Whatever the federal government says doesn't override the basic principle that studies with control groups are superior to studies without, especially when it comes to such poorly defined syndromes as Long Covid, where studies largely have to rely on subjective reporting. That's not something some poster on an anonymous forum wants you to believe, it's what any scientist would confirm. Long Covid studies with control groups have consistently shown little difference in reported symptoms between patients with confirmed infection and those without. |
+1 "Trauma" may be too strong a word (but it's quite common today to use the term loosely), but children certainly have had a lot taken away from them these past two years, and their lives have been restricted in ways we haven't seen in more than a generation. Also, we know exactly that the PPs who are jumping all over this poster are likely the types who will deny any costs and negative impacts of masks on children, just like they denied the severely negative impacts of virtual schooling (or blamed them all on the parents). I'm not sure if it is a lack of empathy or just tribal blindness. |
I have two friends with kids that have had severe mental health issues based on the pandemic. It's troubling that these get erased, or blamed on parents, particularly when major medical groups have discussed the mental health crises facing kids. The need to minimize these problems (inclusive of critiquing the descriptive words used, to suggest they are 'too much') in my opinion just continues to exacerbate the harms to children. |
+ 100 the pro maskers forever will stoop as low as needed to legitimize their own mental challenges. |
Maybe because there wasn't a novel virus spreading that they'd be at severe risk from catching? |
My kids aren't going to be competitive for college sports whether they get covid now or not. And I already have a lifelong chronic disease that'll take 10 to 20 years off my life expectancy whether I get long covid or not. So yes, it's true, I don't really think about those factors. Everyone in our family has had as many doses of the vaccine as the CDC has authorized for them to take, and now we don't require our kids to wear masks at school while transmission in our community is quite low. If rates go back up, we'll change that. |
So this Twitter thread does not make it easy to read the studies linked, and frankly, I don't trust "Twitter threads" as a source of information. This person doesn't seem to have any relevant background; they seem to be in "generative music" and machine learning. So forgive me if I don't appreciate their interpretations. What I need to know is whether "long COVID" occurs with a greater frequency and severity than any other post-viral syndromes, which are completely normal. Like, I do not care about a 10% chance of anosmia for a few months. |
But why was no one insisting that preK kids wear face masks in 2019? They were more at risk then from RSV and flu than they are now from those two plus COVID. And no one was screeching about the fact that, for gods sake, the kids aren’t vaccinated yet from RSV, so how can anyone with a conscience unmask anywhere? |
Lol imagine people learning new information to make different decisions in the future. |
I do wonder this exactly. |
…so are you saying everyone should have been masking? Do you understand the amount of masking that would require? |
Agreed. The author of the quoted thread is a Long Covid patient, who has founded a patient-led research initiative. Hardly a background of medical expertise, and one that doesn't put you in the best position to make unbiased assessments. The systematic meta-analysis by British infectious disease experts linked above is a much better source. |
|
Check out this hot take:
https://twitter.com/DCWard7teacher/status/1506263972273692676?s=20&t=MJh2i7FJVTsAjfb2hgMVyg #NoFuchsLeftToGive |
| when I get a notification that there's a case in my kid's school, I'm glad my kid's still wearing a mask. (As far as I can tell.) |
This just makes me sad. One of my kids is scared to take off his mask because he’s scared of his teacher (a whole separate issue, yes). Incidentally, he was the one of my two kids who came home sick last week, despite the whole class masking. |