I feel like AACPS would have been better served to start the year hybrid (for those who elected this model) and then pivot to virtual for everyone if the case numbers rose in Nov/Dec. That way, folks would have already been settled into their "cohorts" and could easily switch back to hybrid and in-person in the spring if conditions allows. So it feels like AACPS may have missed the window for this, as starting hybrid at the end of Nov may not work well. Having said that, my kids have been going to their AACPS school every day for online learning and it's been great. There are 12 kids in their group and three folks from the County help them if there are issues. They eat lunch at the school and then play on the playground for over an hour each day during lunch. We've been going since Sept 8 and there have been zero issues or outbreaks. So I feel very comfortable transitioning to the hybrid model at this point. |
Six is better than none. I don't know why this would disrupt anyone's holiday plans. Are people really staying in their houses 100% still? I see soccer games, kids at parks, kids at stores, what is the difference? I have two kids, one in private high school and one in public. I can definitively say that having them in a classroom with a live teacher is much more beneficial for any length of time. If children who choose all virutal are with a new teacher, I get the disruption, but when there is a large cohort of virtural learners who are not also kids in the classroom, the coursework may be given on a different schedule or pace. The two hour learning break, for one. This may not happen with the kids who are on the hybrid but at home. Who knows? Many unanswered questions which will need to be addressed, but progress is progress. And as for mask compliance issues, I know that there will always be a risk to someone's mask coming down under their noses or messing with them all day. Unless you keep your child home 100% of the time (in which you should do virutal learning), these things are happening out there daily. I have to correct my child on her mask placement and yes, it's a pain, but she does it when she notices. She's back in school and there have been zero cases in her Upper School. I think change is scary and transition is tough. Those of us who have one child in private have seen it work out, so it's simply not as scary. For the record, we are keeping our kids home the week of Thanksgiving for an extra two days so we can see grandma without worrying a lot. We have the option to be in the virutal cohorts for days we are not in school for our oldest. It's a way to do so without losing ground academically. I hope that can be the case for public schools as well. For so many who don't have stay at home parents or who are strugglin wtih virtual learning, those six days can be a god send. To those who don't want to go back, there are options while the options, granted, include more change. |
Yes, that's true. But it sounds like the classes are going to be much smaller, because students who opt for virtual only will be assigned to a new teacher, making the hybrid cohort smaller. |
I wish they would have rolled this out in September too. The cases were dropping and other schools pivoted while it seemed like the county was inflexible with the decision to do virtual. Now the cottage industry of school based virtual learning centers have filled the gap and shown that kids can congegrate to do learning, on chromebooks, with masks and outbreaks have been limited at best. It's a plan which has been proven relatively safe and effective in the centers and in private schools. |
PP here. No, Not 100% sure. It seems to be the big question that people are throwing around on social media. Most assuming it's a done deal. In all honesty, if they can do a better virutal schedule and help more fully with tech issues and learning content which is better for at home instruction with the new virutal school set up, I think it will be a bonus to have children doing virutal in a separate 'school'. Everyone is jumping to the negative without looking at what is good about hybrid: Smaller class sizes Less transitional time between classrooms/cafeteria Mask wearing which reduces cold and covid Chromebooks now for every child (hopefully, all will be issued one) It's not ideal but in a pandemic, nothing is. I'm thankful it's forward movement. When they can get the full class together, some of these things may not change back. |
| They should just have young kids back full-time, with a full-time DL option for people that aren't comfortable with that. The risk difference between hybrid and full-time doesn't seem that significant. |
Before I see my elderly parents? Yes, yes I am staying in my house for two weeks. |
I'm not sure what point you are making. Should schools remain closed so that you can see your elderly parent? |
I posted above about our experience with private. I have a kids in both public and private and I agree that you really need to start small, see how it works, and then build on that. One of my concerns about hybrid was that I didn't want to play a role in forcing teachers back into the building. When we first had the opportunity to come onto the campus, I spoke with several teachers about this. They described how starting small (short days, different cohorts, reinforcing masking and other rules about hand hygiene and social distancing) with the youngest learners was helpful in allaying their fears about returning to in-person learning. There will always be doubts. I absolutely had them as a parent. But if we take a cautious approach and see how it goes, we might find that it isn't as scary as we think. I also agree with the PPs who said that it would have made more sense to take risks at the beginning of the school year and planned for shutting down around the holiday months. But what's done is done. At minimum, if they can get a few kids back in person before Thanksgiving they will have some useful experience to draw on in the Spring, even if the entire population winds up shifting back to DL during the winter months. |
Why do you think there will be smaller classes? That's why the talked about hybrid kids maybe having new teachers too. They're going to rebalance everything. They'll need teachers to teach the virtual classes, and ~12 kids in each cohort. So once they know who is going where, they'll make groups for the virtual teacher and adjust the in person classes so each cohort has 10-12 kids, so the teacher will still have ~24 kids, even if some of them are new to her. This assumes, of course, there isn't a mass-exodus out of the district, which I don't expect despite the angst going on today. |
|
I think the point about the bad timing of the holidays isn't for the sake of the people traveling, but about the risk those people bring to the classroom.
Is Larlo and family want to go visit great grandma in Tampa for Thanksgiving, they very well may quarintine for two weeks before hand. And if Larlo misses his first in person class because of that, that's fine. But what happens when Larlo gets back? Does he stay home for two more weeks or does he go to school on November 30, complete with whatever he picked up in Tampa? There will ABSOLUTELY be kids who travel out of state and then come to school the next day. While this is a risk at any time, it's exponentially greater by starting November 30. |
I understand this, and would have no problem if schools went all virtual for the two weeks after Thanksgiving. Concern over travel exposure is not a good reason not to try to get some kids back into the classroom if they can keep the numbers small enough to allow social distancing. |
Right... if you are not comfortable, simply don't send your kid back. Stay virtual. Problem solved! Nobody is forcing you to return. |
+1. We have to start somewhere if we ever want kids to return to school in person. If we don't take this step, what step would be appropriate? We have to focus on making progress. |
|
The teachers are making it seem like this is a death march to the inevitable hardship of awful education as if the last month hasn't been overwhelming and ineffective for many parents. What is the deal. It's only K-2 and it's a hybrid schedule.
Working without a contract? Well, I think the board knows where the teachers stand so why even negotiate at this point. Keep posting memes about how 'scary' life will be behind chromebooks with masks on -- as if 60% of kids aren't in virtual learning centers or pods doing that anyway.
|