I can. There are so many parents at our school who have their kids in travel this and travel that but also want their kids in AAP. But then don't want homework and complain school is too hard. Because John has baseball practice five days a week you see. Kids can't do everything. |
I am not the PP but the truth is that the bright kids in ged ed could most likely handle AAP because AAP is an accelerated program and not necessarily a program for the gifted. My kid is in AAP and it honestly feels like what gen ed would have been a couple of decades ago. I have another one in level III services so she gets some services. I still supplement my kids math and writing bc I think ES is just lacking in FCPS. |
That is FCPS's issue with general ed though. If you want higher standards in general ed just push for them. What will happen is if the standards are decent people won't want to switch schools. Naturally people want to stay at their base school near kids within walking distance. |
Just like that huh? Pray tell, how so? |
If they could handle it, they'd be in it. FCPS isn't on a mission to screw a bunch of smart kids. |
At some elementary schools, all classes are taught with the AAP curriculum. There's some talk of expanding that to all elementary schools, the way some middle schools are all honors classes. So far, in those middle schools, that has been implemented by teaching all classes at an honors level and just leaving some students behind and upset, rather than by watering down the classes. |
Have you read the number of kids who are rejected from it in the AAP forum? Yes, bright kids are rejected from it with very high scores. And don't even get me started on the BS appeal process. It is pretty arbitrary and harder to get in at higher income schools. And my kid is in it and she is bright---but wouldn't say she is a genius. There I said it. This is what drivers me bonkers about some AAP parents. You refuse to look at any fault of the program. Saying there are issues is not the same as being anti-AAP or wanting to get rid of it. Somehow you see any criticism of it as an affront to you and your children. Talk about freaking insecurity. |
Teaching some of the AAP curriculum and moving at the pace of a regular AAP classroom are very different. My child is in AAP and his class did around 12 weeks of Caesar's English. Friend's classroom had one or two AART-led all-class sessions on the concept. School counts that as "teaching the AAP curriculum" to all, per teacher when asked. If there was an ES teaching AAP at AAP speed, everyone on this board would have already moved to the district. |
This is what FCPS used to do, before AAP was a thing and they had GT instead. It worked beautifully. Now, you're either AAP or Gen Ed, period. Ridiculous. |
Sure - for GIFTED kids. They make up a tiny fraction of the AAP masses. |
I'm sorry, but I frankly do not care if a LLIV kid isn't receiving *quite* the same level of instruction as a center class. Which I doubt, anyway. A teacher here already said they are receiving the same curriculum. As for equity vs equality, you never addressed the question of why some kids have two schools to choose from while others are stuck at one school. Not equitable OR equal. |
DP. You are everything that's wrong with AAP. If FCPS was still doing GT, no doubt *your* kid wouldn't make the cut. Because that program was actually for gifted learners. It's so funny that the current AAP crowd actually thinks all of their kids are gifted. |
Oh, please! AAP is not neurosurgery. That is completely laughable. DP |
All of this ^^^. The whole "Level 1/11/111" nonsense is just that - nonsense. FCPS has thrown labels on what is basically nothing to appease parents. In reality, if they simply taught the curriculum they used to teach, all kids would be receiving an advanced education. Those who need extra help would be able to get it, but the vast majority of kids could absolutely handle a step up in curriculum. They have dumbed things down so drastically in the last couple of decades that parents now think AAP actually equals "gifted." It does not. And I agree, ES is very much lacking in FCPS. High school is great, however. Middle school is two years of nothingness. |
But interestingly, AAP misses quite a few extremely smart kids. You can tell in high school by the number of kids who go on to excellent colleges, who were never in AAP back in elementary and middle. And the opposite is true, as well. Labeling kids so early in life does no one any favors. |