No, it hasn't been working fine. |
As usual that’s not what Republicans actually want to impose with the SAVE Act, but thanks for demonstrating your cherry-picking skills. |
I mean that the Constitution specifies you must be 18 to vote in a national election and states have an obligation to follow that through positive verification. See the Supremacy Clause. |
Oh, can you show us an example where immigrants voted illegally in numbers that would even remotely affect the outcome of an election. Just one example. Since the problem is SO widespread according to you, it should be very easy for you to demonstrate. |
Again, that poll doesn't show the caveat that the government has to make the ID's free. Why does the GOP oppose that? |
please show where people under 18 are voting in federal elections. (hint: they aren't) |
Yes, it has. There is no proof that undocumented people are voting in any numbers that would sway an election. In fact, most of the voter fraud that is documented has been by republicans. See Meadows, Mark as a prime example. |
REAL ID does not suffice for 45 states. In those 45 states, it DOES NOT SHOW CITIZENSHIP. Only in Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Vermont and Washington will a REAL ID suffice and only then if you have paid the additional 30 dollars to get the "enhanced" version. |
You have a marriage certificate that shows your change in name. This is not complicated. Meanwhile, we have many states where all you have to do is check a box that says you are a US citizen. You think that is secure? It's not. There have been many instances of illegal aliens voting or registering to vote. There are other states where anyone who gets a driver's license has a voting ballot mailed to them automatically. Ironically, some of these states also permit illegal aliens to get a driver's license. Here are just a few of the articles written about noncitizens voting. There are plenty more like this..... https://www.justice.gov/usao-nj/pr/aliens-charged-illegally-voting-federal-election-and-making-false-statements-while https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/19-foreign-nationals-indicted-illegally-voting-2016-elections https://tennesseelookout.com/2025/11/03/tn-secretary-of-state-finds-42-possible-non-citizen-voters-out-states-4-3-million-voters/ https://www.opb.org/article/2024/09/23/voter-registration-noncitizen-oregon-motor-voter/ https://www.mlive.com/politics/2026/01/michigan-voter-fraud-probe-finds-noncitizen-voted-us-citizens-wrongly-flagged.html |
Wow! All those links covering years and years of elections all around the country, and the total number of non-citizens who voted… is under 100. And over 40 of them were only “potential” cases. And all the articles point out how there was zero impact on the outcome of any election. |
The Act itself has no provision to use a marriage certificate as a bridge between a birth certificate and a driver's license. It is merely anticipated that it iwll be acceptable. Moreover, a copy of your birth certificate is not sufficient. It must be an authenticated copy. Presumably, a marriage certificate will also need to be authenticated. |
That excuse is crap. If ONE noncitizen votes in our elections, that is one too many. I will remind you that 10 years ago, a race in VA was decided by drawing a name out of a hat because the election ended in a tie. https://thehill.com/opinion/campaign/366050-tied-virginia-election-proves-every-vote-actually-does-count/amp/ |
Your New Jersey article mentions two people. Your ICE article mentions 19 people in North Carolina. Your Tennesse article mentions 42 "potential non-US citizens" out of a total of 4.3 million voters. Your Oregon article mentions that 10 people who were improperly registered went on to vote (and one of those had become a citizen before voting). The issue there was due to poorly designed software that has now been fixed. Your Michigan article mentions one noncitizen who voted in 2018. Does voter fraud happen? Sure, but in very small numbers. You can bet that in any election close enough for such a margin to matter the recount process will verify the citizenship status of each voter. Fraud also happens when people vote in states where they don't actually live (like Mark Meadows). Does the SAVE act address that situation? |
I have been married more than 25 years. We do not live in the state where we were married. I have NO idea where our license is. Get real, this is a huge burden to try to fill. |
What about republicans who have been caught voting in multiple states during the same election cycle. Are you upset about that? Because that happens more often than what you are expressing outrage over. |