I'm no expert, but based on this, I would submit the 4. The story is that he's very strong in bio and pretty good in other sciences. The idea that only perfection is good enough is really harmful. |
U.S. colleges' undergraduate admissions are NOT a meritocracy system but are based on institutional priorities. I have had students from the same high school (not TJ) who had A's in AP Physics C and 5s on both AP Physics M and E&M, yet still didn't get into IVYs. (High SAT, award-winning ECs, etc., all stellar). Another student without those scores got in. So when parents say that the admissions process in U.S. is a strategic game, they are actually right. |
Is he a rising senior? This kind of GPA from TJ makes it impossible for any ivies or T20s, unless he is URM or has a huge spike in ECs (like winning the IMO gold or solo published in Nature). |
What are the differences between the two students? |
Gender is one. Maybe one was full-pay and the other wanted financial aid. The one who didn't get in had a very rigorous transcript as opposed to the other. Their essays were really good, so we couldn't differentiate on that part. The only reason we felt was that it was an institutional priority, perhaps. |
Forgot to add: The one who didn't get in studied AP Physics C in 10th grade, and the one who got in was studying in 12th grade at the time of the application cycle. |
So where does that put him in his class at TJ? That’s what matters. |
| My kid was admitted to an Ivy for engineering with 2 4's and an A minus. catholic school. No hooks. |
At TJ, if your end-of-junior year GPA is less than 4.5, it makes it extremely hard for ivies, let alone a 4.37, unless you’re URM. Think about it this way, how many Bs are there on your transcript for a 4.37 GPA? It won’t look pretty. |
Is every class at TJ weighted? |
| Is he interested in liberal arts colleges where more girls apply than boys? Varsar for example. In the context of TJ, he may face some strong competition for ivies. |
No. There are mandatory non-honors classes with 4.0 gpa. |
What is his raw (unweighted) GPA? Was there upward trajectory between 9th to 11th grade GPA despite rigor going up? How many "highest rigor" classes will he take in total by end of senior year? |
| What Gpa do you need at TJ to get into Berkeley? |
Look at the UC website they have the average GPA for the incoming classes of all colleges I believe last year for Berkeley it was 4.6-4.8 but look it up |