child's ccd teacher publicly opposes catholic beliefs

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Many Catholic churches around here are going to be more progressive towards gay marriage, and even things like abortion. I am not religious but affiliated with a Catholic institution where TONS of the people who practice are very progressive in their beliefs (and there are a lot of large, reputable organizations that are working to reform these).

Sounds like you need to find a more conservative church? Or maybe (if these are the issues I am thinking of...) reconsider if teaching people to being gay is a sin or that women shouldn't have autonomy over their own bodies is actually the "right" way to be?

I've never heard of any school - religious or secular -- that teaches people to be gay. Besides it's not possible.

Teaching people THAT being gay.

That makes more sense. Did you correct your own error? or are you guessing about what someone else wrote?

[Anonymous]

You need to go to the pastor. If he does nothing politely write the bishop. If he does nothing, politely write Rome.

In the meantime, you may have to teach your child their catechism yourself. Alternatively you may have to go out of your way to get away from the local “cluster.”

Which diocese are you in.

No one has a right to teach catechism. When they take on that role they become a public representative of the Church. If they’re not willing to live in accord with Church teaching, or even worse if they publicly oppose it, they have to choose one or the other.

[Anonymous]

Having worked in the CCD program, it's a usually a volunteer position for which they do not have enough volunteers. So, good luck with this. You may end up teaching the class yourself.

[Anonymous]

Does she actually disagree with the church teaching and values, or does she just disagree with legislating them for all citizens?

[Anonymous]

I would be grateful. Likely my kid will have some crotici

[Anonymous]

So homeschool your child.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Her personal life is different. As long as she is teaching the values that is all that counts.

Is this true for priests and pastors as well?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Having worked in the CCD program, it's a usually a volunteer position for which they do not have enough volunteers. So, good luck with this. You may end up teaching the class yourself.

+1, are prepared to step and teach the class OP?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Does she actually disagree with the church teaching and values, or does she just disagree with legislating them for all citizens?

This.

I don't know a ton about Catholic doctrine specifically. But like OP, I also take religious instruction seriously. As an Orthodox Jew, I expect Judaics teachers in my children's school to agree with and comply in their personal lives with a reasonable semblance of normative Jewish Orthodox standards. At the same time, if they ran for office, I wouldn't expect them to propose legislation against Jewish/Christian intermarriage, just for instance.

[Anonymous]

OP you know that Catholics have freedom of conscience, and that this is an essential Catholic doctrine, right? Unless she is espousing literal heresy (like that Jesus wasn’t divine or the Eucharist is just symbolic) there is likely nothing about her personal views that makes her unfit to teach CCD. If you truly believe that she is unfit you should talk to the priest. But otherwise, I am not sure why you think, say, her position on gay marriage has anything to do with what she will teach 1st graders about the Eucharist?

https://www.scu.edu/ethics/focus-areas/religious-and-catholic-ethics/resources/catholicism-and-conscience/

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:You need to go to the pastor. If he does nothing politely write the bishop. If he does nothing, politely write Rome.

In the meantime, you may have to teach your child their catechism yourself. Alternatively you may have to go out of your way to get away from the local “cluster.”

Which diocese are you in.

No one has a right to teach catechism. When they take on that role they become a public representative of the Church. If they’re not willing to live in accord with Church teaching, or even worse if they publicly oppose it, they have to choose one or the other.

that is completely false. where are you getting that from?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Hehe my nuns opposed many Catholic teachings and l loved them

The best kind!
I love the Catholics with deep social values and who practice "love thy neighbor" over hate

[Anonymous]

This is a private religious school, so I think it's appropriate to question the public stances of a teacher turned candidate. Unless your mind is made up that there is no way forward then I'd approach the teacher first, in an attempt to salvage that relationship in case your child remains in her class. As long as she is fulfilling her duties and following the curriculum, then her personal views, even those made publicly, shouldn't really matter (it's not as though 7 year olds are watching local political debates, right?). If not satisfied, then I'd speak to the assistant principal or equivalent, and so on.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:my child's catholic ccd teacher is running for public office with aspects of her platform being directly opposite of catholic belief.

My immediate thought was to pull my child from the class and switch to a different teacher. However I don’t know if this is the correct thing to do or if it will make a difference.
On one hand, I do not want a person with these views teaching my child religious education, especially during the year they will make first communion. On the other hand, I know nothing about the other teacher; this teacher could also share these views (and if they both do, then what?). Also, I would not expect these topics to come up in second grade necessarily.

here could be other people in the religious education department at my church that share these views. These days it seems somewhat permissible for people to call themselves Catholic and support things that are explicitly against catholic teaching. This person has been a teacher and active in local government for years, so I think it’s likely that her views are known by those in charge.

All of my local parishes have been merged, so I don’t have the option to go elsewhere if this is a pervasive issue in my parish.

I don’t know how to handle this. I think at minimum I will speak with the director of religious Ed, but I’m not sure if I should ask to move classes (if it will even make a difference) and what to do if they say this a permissible position for a CCD teacher to hold.

I would appreciate some perspective as I figure out how to navigate this discussion and situation. Thank you.

You need to inform your diocese stat.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:This is a private religious school, so I think it's appropriate to question the public stances of a teacher turned candidate. Unless your mind is made up that there is no way forward then I'd approach the teacher first, in an attempt to salvage that relationship in case your child remains in her class. As long as she is fulfilling her duties and following the curriculum, then her personal views, even those made publicly, shouldn't really matter (it's not as though 7 year olds are watching local political debates, right?). If not satisfied, then I'd speak to the assistant principal or equivalent, and so on.

It's not a school.