I am not a scientist, lol. But i wonder if there is some additional side effect that makes the risk of psychotic episodes/aggression/suicide/self harm/depression (all listed by the drug companies as possible side effects to those drugs) amplified by the surge of testosterone that boys naturally get during that phase of puberty around the later teen years to early 20s. So instead of self harm, suicide, depression, etc they end up with uncontrollable rage/violence bursts/psychosis towards others. Because these kinds of kids are more likely to take these kinds of drugs, it makes it appear that it is the disorder causing the mass shootings, when in reality it is a side effect of the drugs. |
All the antidepressants come with a warning about paradoxical reactions like suicidal ideation and increased anxiety, so the parents should always monitor their kids for any changes and call the doctor immediately if there is a change. That said, depressed and anxious kids are at higher risk either way, but the risk with antidepressants is much lower than the risk without them. |
I don't know. Cho (VT shooter) was apparently not being treated for his psychiatric problems. Adam Lanza's mom may not have been able to manage his medication - I read somewhere that he had retreated to his bedroom, blacked out his windows and was communicating with his mom via the internet. I think that some of this is due to the fact that these are normal, regular parents trying to handle severe psychiatric illnesses all by themselves with no training, no support, little guidance. |
One possibility is that a kid who is being treated for depression is actually bipolar, but never had a prior manic episode. In that case, a manic episode can come on suddenly and since the parents have never seen anything like it before, they don't know how to respond. |
Not automatic. Semiautomatic. http://www.app.com/story/news/crime/jersey-mayhem/2018/01/02/long-branch-shooting-bill-keeping-guns-kids-stalled/995087001/ |
State of Connecticut wrote a report on Lanza. It's a case study of what not to do with an autistic kid. He was obsessed with violence and was not being properly treated. He was not recieving therapy or medication at the time and he was clearly showing signs of depression as he corresponded about his obsession on the internet. His mother allowed him to isolate himself for years despite professional advice not to do that. The schools did not fulfill their positive duty to identify and address all areas of educational need. And despite his obsession with violence (which his mother may not have fully appreciated) she gave him access to her guns and taught him how to shoot. |
My response earlier isn't intended to say that these drugs don't help people- I have friends who have said that anti-depressants have literally save their lives-- but I think you are spot on that these parents are trying to manage mental illness without enough support. I *cannot* imagine leaving a gun unsecured with kids or teens in the house, period. Or leaving a gun unsecured, period- you never know who may pop by for a visit as a few grandparents have tragically discovered. |
| Usually when something like this happens, the shooter has gone into his own world, has pushed family away and is doing his own thing....which is not completely unheard of behavior for teens who do tend to seek some amount of independence from their parents. |
Doesn't make much difference in this case. You can still fire a lot of rounds quickly with a semiautomatic. I agree with the law that proposed New Jersey law. Should also apply to the mentally ill. Mental illness and guns don't mix. |
| The family would have been saved if they did not own a gun. Adam Lanza certainly should not have had a gun at his house. |
I think anyone with common sense reading about Lanza's home environment would have realized that he was a ticking time bomb. |
Maybe the parents who are careless like that are overwhelmed, depressed, somewhat suicidal themselves. |
His mom was overwhelmed and probably angry. Her life with Adam was miserable. |
I certainly wondered about that with Nancy Lanza, if she just gave up, and this family in NJ--the mom sounded very depressed. |
I agree with you, and with the proposed law, but facts matter. The early reporting was calling the gun automatic - which are virtually illegal everywhere - and that was incorrect. |