I only want my child to get 30 min max HW per day

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It depends entirely on how much they want to achieve (AP classes vs non, is instrumental music part of their load, variety athlete or not, etc)


I think OP is just raising an underachiever. My kid is a senior right now taking 5 AP classes. Last year was two DEs and 2APS. He’s also a starting varsity athlete, tutors German and a math (both through the honor society) and participates in math and science competitions. Yes he also does a ton of homework to maintain his 4.6.

Having a kid tracking toward engineering which is full of smart and competitive kids I can tell you for a fact the high achieving kids in China and India don’t have parents whining that their kids have too much work. Some of the low intellect America we have in this country are an embarrassment.


+1000
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Homework is banned in my house, the school has more than enough time with them during the school day and they don't need to be cutting into the students personal time.


How old are your kids? If they're early elementary you can get away with this nonsense but they will be very ill-prepared for older elementary, and in turn, in bad shape when they hit MS and especially HS. They will have zero study skills, though I suspect you think there are no such things as study skills....

If you think you can keep up "homework is banned" all the way through high school, you will be homeschooling anyway, because your kids will fail everything at school. Why? Because homework counts as part of grades in some courses, and because at a certain point, they will be unable to pass tests IN school because they did not do the necessary learning and practice outside school hours.

But you do you! You'll screw over your own kids academically, but at least you'll have stuck to your principles, right?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:My kids mostly finished the bulk of their homework at school. They had other interests and worked on that at home. But, yes, they did work. They also got straight As, aced SATs, aced ECs, and took 12 APs. 8 APs by the end of 11th grade and from all 5 core subjects. 5s in all. So what? They are STEM magnet public school students. By 4th grade they had mastered study skills and time management.


That's awesome. Any tips you/they learned on how to master study skills? Sometimes I feel my kids are spinning their wheels trying to do homework, so it takes longer than it needs to. (Especially getting distracted by technology)


I can tell you what worked for my kids. It may not be palatable.

Dedicated time and place to do the homework - My kids had to do homework, after they came back from school and had a snack. The homework was done with my help and under my supervision on the dining table. They had to do it neatly (or I made them re-do it), write their name, subject, date, and write the question that they were answering. Then I checked their work, they put it in the folder and put it in the bookbag. Train your kids to sit for an hour and do their homework/study, so that they get used to it.

Daily practice - When did they start this? From kindergarten. But before that, we were playing "school" at home. If they did not have homework, I printed out worksheets for them to do the homework. I also sat with them for homework and timed it so that they were not wasting time. No TV, no phone etc. It was a big time commitment from me too. I was not even browsing my phone or doing errands etc. I was sitting with them on the dining table as they did their homework. This was done every single day, including summer vacations.

Enrich and expand their horizons - I was curating curriculum, study guides, text books, tests...so that I could teach them. Education was a serious business at our home. My kids were sitting at home and doing one hour of work from the time they were little kids. It also included watching documentaries, watching PBS programming, reading books, magazine etc. In some ways, I was learning with them and tutoring them. I needed it to be fun for my kids and be in tune with what they were thinking and watching. I needed it to be fun for me.

Build knowledge and skills - By the time they were in 3rd grade, they had memorized multiplication tables, fraction tables and square tables, long multiplication and division with decimals, knew cursive, fractions, ratios and percentages, had learned spellings and word usage. Since they were in magnet programs in MoCo, they had learned to break projects in small chunks and learned how to study for tests by using quizlet app. They knew how to make powerpoint presentations, they knew MS apps - Word, Excel. By 4th grade, they were programming for robotics competitions, knew how to research for a paper, find credible sources, how to make a bibliography, how to quote, academic honesty etc.

From 3rd to 8th grade, I was accelerating them in many subjects not taught in school. Geography, world history, comparative religions, history of art, politics, current affairs, By 6th grade, my expectation was that they would be finishing bulk of their homework and projects at school, when it was handed to them. This freed us to do other things at home. Including listening to NPR and reading about the covered topics in wikipedia etc. The best part of the magnet programs was that they found a number of peers like them.

Be a resource for your kids - You need to put in the time to understand what will be asked of your kids in each grade and have a long term plan, so that you are working smart and in a logical manner. Make them take ownership of the process so that they learn to do it for themselves (under your guidance). It is not a good feeling to be hustling to meet a deadline.

Hurry up and finish - I have one kid who is a perfectionist, another kid who has a tendency to procrastinate. Having a fixed time and place to study, and a training to be able to sit down and just do the work was the most important take away. I taught the kids (because I was there sitting with them), to start something, do a good job, not linger on it, finish it and then put it in their book bag from the time they were 3 or 4 years old.

I think by 8th grade, I became more like a reference guide for them. They were driving how I could help them. By 8th grade, they had a lot of basic skills to study, research, manage time and projects, advocate for themselves and juggle their commitments.

Look, I do not believe that the students - by studying less, or being mired in busy work, or by having long breaks in their school year, or by not learning presentation or research skills, or by not learning creative writing and analysis, or not having a good work ethic, or having knowledge gaps - will become successful. Both parents and students have to work hard to make the students capable and succeed. The teachers and schools can only do so much and they don't lose out if your kid is poorly educated.


This is a troll, right?


Nope. But, you should move along. You are not the intended audience for my post.


Not PP here but the intended audience for your post is gullible and doesn't recognize an obvious troll.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Homework is banned in my house, the school has more than enough time with them during the school day and they don't need to be cutting into the students personal time.


When I see this argument, it is always coming from rich parents. The underlying belief is that their kid doesn’t need homework because their kid will be set up for life regardless.

But this is not the situation for the vast majority.


I used to babysit kids who were at school until 4pm. There was homework hour with tutors after school so that the parents did not have to bother with that when the kids came home.

That's probably whats going on in pp's case.
post reply Forum Index » Tweens and Teens
Message Quick Reply
Go to: