POSSIBLE SPOILER Are you talking about the boy? The son of the other judge? |
I mostly listen to Stephen King's books and some of the narrators are better than others. I read everything he comes out with and I personally thought Never Flinch was a bit slower/duller than more recent works like Holly and the collection of short stories (You Like it Darker, I think?). |
+1000 That show was amazing. I haven't read the book because of the mixed reviews and I loved the show so much I don't want to dislike the book. |
|
Just finished Julie Chan Is Dead by Liann Zhang
It's somewhat similar to Yellowface in plot (this isn't spoiling anything) - a young woman takes over her dead identical twin's life The end was freaking weird and it sort of fell apart for me by then but I liked probably 75% of it well enough 2.75/5 |
When I was in grad school for creative writing I remember we had a big discussion in one of my classes about why you get great book/ bad movie/tv adaption or average-at-best book with a great adaptation and there are not a lot of exceptions or in-between situations. The only instance I could think of where I truly loved a book and the film of it was A Clockwork Orange. (But that film has about the biggest problem it could have, which is in the casting. I think I love that film as much as I do because of Malcolm Mcdowell's performance, but he was way too old to play Alex. The Alex in the book is only 15 and he is younger than any of the rest of the gang, which he is running. What the authorities do to him when they catch him -- deep psychological conditioning by combining his beloved Beethoven with torture and images of crime and violence -- is a very different proposition with a teenager as opposed to a young adult. The Alex in the film is old enough that a major them of the book disappears.) Anybody have instances of where you loved both the book and film/show that arose from it? |
|
Harry potter
The Martian Project Hail Mary comes close |
I agree with all of these films being great adaptions of the books. With Project Hail Mary I'll say the film is different from the book but I think they made the right choice to do it the way they did. I also think the two, along with the Harry Potter books, make for a great combo package, where reading or watching alone doesn't give you the full story. |
You could make a good argument that these are not "great" books. I know people would come for me on this. And I'm not necessarily saying it is the case, just making the argument. I haven't read Project Hail Mary. |
Pachinko. I actually think the series is better than the book, maybe because it's so visually stunning. |
| Just started the Ten Year Affair by Erin Somers. Its funny and getting right into the story so far I'm liking it. |
What it is not great about them? HP is a freaking phenomenon. The Martian made it to film (w a major movie star) from a self published book. |
The Shining by Stephen King— loved both the book and the movie Life of Chuck also by King. Loved the short story and loved the movie even more |
Remains of the Day Love Anthony Hopkins and the subtle humor in the book. |
The Audible version of Kin was beautiful. I loved the writing and the narration. |
|
Biography of Sir Thomas More
|