No…it’s just not a social school so it’s silly to include it with BC and Wake. |
Vanderbilt down 1, Cornell and Columbia up 1. I feel like your DC is at Vandy because that doesn't make sense. Drop BU, Tufts, NYU, USC, and Wake Forest. |
It does not |
I really don't know why people say at my private as if your anecdotal evidence, that may be a lie, matters. Emory along with Georgetown have the wealthiest applicants in the country, that's a fact. BC,Tufts do not come close. |
Wealthiest? Who cares? |
May be a lie? Lady, Emory is seen as distinctly not fun by most kids, and the kids who go there from our private are those who aren’t in the top twenty percent of the class, but desperately want to go to a T25 so they apply and get in ED1. If that’s what your kid wants, go for it. |
Take out BU and it’s perfect as is. Columbia lost a lot of value with all the bad press from the protests. Made the administration look hapless and the students like a bunch of misfits. |
I am curious this idea of “not fun” as once you remove big time sports, trying to understand why/how Emory is “distinctly not fun” compared to every other academic D3 school (and many academic D1 schools). It has a fairly active Greek scene, on campus clubs/theatre, activities in Atlanta, a quick Uber to plenty of hopping parts of Atlanta, etc. As an example, I rarely hear much about how Columbia university offers much in the way of “fun” but rather its NYC location provides the fun. |
It’s dismaying how many kids are pressured to compromise their college choices by committing to an ED choice like Emory (or any other college) for all the wrong reasons. That being said, I don’t think everyone at Emory applied their ED out of “desperation” to be at a T-25. |
Why do you guys care so much?!? |
It's not 1980 anymore. The world is bigger than the Ivy League. I'd leave Vanderbilt where it is and add Rice to the second tier. But agree that BU, NYU, Tufts, USC, and Wake Forest should be dropped all together from this ranking. And if you're going to include them in SLACs, I'd also move West Point and Annapolis up. Wellesley down. |
Private top tier: HYPSM
Private second tier: Brown, Cal Tech, Chicago, Duke, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, Penn, Columbia Private third tier: Carnegie Mellon, Cornell, Emory, Georgetown, Notre Dame, NYU, Rice, USC (Southern Cal), Washington U (St. Louis), Vanderbilt, Dartmouth Public top tier: Michigan (Ann Arbor), UC Berkeley, UCLA Public second tier: Florida, Georgia Tech, Illinois - Urbana Champaign, North Carolina (UNC Chapel Hill), Texas (UT Austin), UC Davis, UC Irvine, UCSB, UCSD, William & Mary, Wisconsin, Virginia (UVA) Public third tier: Many... like 30 SLAC top tier: Amherst, Pomona, Swarthmore, Wellesley, Williams SLAC second tier: Bowdoin, Carleton College, Claremont McKenna, Middlebury, Smith, US Military Academy - West Point, US Naval SLAC third tier: Barnard, Bates, Colby, Colgate, Davidson, Hamilton, Haverford, Richmond, US Air Force Academy, Wesleyan |
Zero school spirit, partially due to no football or other spectator sports, and a good number of not particularly social kids. Emory is hardly unique in this respect but it isn’t particularly popular for this reason. Loses cross admits to USC, Tufts, Wake, NYU, Wash U, Vandy per Parchment, which is quite funny as some on this board put much weight on its US News ranking. Actual students prefer some lower ranked schools. |
Once your kid’s school’s college T-Shirt day rolls around, I’ll bet that most of the kids won’t care about who got into T-25’s, T-50’s, who got their first choice, who’s going to a safety, etc. they’ll be looking ahead to prom, graduation, etc. Come August-September, the worry will have shifted to “will be they be happy and thrive at their college”? Too bad this shift or thinking doesn’t happen a year earlier, at the beginning of senior year. |
This is fairer, but I still don't hink USC and NYU belong there. And I don't see why if you're making undergrad tiers you would separate publics and LACs. Tier 1 Harvard, Yale, Princeton, MIT, Stanford Tier 2 Cal Tech, Chicago, Duke, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, Penn, Columbia, Brown, Dartmouth Tier 3 Carnegie Mellon, Cornell, Emory, Georgetown, Notre Dame, Rice, Washington U (St. Louis), Vanderbilt, Williams, Amherst, Berkeley Tier 4 Pomona, Swarthmore, Wellesley, UCLA, UMich, UVA, UNC, USC, NYU, BC, Gatech, Bowdoin, Navy, CMC, Tufts Sorry if I missed a few. |