT of people lie in the ED. And a lot of people will swear they aren't pregnant because of a vasectomy or BC or their tubes are tied only to be the rare failure.
What I feel like a lot of posters here don't realize is how incredibly impactful pregnancy is to a woman. If you ARE pregnant, their are treatments that can kill you. Even if you don't care about the baby, the mother's health can be greatly impacted by pregnancy as well. It would have been negligent for them to NOT run an HCG on a 22 year old with abdominal pain. If they had not run the test but OP's daughter was in fact pregnant and something they did caused the baby to be injured, or perhaps OP's daughter crashed the next day because it was an ectopic, then the urgent care could be sued. Because it is a standard of care test that gives critical critical information about a woman's health. I had sinus surgery this spring and they ran a pregnancy test on my despite my tubes being out. Because the consequences of NOT KNOWING a woman is pregnant can easily be deadly, and the test is non invasive, there is basically no reason to not run it. |
Your DD is prime sex age. She had gastro issues. I don’t think this is a big deal.
Have you never watched a tv show where the girl comes in swearing she never had sex and she is like 6 months pregnant??? |
Right. It’s so ridiculous it’s funny. Also GIRL POWER poster is so focused on women giving their consent they can’t even see this is in the best interest of women. |
Isn’t insertion the actual definition of intercourse? I would have also assumed you could not get pregnant this way. Goes to show sometimes the patient just doesn’t know. |
This! |
It strikes me as obvious that the same people saying that a pregnancy test shouldn't be done routinely in this situation are the same ones that would RUN to an attorney if anything went wrong during treatment or surgery, assuming the patient was, in fact, pregnant. |
At this point *I* will pay the $37 if OP agrees to stop going on about it. |