Nothing in that story contradicts and in actual fact that story supports the conclusion of all studies that have been conducted on this subject that have concluded that helmets reduce the head injuries and death. Your continued insistence to knowingly claim otherwise is sick, wrong and amoral. You should be ashamed of yourself. |
It is neither binary nor contingent. Both are good and both can be done independently. |
I would say that "all" is overly broad. There's also a question of benefit vs. cost. What is clear is that the benefit of wearing a helmet is limited -- and there has been a long history of people in the public health and traffic safety business grossly over-stating that benefit. Google "bullet stopped by bible." There are thousands of stories of people believing that their lives were saved when a bullet became embedded in a bible they were carrying. Should we encourage people to carry bibles as a public health measure? Strapping a bible to your head is probably marginally less effective than wearing a bike helmet. If bike helmets were designed like motorcycle helmets they would probably provide measurable benefit. The government is already in the business of mandating standards for bike helmets, why don't they use the same standards as motorcycle helmets? Because no one would wear them, because they would be too uncomfortable. |
|
The obvious solution, and end-game for cyclists, is to ban cars for the safety of bike riders.
“You don’t NEED a helmet if there are no cars to hit you”. |
You are the equivalent of an anti-vaccine nut job. |
A motorcycle goes a bit faster than a bicycle. Energy goes up as speed squared. Some people don't wear helmets on motorcycles, we call them organ donors. |
| When do we start concern trolling about kids at skateparks who don’t wear helmets? Kids skiing? Kids ice skating? |
I think those already exist but are less vocal because skate parks and I’ve rinks rarely threaten car drivers’ ability to drive dangerously. |
Except the difference is that vaccines are effective and bike helmets aren't. |
Interestingly, the CPSC standards for ski helmets and skate helmets are the same as for bike helmets. In the winter I wear a ski helmet cycling because it keeps my head warmer. |
It would be okay to be this stupid if you were not making knowingly false statements that have the outcome of hurting people. That makes you a sociopath and yeah, you are no better than the anti-vax nut jobs. |
Over-inflating the benefits of helmets is just as bad from a public health perspective as minimizing them. That's why the CDC and NHTSA were forced to take the misleading statements off of their websites. To the extent helmets have a protective benefit, it's so small as to be almost immeasurable. There's a reason that despite 30+ years of concerted effort to find that benefit, it remains elusive. |
If you can't debate the message, attack the messenger. |
You have proven to be intransigent when confronted with evidence of helmets working https://www.consumerreports.org/head-injuries/most-cyclists-who-suffer-head-injuries-arent-wearing-helmets-a9629801958/ |
Consumer Reports? Really? |