Anonymous wrote:OP here. Thanks for all the responses - some of them quite funny! We are N.E. WASPs, so maybe that's why we like the "WASPy names". Also, several on the list are family names. Anyway, the perspective is interesting!
Seriously, you are one tough cookie. If I had received responses like this, I'd be sobbing (pregnancy hormones or no). I admit I agree with the consensus, too trendy for my tastes, but I really admire the hell out of you for handling the feedback with such class. Way classier than some of the responses, that could have said the same thing without being cruel.
I had to name two boys, and it was ROUGH. Seems like we had to choose from either had classic names (John, David, etc., which made me want to snore) or super-trendy ones. It took us MONTHS to decide. Our first is Nathaniel, we call him Nate. It has been a really good name - everyone understands it and it's un-offensive but there aren't any other Nate's around (well, almost none). I like the upbeat sound of it, and how Nate could be a baseball player and he could use Nathaniel if he's a serious lawyer-type. Or a beat poet.
Our second is Jack River. River was my choice, but people kept saying things like "Are you going to buy him a bong for his first birthday?" so I decided to give him something more traditional. We absolutely couldn't decide on a name we both loved, so we compromised with Jack - it was my grandfather's name and my DH's father's name (well, John is). We don't regret it, but I do wish we'd found something we loved more that was a bit less common than Jack is these days.
Blah, blah. Sorry to ramble. I'm just recalling how rough it was choosing names! I hope you find a name you both love.
|