GDS vs. Potomac for upper school

[Anonymous]

I have generally heard that STEM is better at Potomac as said above because of robotics and SERC. Math is better at GDS. but Potomac has lunch and a larger campus. GDS gives more freedom and Potomac is more structured. Not sure about social environments and quality of teachers at the two schools.

[Anonymous]

Not sure if college counselors are better at one school or the other.

[Anonymous]

College outcomes are great at both - slightly better at GDS but wouldn't let that guide the decision.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:For those saying GDS hands down, what’s that based on?

I would pick GDS or an another DC private any day. DC private schools have more weight with admissions across the country. Facts!

Fit beats college admits.

None of the DC area privates are particularly weighty on the national scale.
I think Potomac college admits are probably a bit better than GDS.
How many did GDS to Harvard last year?

[Anonymous]

I don’t think Harvard or other ivys are a good benchmark because it could be driven by legacy hook.

[Anonymous]

Both are great schools. Can’t go wrong with either

[Anonymous]

We are struggling with this same question, and the caricatures feel like a distraction. It seems that both schools are rigorous, thoughtful, and deeply caring about their students. I’d venture that several families are in a similar situation as well, and what attracted us seems to have attracted others: a well-rounded, challenging, modern, and secular education of the highest caliber. Our 8th grader is also torn, and sees a lot of benefits in both schools and their respective approaches. We like the city. We like the woods. The commute sucks either way. It may, for us, come down to a few data points with the curriculum. The Potomac way of structuring history courses seems more carefully considered and logically organized, with a real blossoming of options in the final year. The math courses at GDS seem like they may offer more opportunities to accelerate given our student’s particular experience. Less than 48 hours to make a call… Maybe we flip a coin, maybe we just go with the cafeteria. It’s a great problem to have.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:We are struggling with this same question, and the caricatures feel like a distraction. It seems that both schools are rigorous, thoughtful, and deeply caring about their students. I’d venture that several families are in a similar situation as well, and what attracted us seems to have attracted others: a well-rounded, challenging, modern, and secular education of the highest caliber. Our 8th grader is also torn, and sees a lot of benefits in both schools and their respective approaches. We like the city. We like the woods. The commute sucks either way. It may, for us, come down to a few data points with the curriculum. The Potomac way of structuring history courses seems more carefully considered and logically organized, with a real blossoming of options in the final year. The math courses at GDS seem like they may offer more opportunities to accelerate given our student’s particular experience. Less than 48 hours to make a call… Maybe we flip a coin, maybe we just go with the cafeteria. It’s a great problem to have.

Good luck! DC is at one of those and joined in 9th! I’m sure you’ll be happy
either way. Does your child intend to play any sports? That could be a factor. Each school has different strengths. If you have a girl who plays volleyball, GDS is the clear choice, for example.

[Anonymous]

I don't know what the admit rate is like at GDS but Potomac only takes 20 9th graders from a pool of hundreds of applicants with very little preference for legacies at the upper school level. So your kid will probably thrive wherever they go. Location might end up being the driver.

Potomac also encourages public speaking in a way that I don't see often.

[Anonymous]

I personally resonate with the ethos of GDS more than Potomac, and my pick between the two would be GDS. The kids who graduate from GDS also seem very mature and independent for their ages – the kids I know at Potomac are a bit more "suburbanite" types and dependent on structure. If you/your kid can't make lunch daily and you don't want to spend more $ on off-campus meals, that might be a problem, however.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I don't actually think these schools are in the same league (though I'm sure Potomac boosters would disagree).

I agree.

-a parent with kids at a different school

[Anonymous]

Several of the recent posts feed the caricatures. Absolutely same league. Great academics and educational outcomes at both if you seriously investigate. Maybe there is old thinking on this board that feeds an antiquated view that GDS is a superior “DC” school, but in the here and now, these schools are competitors for talented kids and their parents. Both strike me as only mildly suburban, city-fringe (this isn’t the School Without Walls, it’s NW and McLean) and both schools take advantage of their proximity to the city. Maybe the growing economic heft of NoVa contributed to a closer alignment over time—dunno, but it’s truly where we’re at. Both great. Both competing for top talent. Both have excellent outcomes and sharp, eloquent, confident kids graduating.

[Anonymous]

This

Potomac has lunch

[Anonymous]

Reasons why we chose GDS over Potomac this cycle from talking to current Potomac parents :
- Long criticized math program at Potomac; most k-8 kids are required to retake geometry
- Conservative parents vs more left of center at GDS
- More flexible curriculum: able to go up and down levels of class from year to year
- No required after school sports
- More diversity at GDS

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Several of the recent posts feed the caricatures. Absolutely same league. Great academics and educational outcomes at both if you seriously investigate. Maybe there is old thinking on this board that feeds an antiquated view that GDS is a superior “DC” school, but in the here and now, these schools are competitors for talented kids and their parents. Both strike me as only mildly suburban, city-fringe (this isn’t the School Without Walls, it’s NW and McLean) and both schools take advantage of their proximity to the city. Maybe the growing economic heft of NoVa contributed to a closer alignment over time—dunno, but it’s truly where we’re at. Both great. Both competing for top talent. Both have excellent outcomes and sharp, eloquent, confident kids graduating.

No matter how much money Potomac funnels into its facilities, its education can't measure up to the DC privates, sorry. I feel like Potomac has no clear ethos, while Sidwell/GDS/STA/NCS have unique identities and visions. I'm not "old" either -- just someone in their 20s who was born and bred in DC.