Forum Index
»
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)
Please! The 300K post was most likely trolling and you actually agree with that alarmist nonsense. First of all, WJ today is not some amazing school that drives property values. It is weaker than other W schools and not much better than, for example, Richard Montgomery that has similar demographics to Woodward options 1,2 and 4. Second, it is not all about the quality of high schools. Garret Park and Tilden will still have mostly the same teachers and same kids going there. So if parents were happy with what they were getting with these two schools before, there is no reason to suddenly completely turn their backs. Even more importantly, Garret Park and Tilden neighborhoods are very safe and walkable, a rare combination that will not change with the new school. Every responsible new home buyer in the last two years knew that the rezoning is coming and that for some neighborhoods (for example Old Georgetown Village and Timberlawn) it will be a miracle not to end up in the new HS. And yet, home prices in that area went up by more than 15%. |
Options 2 and 3 are the only ones that optimize utilization. They others assume MCPS will spend MORE money to build out Edison |
Is there a document that says they intend to build out Edison under options 1 and 4? Or how are you reaching that conclusion? |
I can understand about home purchases near WJ and Woodward. But the boundary study extends to rezoning homes far away from it. The more an option does that the more complaints there will about property values. |
What do people have against medium-FARMS schools? Like, I get why folks would be nervous about high FARMS schools (and why white families might be hesitant about schools that are less than 10% white), but are there reasons (besides racism-- trying to give people the benefit of the doubt here) that medium FARMS schools with racial diversity reflective of the county are a problem too? We are a white middle-class family in a medium-FARMS elementary focus school with about 30% white kids, currently zoned for middle and high schools with similar demographics, and it all seems pretty great so far to us. Genuinely wondering why it would be so terrible for Woodward to be medium-FARMS instead of low-FARMS? |
Both of those options result in 20% overcrowding at Wheaton. In the meetings, the consultants have said there is a "shell space" at Edison that can be finished to absorb that capacity. Several posters have identified issues with this, including the time it takes Wheaton students to walk to Edison given the size of Wheaton HS, as well as the fact that capital projects like this one take years just to get funded. This year, the Council dug into the retiree health fund to pay for MCPS's budget request. There is not extra money for this when other high schools have space. |
People are upset their property values might go down. Regardless of whether individuals are racist, home values in MoCo differ in part due to perceived school quality and fears about Black and Latino youth. |
Thank you for that synopsis. Since Option 3 looks like a non starter based on busing kids away from walk zones, option 2 seems to be the one that solves utilization. But upthread it was suggested that the major downside is many split articulations in Option 2. (My kids would not be impacted in that way so I’m taking DCUM’s word for it.) |
+1 The Woodward option worked because there was an existing building, that MCPS already owned, centrally located in the county. As much as I want a downcounty school to serve TkPk/SS inside the Beltway, the only property recently available was 1) not for sale; 2) not already owned by MCPS; 3) not appropriate in its current form for a school. |
....and some folks have been proposing the State of Jefferson for 50 years, but that's not going to happen either. |
| Option 3 is batshit. |
No, this is incorrect. Current Tilden families with students THAT CURRENTLY WALK (and you are right that it is safe and lovely) would be bussed A LONG WAY to other middle schools under some of the option. |
I imagine they could adjust options 1 and 4. It would require split articulation, but Option 1 has no split articulation so adding one split articulation is not the end of the world. |
That’s not actually the issue. The issue is for neighborhoods who basically figured they would go to Woodward (as they are within the walk zone for Woodward) are getting bused to Wheaton and Kennedy, while current Wheaton and Kennedy (maybe Einstein too) are bused into Woodward. |
Maybe some will but they would not be speaking for all WJ parents. In fact, the WJ PTA cluster testimony has always made it clear that they support reopening Woodward for WJ AND DCC. |