8 year old decided she likes dad more than me

Anonymous
Hi OP,

What worked for me was DH and toddler taking a Gymboree, then Music Together class, just the 2 of them. DH liked having other dads to hang with and it was a more fun/structured way for him to enjoy the younger DD.

While they did that, I had a standing "date" with older DD and would give her 2 choices of activities and let her pick one. When she tried to derail that, while out, we made a list of fun things, put them in a box and she would pick one. So she had input but was not in control. Getting out of the house helped a lot with changing the dynamics.

My mom said to treat is as good practice for teen years.

If you don't, I'd have a standing monthly or bimonthly date just for you and DH, have a standing sitter or join a babysitting co-op. It's important for that relationship to be nurtured and primary, it's the bedrock of the family.

Hang in there!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
You should be hurt, sad and intolerant with your DH's attitude of refusing to equally share care for your toddler.

Instead you are focused on appropriate feelings of an 8 year old.

Talk about misplaced emotions!


OP here. Maybe you're right. However, I was the one who suggested to have a second kid (he agreed, but now regrets it). We agreed that I'd take care of the toddler more since he would have been happy with one. I don't mind, I love my toddler. I just didn't realize my relationship with my #1 would suffer as a result.


Even still, your DH agreed to be the parent of a second child. This is going to be a big problem for your toddler later on if your DH never comes around to being an equal parent in their life. In the meantime, maybe you need to hire a babysitter so you can have some one on one time with your older child since your DH refuses to step up with your toddler.
Anonymous
Agree with everyone’s suggestion of fun 1-on-1 time. Doesn’t have to be going out. You can cook dinner together (something she loves) one weekend afternoon while the toddler is napping. And yes, your DH should take toddler to a class for 1-on-1 time.
Anonymous
to me it sounds like her dad isn’t present enough for her. You are, be proud of that
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
You should be hurt, sad and intolerant with your DH's attitude of refusing to equally share care for your toddler.

Instead you are focused on appropriate feelings of an 8 year old.

Talk about misplaced emotions!


OP here. Maybe you're right. However, I was the one who suggested to have a second kid (he agreed, but now regrets it). We agreed that I'd take care of the toddler more since he would have been happy with one. I don't mind, I love my toddler. I just didn't realize my relationship with my #1 would suffer as a result.



Wow this is messed up
Anonymous
Totally normal. At 8 I started taking my DD to Starbucks for a treat and "coffee". Let her talk about whatever and genuinely listen. Now my older DD is 15 and she really prefers me, whe the younger one is all about dad. Just let them have relationships with both of you independently and know that each of you have a place.
Anonymous
I’d probably do things that girls-only specific that it'd be fun and impossible for your DH to replicate with DD.

Your DH should not show favoritism of one child. He agreed to two kids and it’s too late to renege. You two should rotate toddler responsibilities evenly.
Anonymous
Keep the end goal in mind: you want your kid to be a psychologically healthy, happy adult. One of the greatest gifts you can give your daughter to further that goal is a solid relationship with her dad. I know it’s a tough pill to swallow when she demonstrates a preference, but try to remember that it’s a GOOD thing that she has that relationship and it doesn’t actually subtract from all the good that you give her. just continue to think of ways to show her that you love her whether she returns that affection or not. And Cultivate that relationship between toddler and dad too as much as possible, remembering that fathers often focus on the older until the baby/toddler is a bit more rational.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
You should be hurt, sad and intolerant with your DH's attitude of refusing to equally share care for your toddler.

Instead you are focused on appropriate feelings of an 8 year old.

Talk about misplaced emotions!


OP here. Maybe you're right. However, I was the one who suggested to have a second kid (he agreed, but now regrets it). We agreed that I'd take care of the toddler more since he would have been happy with one. I don't mind, I love my toddler. I just didn't realize my relationship with my #1 would suffer as a result.


Uh …. this is bullshit, OP. He made the kid. He can take care of the kid.

Leave the toddler with DH and go do some fun stuff with your 8 year old.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:So, I'm the primary parent, but DH is involved maybe 30% of the time. We both work FT but his job is more intense. I am point person for our toddler, so he is more with the 8 year old when he's parenting.

I feel like I don't get enough time with my older one - whenever I'm parenting, I have them both, and obviously the toddler needs a lot of attention. I do try to occasionally take just the older one out, but it's hard, because DH doesn't really like the toddler age.

