Don't know what you mean. could you explain? |
Also, candidates for President basically have to have some type of faith (or pretend to), or they would be unelectable. |
Right - as was the case with Obama, as he made pretty clear in his pre-election book. I recall at his inauguration, I cheered when he said something like "...to people of faith and people of no faith." |
Also the artificial constructs, as you call them, of atheism and religion, cause a lot of trouble, irrespective of the fact that they are artificial. |
| Control power money |
I don't think anyone but you called religion and atheism "artificial constructs". Religion, broadly speaking, is a brief system. Atheism is not a belief system. It is the lack of a belief system; the lack of theism. |
oops "brief system" should be "belief system" |
DP OK that (position that atheism is not a belief system) is the position of the Atheist International Allaince but I believe the truth is much more nuanced and non black and white. For the record, I am not proselytizing for any particular belief system although I am religious. In a literal sense your contention that has been oft repeated in this forum may be true - “Atheism, in the broadest sense, is an absence of belief in the existence of deities. Less broadly, atheism is a rejection of the belief that any deities exist. In an even narrower sense, atheism is specifically the position that there are no deities.” (Wikipedia) But atheism is an ideology and does guide non believers in understanding reality … “What counts as a belief system? A belief system is an ideology or set of principles that helps us to interpret our everyday reality.“ (https://study.com/academy/lesson/belief-systems-definition-types-quiz.html) This article captures some of the nuances from an atheist’s perspective Faith of the faithless: Is atheism just another religion? The taunt that atheism is religious thinking in disguise undermines its claim to be a better way to run the world. The truth is more complex than you might imagine By Graham Lawton 11 April 2017 https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg23431212-800-faith-of-the-faithless-is-atheism-just-another-religion/ That said, we need to find ways to peacefully live together and allow safe spaces for different belief systems/ non belief systems - as long as they do not perpetuate hate or harm to others. |
Haven't read it yet (intend to) but this quote sticks out to me: "The taunt that atheism is religious thinking in disguise undermines its claim to be a better way to run the world." Atheism does not claim to be "a better way to run the world." At most, I think that individual atheists have said that the world would be better off without religion. Seems like the author is grasping at straws, trying to make atheists admit, or trying to demonstrate, that atheists want to run the world. |
Yes i only posted the nuances form an atheist perspective - The main point is that it is not black and white. I don’t wish to convert anyone to any belief system or lack thereof. However there are definitely do appear to be some elements of belief systems within atheism. The main point to Mr is that we live honestly and responsibly according to what makes the most sense to each of us - not just intellectually but as whole people. We are all complex beings. |
The first link leads to one quote. The second leads to an article that requires a temporary, free subscription to read in its entirety. I chose to not subscribe. Perhaps pp could post more here. Meanwhile, I'd say that this is one persona's opinion, to which he is entitled, of course, but no reason to assume it's correct or indicates how all atheists think. I remember years ago, a well-known atheist (don't recall who) said something like "We are a gentle people". My reaction was that we (i.e., atheists) are not a people at all and not all of us are gentle. I think he meant to say that atheists are not a threat to society (as some religions have been) and that people should not fear atheists as a group. That's what I think, anyhow. |
There may be individual atheists who have a belief system, but atheism itself is simply not a belief system, just as asymptomatic is not a disease. Probably not all Catholics believe exactly the same things, though Catholicism IS a belief system. |
As a formerly religious atheist, I completely agree with this. It calls for honesty and responsibility, which are possible with or without religion. |
| Another thread about atheism, how many are needed, honestly? |
Perhaps you shouldn't comment on such threads, which only keeps them going. You could start a thread about looking for a church in your neighborhood, or something, instead. As for your question, none are needed. No threads about anything are needed. All threads here are voluntary. |