Carrie Bradshaw was not good looking enough for her dating life

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I never found any of the guys she dated to be over the top gorgeous either. Good looking, yes. Rich, some. But they weren’t strikingly attractive like Smith Jerrod. Aiden was too good for her for sure because he was a good guy and she walked all over him but it was his personality that made him so attractive.

yes, Samantha dated the best looking men - smith Jerrod and also Richard wright

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I know a woman who is a total doppelgänger of SJP’s (literally could play a younger version of her) down to the fashion sense. She has no problem dating, at all.

I guess that’s shocking for the anti Semites in this thread.

I would really love to see the appearances of the people claiming she is ugly.

For sure, SJP dated far hotter men irl than any poster here.

and how weird is it to be hung up on “proving” she is ugly. Get a life, people.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I know a woman who is a total doppelgänger of SJP’s (literally could play a younger version of her) down to the fashion sense. She has no problem dating, at all.

I guess that’s shocking for the anti Semites in this thread.

I would really love to see the appearances of the people claiming she is ugly.

For sure, SJP dated far hotter men irl than any poster here.

and how weird is it to be hung up on “proving” she is ugly. Get a life, people.

I'm so glad I'm not friends with people like the people who post about shallow ridiculous topics like this one. It explains a lot about our world though. Sad.

[Anonymous]

Did none of you actually watch the show in the 90s, with her walking around her apartment in her underwear with the most amazing a$$ and legs? You must've missed it. Her hair and body were 10/10, clothes 10/10. That's a lot.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Did none of you actually watch the show in the 90s, with her walking around her apartment in her underwear with the most amazing a$$ and legs? You must've missed it. Her hair and body were 10/10, clothes 10/10. That's a lot.

Her apartment too~

[Anonymous]

Her character was the kind of girl you date, not marry.

[Anonymous]

As a mom to an 8 year old girl, this thread makes me incredibly sad.

Maybe it was previously mentioned, but where the hell is the “Jerry Seinfeld and George Costanza we’re not good looking enough for their dating life” thread??

The fact that it’s probably mostly women negatively commenting on her looks is depressing.

My least favorite Office episodes is the “Is Hilary Swank hot?” B-plot one. Even worse than Scott’s Tots.

We have a long way to go.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Her character was the kind of girl you date, not marry.

That's clearly what Big though, until he realized perfection bored him and he wanted to be with someone with hot sexual chemistry who made him laugh.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Her character was the kind of girl you date, not marry.

Yeah, and then you complain about how your wife never wants to have sex.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:As a mom to an 8 year old girl, this thread makes me incredibly sad.

Maybe it was previously mentioned, but where the hell is the “Jerry Seinfeld and George Costanza we’re not good looking enough for their dating life” thread??

The fact that it’s probably mostly women negatively commenting on her looks is depressing.

My least favorite Office episodes is the “Is Hilary Swank hot?” B-plot one. Even worse than Scott’s Tots.

We have a long way to go.

Spare me. These are not mutually exclusive.

[Anonymous]

I've been re-watching the show too and I've been struck again by how attractive she was. Her body was phenomenal, she had great hair and just a general sensuality. I guess we all have different tastes.

---47 year old married mom of 3

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:As a mom to an 8 year old girl, this thread makes me incredibly sad.

Maybe it was previously mentioned, but where the hell is the “Jerry Seinfeld and George Costanza we’re not good looking enough for their dating life” thread??

The fact that it’s probably mostly women negatively commenting on her looks is depressing.

My least favorite Office episodes is the “Is Hilary Swank hot?” B-plot one. Even worse than Scott’s Tots.

We have a long way to go.

Here's the thing though, Jerry Seinfeld or Adam Sandler I might add are two ugly dudes who know they're ugly and generally are keen to recognize their 'stations' in life . They aren't out here acting like they're some kind of beauty mavens whose presence we should be grateful for . You could say the same thing for men in general. You seldom find men who are 4s and act like they're 8. Women on the other hand .............that's a different beast.

[Anonymous]

I’ve read through some of the debate on this thread and to me, seeing as how SJP dated JFK jr., none of the men on the show were out of her league. Her face is unique but not far below average and her body was fantastic. Definitely skinny but with some curves. The only one she dates that seemed a little odd to me was The New Yankee” in that episode, but that’s more because I assume pro athletes date women in their 20s.

[Anonymous]

Completely agree, op. She was way out of her league, even with the body.

At best, she’s a 6

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Completely agree, op. She was way out of her league, even with the body.

At best, she’s a 6

You're being too kind .