
That's fine. We won, and TJ won as a result. |
Taliban won too. Doesn't mean Afghanistan won. |
If woke-ism and race-based admissions are the criteria for winning, then yes, TJ won. Agree on the "flowery words" reference, and wonder how "much healthier academic environment" is defined... |
...... you're seriously comparing one of the greatest geopolitical tragedies of the last century to the admissions process for a high school? Another candidate for the Mount Rushmore of most insensitive, tone-deaf things said on this forum. |
Not last century. Last week! |
A process that results in 75% representation of a collection of races that amount to 20% of the population of an area is pretty damn race-based. |
"of the last century". good grief. |
Nothing is defined. We won. Buzz off. |
Just because one side won doesn't mean the country, organization won. Meaning of the analogy. Response to we won, therefore all is good post. |
TJ admissions are race-blind and that poster is either attempting to mislead or just horribly uninformed. |
The levels of self delusion and word twisting...this whole exercise of eliminating an objective race blind test, adding a bunch of experience factors including race based ones was expressly intended to reduce certain a races and increase others. It is an exercise in complete futility as a lottery gifted school is just not something people will aspire for. So no winners at all. Can someone please shut down this thread. Makes me sick. You guys won in your misguided efforts in destroying a school by treating it as some kind of spoil of war, benefit. It is not. It was the idea of excellence that made the school. Not some labs. And that aspirational idea helped the teachers, community, companies and the entire area. You could have easily increased diversity with actual quotas while still keeping it aspirational instead of just doing lazy, spiteful, value destroying and yes, utterly racist nonsense. |
That says it all. In your mind, TJ won because you got what you wanted. Many others believe that TJ lost and that the primary beneficiaries are going to be the top neighborhood high schools. They may not be TJs, but they are known quantities that stand to only get stronger with uncertainty introduced into the TJ admission process (and the sense that TJ now stands not for academic excellence, but retail pork barrel politics). |
I disagree, the 80% isn't good enough to compete |
Both TJ and those base schools will benefit tremendously. Schools like Langley, McLean, Chantilly, etc will be very well served by welcoming students who would have been among the back-end of the TJ population. TJ will benefit from an injection of fresh perspective and the admissions process will probably become even more popular (and therefore more competitive, raising the caliber of the student body) as talented students in different parts of the county actually become interested in attending. |
Just like those kids from the wealthy schools will be fine many equally gifted students from less affluent neighborhoods will benefit from TJ. This will make FCPS even better than ever. |