Downton Abbey February 8, 2015 SPOILERS

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:MyDH watches and asks rude questions or makes comments about how hot Mary is, how pathetic Edith is, what a pompous twit Lord Grantham is, and why I would dump him in a Downtonw Abbey minute for Dr Clarkson.

Gotta give it to your DH when it comes to LG. He is a total twit.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:My DH doesn't watch either. I don't mind.

I don't either. I like watching by myself - otherwise, I'd have to constantly explain the backstories to him. It's just not his thing, and that's ok with me.

[Anonymous]

I know it's "just a TV show" but it was so upsetting to see Edith just walk in and take Marigold away from the Drewe family. As an adopted child, I felt sick to see the adoptive parents here treated like they were not "real" parents. I can only imagine how unbearably traumatic it would have been for me to be ripped away from my home and family at Marigold's age. What Edith did to her daughter and the Drewe family was far, far worse than anything Mary has ever done to Edith. I can't sympathize with or root for Edith anymore. Giving birth doesn't make you a mother. Mrs. Drewe was Marigold's mother. And the fact that Mrs. Drewe said something kind about Edith to the child in the midst of her own extreme heartbreak was the perfect illustration of who actually loves the child and puts her first.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I know it's "just a TV show" but it was so upsetting to see Edith just walk in and take Marigold away from the Drewe family. As an adopted child, I felt sick to see the adoptive parents here treated like they were not "real" parents. I can only imagine how unbearably traumatic it would have been for me to be ripped away from my home and family at Marigold's age. What Edith did to her daughter and the Drewe family was far, far worse than anything Mary has ever done to Edith. I can't sympathize with or root for Edith anymore. Giving birth doesn't make you a mother. Mrs. Drewe was Marigold's mother. And the fact that Mrs. Drewe said something kind about Edith to the child in the midst of her own extreme heartbreak was the perfect illustration of who actually loves the child and puts her first.

I am not adopted and I felt the horror of that moment. I felt for Mrs. Drewe.

[Anonymous]

I thought it was horrific too. But Marigold had not been adopted by the Drewes. It was more of a foster child arrangement. This doesn't lessen what Edith dif

[Anonymous]

It was never really clear to me how long Marigold had been with the Drewe's. Because she had been with the Swiss family for a while too, right? They made some comment about poor Mrs. so and so, but how she was able to adopt another child. (And if anyone read the recent story about Swiss work farms for children, makes you glad to get Marigold out of there. It wasn't all chocolate and cuckoo clocks, apparently, in pre-war Switzerland.)

Honestly, I'm not sure how much it would really affect Marigold. If I got hit by a bus on the way home today, my 4 year old would be upset for a little while, but if I was replaced by a loving mother, I bet it would have no long term impact on her.

And, keep in mind that this was a long time before "In the Best Interests of the Child" was written...no one really thought in those terms back then, so we can't really expect Edith to. They used to put orphans on trains and put them up for auction at train stops along the way.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I know it's "just a TV show" but it was so upsetting to see Edith just walk in and take Marigold away from the Drewe family. As an adopted child, I felt sick to see the adoptive parents here treated like they were not "real" parents. I can only imagine how unbearably traumatic it would have been for me to be ripped away from my home and family at Marigold's age. What Edith did to her daughter and the Drewe family was far, far worse than anything Mary has ever done to Edith. I can't sympathize with or root for Edith anymore. Giving birth doesn't make you a mother. Mrs. Drewe was Marigold's mother. And the fact that Mrs. Drewe said something kind about Edith to the child in the midst of her own extreme heartbreak was the perfect illustration of who actually loves the child and puts her first.

I am not adopted and I felt the horror of that moment. I felt for Mrs. Drewe.

+10000

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:My main irritation is that my DH will not watch it; he says it's like watching a rock garden grow.

I love this. It's kind of true. My DH doesn't watch DA but he watched the Julian fellows P&P with me.