I have more than enough information to know that masking is important and that we're in a surge that should last for a few weeks. I also don't buy into some notion that we should throw our hands in the air and give up completely on trying to prevent spread because of a few special snowflakes. So what's your point because I don't see one. |
I agree with you but they are taking off masks to eat, which basically erases the risk budget. Fundamentally, we just need to stop testing exposure and only test symptomatic for folks who might require antivirals. And I was a strident lockdown, mask, advocate and I actually hoped we would have a rapid test way out (AM test every day for daily clear passport) but that is where we are. |
Dear god some of you will just never stop. You know all the things about all the people all the time and how everyone should behave. Insufferable. Calling the kid with the glasses a snowflake a couple times is also obnoxious and not as funny as you think it is. |
My kids eat outside at school except in severe weather. Masking is still really helpful. Even if they do eat inside, there's a huge difference to being exposed all day and just for 30 minutes at lunch. The odds of transmission go up with duration of exposure. Unmasking at lunch doesn't erase the benefit of masking the rest of the day. |
Have you really never heard of science? We know how covid is transmitted. One kid with glasses doesn't change the science, nor whether the community should try to stop the spread to keep people healthy. We've also been wearing masks for more than a year now. If you can't sort how to wear a mask with glasses, then you haven't tried very hard. Signed, glasses wearer. |
Special snowflake is in reference to the PP's view that her daughter is so special that public health policies need to change so her daughter's glasses don't fog. |
But the glasses wearing snowflake IS following public health policy. The mask are still optional last I checked. I believe the point was worry about yourself. |
So the science says with good vaccines and anti virals in play and a community with low hospitalization and death rates, children in school need to mask to as near zero as covid as we can get? I think that's what you say, not what science says. CDC doesn't even say kids need to mask in a medium transmission County. CDC says if you are at high risk for severe illness, talk to your health care provider about whether you should wear a mask. But wait, I know. CDC doesn't follow the science. You do. |
You know that asymptomatic carriers also spread covid, right? Testing helps prevent further spread, but according to you it's useless. That's bonkers to me. Really do not understand why you are against a measure that is so easy and helps prevent spread. And agree with others that a half hour of maskless exposure at lunchtime (and for many kids that exposure is outside!) does not undo the good that comes from masking indoors all day. It's like saying that if someone is going to smoke 1 cigarette a day, they might as well smoke two packs. That's not the way risk works. |
Dr. Duran also sent out an email to parents today suggesting and requesting mask use from kids during this surge, fwiw. |
He did that several weeks ago too. I don't think APS has much credibility left when it comes to handling this pandemic. If it wasn't for the state of VA we would have not had a full year of in-person school and there would still be a mask mandate and probably one for as long as covid exists on this planet. |
You were doing okay until this part. The bolded is your opinion. It's not science. Clearly not everyone agrees on what lengths a community should go to in order to stop the spread of covid and in fact it's shifted over time in most places We've seen that across the world. |
It makes zero sense for kids to go unmasked to school during a period of high or substantial transmission, like we are having now. It’s great that hospitals aren’t full but we’re essentially intentionally infecting kids with this virus now. That is not a great public health strategy and I think the CDC really messed up and got it wrong, giving into political pressure regarding masks. We could have done more to keep kids safe and healthy, especially just as more information comes out about long-term effects of COVID infection on children. |
What is the more information? I would be interested to see any controlled studies. Not just media coverage of anecdotes. The only controlled studies I have seen say it’s rare in kids and resolves. But would genuinely be interested to see additional info. |
Increased pediatric diabetes in children post-COVID is one example. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7102e2.htm https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2788283 |