Sure. But imagine having to tell your 4.0 UW kid they need to go to MC and transfer to UMCP when their peers with lower stats got into UMCP while your kid was rejected. It stinks. And there’s a reason we have this same conversation on dcum year after year. |
| Guys, every college that matters (and even those that don’t based on the opinions on dcum) doesn’t care about weighted GPAs; it all gets recalculated. |
Yes, white. My daughter's friend that was rejected was Asian. The child that got in with a 3.0 was not white. I say all of this factually and without any feeling. |
+1000. It was obvious on Naviance/SCOIR what that line was for both my kids at their respective high schools. They were in the unpredictable middle. Their college counselors were clear UMD was a target/low reach. I’m biased as a parent that they were good high school students, they have high GPAs at competitive colleges, but it was clear that for UMD it could go either way. |
Unfortunately, this happens at a lot of univ. My kid was rejected at MIT: ORM male, 4.0/4.92 1580 SAT (one and done) from a magnet program. A classmate of theirs who was LGBTQ and a URM who struggled in their MVC class that they had together got into MIT. |
Kid rejected, huh? |
What does lgbtq have to do with it? My dd is as well and it is nowhere on the application. |
Every college has a range of GPAs and unless UMD has said 100% of their class has 4.0 UW, you have to assume kids get in with less than a 4.0 and some kids with a 4.0 don’t get in. I’m not sure what you’ve been telling your kids, but we’ve been clear from the beginning that UMD is tough, and even with high stats there are no guarantees. Have a back up plan whether that’s applying to colleges where you can get into the honors program and/or merit or be willing to go to CC and transfer. The other thing is your kid should have safety schools on their list that they are willing to attend and the family can afford. So if they truly have safeties they are actually willing to attend, they should have already reconciled that they could be at a school where other kids didn’t have a 4.0 coming in and that also might be lower on prestige than where some of their classmates with lower GPAs end up. |
They can also go to one or the other strong Maryland public colleges or universities. If they want to live away from home, and their stats are competitive for MD they can look at private options with good merit. If they want to commute from home and don’t like whatever schools are within commuting distance, they can also look at local private schools with good merit. |
Bless your heart. We know this. But you don’t understand what some of us are frustrated with when it comes to the ridiculously unpredictable admissions process at UMCP that seems to disproportionately impact a certain group of applicants. |
Nope. Kids had zero interest in staying local. They are out of state broadening their horizons rather than doing mcps 2.0 at UMCP. But I follow this stuff closely for a variety of reasons (including professional reasons). I still think UMCP offers a top notch education at a good price point. I’m definitely not a hater. In fact, we have season tix for two sports and are routinely on campus. |
Of course it's frustrating for so many MCPS students and families! It's just the way it is, and it will be that way until UMBC/Towson/etc grow in regard. I imagine people in NJ feel the same about Rutgers. They have a similar sized population and one highly regarded flagship. |
I agree this is wrong. I’m from a state where any decent student gets into the state flagship. What MD is doing to their top students is just wrong. |
|
In for letters and sciences but not biochem as
applied. 1370 MCPS, 3.91/4.69. Unlikely to be our first choice in the end but nice to have. |
| According to Bethesda Magazine, 32% of those who applied to UMCP were accepted from the top Bethesda area high schools. Compare that to my daughter's Bethesda area private school, where 54% are accepted. The sad part is the majority do not matriculate there because they are more interested in private universities and can afford them. In my opinion, UMCP should be more discriminating with private school applicants, but I suspect that is not feasible. Clearly these students are just checking the box to apply. For my daughter, Maryland was considered a "very likely" despite everyone claiming it is such a hard school to get into. Doesn't seem fair to me. |