How could Robyn Lawley be considered "plus size"???!!!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:She's plus size for a model, not a normal person.

By the way, height doesn't affect size the way you think. Plenty of tall women are still size 6 shirts or skirts. Pants are different because of length. Being tall only changes your size if you are wide, either you skeleton or from weight.

Not true.

I'm a "thin" 6ft woman and wear an 8 skirt. My BMI is borders underweight.

So your skeleton is bigger overall, not just taller.

[Anonymous]

A friend of mine used to do some plus-sized modeling. The average size for them was 10-12. Once she hit size 14, she was too big to be a plus sized model and her career was over. And the irony was this was for Lane Bryant - who doesn't sell clothes under size 14.

[Anonymous]

I was just looking at that article and wondering the same thing. She looks like a normal size to me.

[Anonymous]

She reminds me old school pinup girls.

[Anonymous]

I would love to look like her. She looks great. I am many inches shorter though.

[Anonymous]

By the way, height doesn't affect size the way you think. Plenty of tall women are still size 6 shirts or skirts. Pants are different because of length. Being tall only changes your size if you are wide, either you skeleton or from weight.

Agreed.

This height crap on this board gets on my nerves. Ppl on here always say you are a "fatter" 10 (for example) if you are 5'2" vs 5'10". I would assume the clothing industry sizes the waist/hips/thighs of pants for a 10 the same, and then adjusts the length.

[Anonymous]

She is what my mother would call a "healthy girl."

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I imagine she's only a size 12 in designer sizes. At Ann Taylor or Gap, she probably wears a 6.

That's because of vanity sizing.

[Anonymous]

while this points to issues with designer perceptions of sizes, i think this points to issues with normal peoples' perceptions of sizes too.

our country has an obesity problem and people think when you're "thick" that you're "normal." and guess what? you are normal, for the overweight society we live in. you're not thin.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:She's plus size for a model, not a normal person.

By the way, height doesn't affect size the way you think. Plenty of tall women are still size 6 shirts or skirts. Pants are different because of length. Being tall only changes your size if you are wide, either you skeleton or from weight.

Not true.

I'm a "thin" 6ft woman and wear an 8 skirt. My BMI is borders underweight.

I'd like to hear more about this. I am 6'' and don't consider myself thin at all, wear a 14. And people are always telling me, yah, but you would be a 10 if you were 6 inches shorter.

True?

OMG you are six INCHES tall!?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

By the way, height doesn't affect size the way you think. Plenty of tall women are still size 6 shirts or skirts. Pants are different because of length. Being tall only changes your size if you are wide, either you skeleton or from weight.

Agreed.

This height crap on this board gets on my nerves. Ppl on here always say you are a "fatter" 10 (for example) if you are 5'2" vs 5'10". I would assume the clothing industry sizes the waist/hips/thighs of pants for a 10 the same, and then adjusts the length.

Yes, except they don't adjust the length. So if you are tall you are going to appear slimmer as a 10 than you will if you are short. Picture a 5' person wearing a size 10 and then someone 5'10" wearing the same pants (which are now cropped). Who do you think will look slimmer?

And speaking as someone with a longer-than-average inseam, I really wish they would size them longer!!

[Anonymous]

Yes, except they don't adjust the length. So if you are tall you are going to appear slimmer as a 10 than you will if you are short. Picture a 5' person wearing a size 10 and then someone 5'10" wearing the same pants (which are now cropped). Who do you think will look slimmer?

And speaking as someone with a longer-than-average inseam, I really wish they would size them longer!!

You are talking about appearances, I'm talking about actual measurement. Or are you saying that the waist size for a 10 in longer lengths is different than a 10 in petites for the same brand of pants?

[Anonymous]

double digits is plus size no matter how tall you are.

[Anonymous]

she has a fuppa

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:She's plus size for a model, not a normal person.

By the way, height doesn't affect size the way you think. Plenty of tall women are still size 6 shirts or skirts. Pants are different because of length. Being tall only changes your size if you are wide, either you skeleton or from weight.

You're right about the size thing, but I think it's silly to call someone who is height-weight proportional, like she is, plus size.