Amazon is not paying any full-time drivers. It's gig work, no benefits. Is that the direction you think all jobs should head? Lowest-bidder, zero-protection, zero-accountability temp workers for everything? |
That’s the GOP way. |
Again, if the job were so terrible and compensation so bad, then no one would do the job. Yet people still do the job. That just goes to show you how vastly over compensated UPS drivers are. Amazon drivers do the same job for a fraction of the cost. Do you have a point? In our at will economy, people drive trucks for Amazon. So obviously the compensation is still fine. |
You can't compare flexible gig work to a full-time job! That's like saying that because some people take tutoring gigs, no one should be a teacher, or teachers should be paid the same hourly rate. Or no one should drive municipal busses, we should all just rely on Uber and Lyft as our sole means of transportation. |
You can piss and moan all you want. If Amazon's gig job compensation was so awful, then no one would do it. Yet people do it. Facts are facts. Amazon shows how much uneducated, unskilled labor used for driving trucks and delivering packages is truly worth. It's worth about $20-25/hr, not $50/hr or $80+/hr (if you count benefits) like UPS is paying. UPS is massively overpaying for the same labor that Amazon, DHL, regional parcel carriers, and FedEx all pay about $20-30/hr for. It's that simple. Again, people drive for Amazon, so clearly the pay is enough. We have an at will employment economy. People are free not to drive trucks for Amazon if the pay is too low, which will force Amazon to raise compensation. But they do drive trucks for Amazon. UPS is going to be hamstrung for years with massive labor costs they are going to make them uncompetitive. They'll be forced to raise prices or investment in the company will flee, which will limit their long term growth. Or they'll have to slash jobs. They will lose market share as they become less and less competitive. |
You're an awful person. There are many reasons people stay in or take on jobs with terrible benefits. Not because they think it's just fine. People deserve a living wage and to have health care and to be able to retire before they're 80. |
Where in the constitution does it say you deserve these things? |
They have a great pension and post-retirement healthcare.
Here's the thing though--they actually fail out/cut a lot of people during the driving training. |
I thought 170k was pennies to the people on this forum |
I don’t believe this. Do you have sources? My amazon driver is the same guy every day in the gray amazon sprinter van. I have no idea how that guy is coming to my house (sometimes 2x a day since my dd just had a birthday) daily and isn’t full time. I’ve seen him for over a year too. My UPS guy has been the same for at least 5 years. They work hard for their money. I say that the private sector should pay what they want to pay. Capitalism. What is wrong is when CEOs are making 40x what the average person makes. That’s the rot in the system. |
Do all jobs need to pay a living wage? I worked plenty of jobs between ages 16 and 24 when I started my career and graduated. I didn’t expect any of them to pay enough for me to live on. They were jobs to supplement and help me pay my tuition. Some jobs aren’t meant to be careers. And what is a livable wage anyways? I think the expectation should be that you have a spouse, partner or roommate to split living costs with. Working retail isn’t going to pay enough for you to afford a 3 bedroom apartment and be able to have kids on your own. 2 retail salaries might. |
NP and that is my understanding of how amazon works too. Some of it is gig work, some of it is Amazon subcontracting out with a license to use its brand on the vans. At one point Amazon was heavily subsidizing the van costs to build out its delivery network, not sure if that is still the case. |
We are a capitalist society. Wages are set by what the market will bear and by what the industry needs to pay in order to attract sufficient work force to handle the work load. Basically a derivative of supply and demand. Due to the pandemic and the explosion of on-line purchases and delivery, the need for package delivery staff has gone up. Right now, companies like UPS do not have enough drivers to handle the volume and ensure that delivery quotas and deadlines are met. So, they have to attract more staff and the only way to do that is to increase the salary and compensation offered. Useless educations do not need to be paid extra. Just because someone has some random useless LA degree, does not mean they deserve to be paid higher. Their degrees add nothing to their market value and employers are not required to pay people back for spending money on an education. I've seen people hired for essentially non-skilled or low-skilled positions and had two employees hired for the same position, but one with a college degree got a significant increase in offer over the one without a degree. Same job, same required skills. The degreed person does not deserve more, but got more because of stupid corporate policies that give bonus incentives to those with a degree. I think people who take difficult to fill positions for companies making a decent profit are worth more than people who happened to blow four years partying and taking courses in subjects that they'll never use and sit at a desk doing a job that makes no money, and just wastes time. There are thousands of random office workers who are completely replaceable and offer no additional skills or worth for their four years of Spanish and random liberal arts subjects. |
This is completely disingenuous. The physician is making a median salary for a pediatrician. That is the amount of salary they are paid and does not include benefits. That does not include health and dental benefits, long term care, paid time off, retirement benefits, and many more benefits. The UPS drivers are being paid $170K total compensation. They are paid $90K-102K in salary plus an additional $68-80K in benefits. The pediatrician is still being paid almost double what the driver is being paid. Plus, the drivers are getting extra as a hiring incentive. UPS does not have enough drivers and they have to offer more as an incentive to get more people to apply. This is no different than companies offering hiring bonuses for hard-to-fill positions. Frankly, there is not a huge shortage of pediatricians to fill open positions. While we could use more pediatricians, there aren't enough hospitals, clinics and practices that are hiring pediatricians relative to the number that are applying. There are more applicants than available positions right now. That is not true for drivers. |
A society full of haves and have-nots is an unstable society. It’s bad for the people who don’t earn enough to live comfortably, and it’s bad for the wealthy because they become in danger of revolt. Unfettered capitalism is dangerous for all of us. |