Yes it does. And if you have to ask... youre not meant to know about it. |
Those are old money and WASP adjacent but true WASPs are rooted on the east coast, occasionally in certain glamorous west coast cities like San Francisco or Los Angeles. Midwestern German stock white people with their green bean casseroles are not WASP culture (though there are many similarities and lots of overlap) |
What about these descriptions is “peculiar and amazingly rigid and narrow?” Would you prefer if we said Snoop Dog was also a WASP? Or perhaps just Martha Stewart would do? |
I agree with this assessment. I would, however, say that many WASPs stepped away from the Ivies (about a generation ago) because they realized they were a bad investment. I think Jews are reluctantly coming around to that same position, too. |
Gee, this doesn't sound biased at all 🤔 I guess I could fire back some fairly rude assessments of Jews and start praising WASPs but I have a feeling that wouldn't be allowed. Although I agree with you the groups are NOT similar in the slightest. |
This is funny. WASPs moved away from the Ivies because we can't get in anymore! Everyone through our fathers went to HYP, then my generation (Gen X) could barely get in unless we played squash or rowed, so we ended up at NESCAC schools. Now our own kids can't get into those and are prevalent at Bucknell, Dennison and the like. It's a sad downward spiral. |
Go for it! I think those stereotypes are right on, especially about the food. Go to a wealthy WASPy wedding and a wealthy Jewish one. Compare the food and get back to me. Yes, the WASPy wedding will be beautiful and have amazing flowers and decor, but for some reason, they are going to scrimp on the food. The Jews will leave the flowers out, if need be, but not the food. Also, the big elephant in the room difference was left out: Jews are far less likely than WASPs to have an alcohol problem. Your turn… |
I'm Jewish and attended a very Waspy New England boarding school. Jews are much more clique-y, Wasps are intensely individualistic to the point of loneliness. Jews can err into gaudiness, Wasps cling to LL Bean/J Crew uniform.
I think the drinking happens in both communities. |
Alrighty... since you've asked me to... grasping strivers, loud, new money, ostentatious, pushy/mannerless, cliquey/not welcoming to outsiders, horrible food (gefilte fish?! WTF), trashy, etc. I will say that as much as you say people dont like WASP weddings, many people pay big bucks to get married in "WASPy" locations with a "WASP" style (which is kind of derived from English style). Not many people getting married in chuppahs despite being Filipino, IJS. Anyway... each group can have their own judgements of their others. |
Agreed, but it was because your parents didn’t feel like paying extra to help you get in. Just as you WISELY don’t feel like doing that for your kids. If you really wanted to, you could find a way to make it happen, but you don’t even bother thinking about it. The Ivies now take that kinda money from foreign students and governments. You’re not missing much. |
The initial comment that you took offense to called Jews “frank,” “direct” and “loud.” Those were polite euphemisms. But I suppose that it makes you feel classier to spell it out “grasping strivers” and “trashy?” I said point blank that WASPy weddings are aesthetically beautiful. It’s just that I make a point of eating before I go to one. With a Jewish wedding, I get a workout in first. Don’t even get me started on the lavishness that is an Indian wedding…but I digress. Also, practically every wedding I’ve gone to in the last decade has the bride being given away by both of her parents per Jewish tradition. I’m not sure why you’re so offended by the descriptions of WASPs. I don’t see them to be very mean at all. |
Yes, they called Jews "frank, direct, and loud vs reserved, inhibited, discreet, quiet. Warm with family and throw big parties vs cold and don't serve enough food." Clearly biased, as my previous comment said and whoever replied (you?) said you'd like to hear my honest assessment and that WASPs also have alcohol problems. So a second ago you wanted people to "go for it" and be honest but now that someone was you're offended? |
Don't forget that within Jewish culture there is a distinct difference between German Jews and Polish/Eastern European Jews, and then the Sephardics of the Mediterranean and North Africa worlds. |
I don’t think the initial comment by a different poster is biased at all. I think it’s very accurate on all counts. I’m also not remotely offended by your comment. I think you’re quite funny. Why? Because while championing their cause, you don’t come across as politely WASPy in the least, nor do you have the coolheaded WASPy demeanor, the kind that built this country. Nope, instead you are seem to be deeply offended by WASPs being called “discreet” and “reserved,” which is not only not inoffensive but, also very true. Keep it coming! And please don’t tell me you’re a bot, I’ll be disappointed. |
I'm glad you're not offended. And thanks for proving my point that your stereotypes about WASPs, the WASPs you THINK you know and are so pleased to have figured out, are completely wrong. Maybe they are "cold" and "reserved" with YOU and that's for a reason. I guarantee the conversations are different in private, when youre not around. That's the politest way I can say it. Have a good one. |