My kid, however, has been more and more focused on her dad. She looks a lot like him, so she says they are twins. If we're watching a movie or out to eat, she and her sister fight over who gets to sit next to him. If we are playing a game, they fight over who is on his team. They want him to take them to school and pick them up. When I was going to buy family pajamas, the older one said she only wanted her and her dad to match, and the toddler and I should have a different design. The toddler cried and also wanted to match dad.

I think generally the toddler is just copying her older sister (she copies her in everything) - otherwise she seems equally attached to us both. But the older one truly prefers DH.

I did go on a mother-daughter vacation with my older girl, and right after she said "When do I get to go just with dad?" So, we planned a father-daughter trip, they just got back and she's asking when she gets to go again. I said we'd probably go just the two of us next (whenever the next trip is), and she got upset.

Today she sat there for half an hour making an elaborate card and gift for her dad and nothing for me.

DH and I have tried to tell her it's not nice or fair to do this - just like she gets upset if she feels that we are favoring her little sister. But she disregards it totally. I do feel hurt and unloved, honestly, because 8 is such a magical age, and I want to enjoy it with her. I am kind of resentful at my DH that he refuses to do more with the toddler - maybe if I had spent more time with her over the past couple of years, she would love me. But at this point, even if he offers to watch the toddler, she doesn't want to be with me.

Any advice?


Yes! Get over yourself. I have three daughters and I also work a lot but am the primary parent. My girls are all daddies girls and I love that for them and him. Sometimes they are more into me and sometimes they are more into him but their relationship (because he’s the opposite gender) is less complicated in my opinion.

Just go with it - don’t show emotion (no moping around) don’t be a drama queen (“where’s mommies card!”). Your children are not responsible for your feelings nor are they owed anything because you chose to be the primary parent. Stop the martyr shtick. People have preferences. Your daughter prefers her dad right now. Deal with it!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
You should be hurt, sad and intolerant with your DH's attitude of refusing to equally share care for your toddler.

Instead you are focused on appropriate feelings of an 8 year old.

Talk about misplaced emotions!


OP here. Maybe you're right. However, I was the one who suggested to have a second kid (he agreed, but now regrets it). We agreed that I'd take care of the toddler more since he would have been happy with one. I don't mind, I love my toddler. I just didn't realize my relationship with my #1 would suffer as a result.



Wow this is messed up


+1. So you’re both psychos and you’re still mad your older child prefers her dad? Gotcha 🤮
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
You should be hurt, sad and intolerant with your DH's attitude of refusing to equally share care for your toddler.

Instead you are focused on appropriate feelings of an 8 year old.

Talk about misplaced emotions!


OP here. Maybe you're right. However, I was the one who suggested to have a second kid (he agreed, but now regrets it). We agreed that I'd take care of the toddler more since he would have been happy with one. I don't mind, I love my toddler. I just didn't realize my relationship with my #1 would suffer as a result.



Wow this is messed up


I have to agree. You guys agreed he would just ignore the little one? For how long? That’s crazy

I think having a preference can be very normal but it’s happening in the setting of some messed up stuff so I would be worried it’s because she already understands that she has a different relationship with her parents that the younger one does and she’s reacting strongly to that. You have to be the adult and make sure you get time with your oldest op. And your husband has to be a parent to your toddler, not a fun uncle.
Anonymous
Keep parenting the right way and continue to treat both the kids equal like you already are. Kids tend to show a preference for one parent and it can change from time to time.
Anonymous
Hi OP, i feel your pain and understand what you are saying. I want to point out that your spending time with the toddler may not be the cause of DD's preference for her dad. I have an only DC and also the main parent. DH is very hands off and not around much due to travel. DS prefers DH and while it does sting a bit, i can see why. I'm the one who makes sure homework gets done, reminds DS to brush teeth, have a bath and all the necessary day to day stuff. DH doesn't do any of that stuff - plays with DS once a week but takes him out for some fun stuff once a week or every other week. He doesn't like to correct DS so DS considers him more fun.

I wouldn't let it bother you too much. DC will eventually appreciate all that you are doing. As others have mentioned don't let DD know that it bothers you. I'm sure she loves you too and doesn't realize you are hurt by her preference.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
You should be hurt, sad and intolerant with your DH's attitude of refusing to equally share care for your toddler.

Instead you are focused on appropriate feelings of an 8 year old.

Talk about misplaced emotions!


This. Your DH doesn’t like the toddler stage?! Tough poop. He has a toddler. Geez. He don’t get to just skip parenting o e of his kids.
post reply Forum Index » Elementary School-Aged Kids
Message Quick Reply
Go to: