|
While it's true that Josh Hart may have been a journeyman before joining the Knicks, he's now firmly in the limelight and leads the league in postseason minutes. By the time his current deal ends, he will have made over $100M in salary. ESPN.com published a piece recently about his Sidwell roots.
All that said, I agree that it's ridiculous for PP to have cited him as evidence for category 3. He's hardly a no-name player though. Journeymen don't have over 800K IG followers. |
Their facilities blow Sidwell’s away? Surely you’re joking. Have you seen the inside of STA’s gym? It looks as if contractors haven’t touched it since it was built at the turn of the 20th century. NCS’ gray building looks lovely from the outside. The inside is a completely different story. It looks like some parts have been renovated, and others completely ignored—all on the same floor. And why do they make visitors walk through that dank and stinky cafeteria on the ground floor? Finally, why do you have to walk outside to get to all three buildings? Who wants to walk a city block to get to PE classes in the rain and snow? The campus (and the miserable grind atmosphere) was a deal breaker for our family. |
Construction starts this summer (June). I can already tell that Sidwell’s haters are really going to be upset in 2026. Oh well… It’s not easy being the best at so many things. |
How many CURRENT NBA players do any other DC private schools have? I’ll wait. While I’m waiting, how are the academics at any of those other high schools? Rigorous? Or is it more like SJC, where the athlete always comes before the scholar? |
|
Luka Garza went to Maret, won the Wooden Award twice (plus runner-up once), and is on the Timberwolves. His NBA career won't pan out, which most predicted even though he was dominant in college.
That said, why are you limiting to basketball only? There are a good number of DC area private school alums in the pro baseball, football, and soccer leagues. |
The discussion is not limited to basketball. Which top* DC private schools have professional athletes CURRENTLY playing in the NBA, NFL, MLB? Professional soccer in the US is meh, so let’s skip that one. * Please don’t list DC schools that are essentially sports factories. Those are schools that will graduate any athlete as long as he/she can still play the sport. |
| ^ Also include the WNBA because it’s on the rise. |
STA Matt Bowman current player on Yankees MLB. |
|
Do you consider Stone Ridge a sports factory? Because Katie Ledecky (a far more decorated athlete than Josh Hart) went to Stanford and graduated in under 4 years.
Bullis and Georgetown Prep have players currently in the NFL. There's a player on the Chicago Cubs who went to Georgetown Prep and Duke. The Arizona Diamondbacks have a pitcher who went to STA and Princeton. Kristian Fletcher went to Landon and was a trialist with Manchester United and Borussia Dortmund before signing with DC United as a 17 year old. You would have us think that Josh Hart and Saddiq Bey are special snowflakes? |
None of the schools listed above, except perhaps STA, is Sidwell’s academic peer. You don’t have to worry much about your grades if you’re an athlete at Bullis, Gonzaga, Prep, etc. Sidwell expelled Josh Hart due to poor grades. The Sidwell community protested for months before he was allowed to return, and he was tutored by teachers, parents and other community members until graduation. US soccer (especially men’s soccer) is not qualified to be a part of this conversation. You can’t even name the Bullis and Prep players. Nameless, faceless players on teams with 60+ players each. While Katie Ledecky is certainly a “decorated” swimmer, I missed the name of her professional sports team…because that’s what this conversation is about. |
Landon? 🙄 Don’t get me started on the sorry athletes Landon produces. You can invoke Landon’s name when we start talking about murderous athletes. |
Keep moving the goalposts. And citing the academic troubles that Josh Hart experienced doesn't help your case in any way. The athletes I listed were able to cut it at top universities, whether or not you consider their high schools to be Sidwell's "academic peer," so clearly they were well-prepared. |
Josh Hart was able to successfully complete his degree at Villanova. No doubt due to his Sidwell education. Those high schools are not Sidwell’s academic peers. That’s a fact, not my opinion. |
|
The fact that Sidwell let Josh Hart return means they’re no different from the schools where you claim the athletes don’t need to worry much about their grades.
And I don’t think you believe that Sidwell has any academic peers. So this discussion is basically moot. |
Actually, this conversation was about most famous DC private. It's still not Sidwell. |