VYS Soccer - better or worse?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:How is the DA designation and involvement working out for Vienna-based boys?

Well for one thing Vienna has no DA designation.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:How is the DA designation and involvement working out for Vienna-based boys?

Well for one thing Vienna has no DA designation.

Vienna is now a part of VDA.

[Anonymous]

The boys teams consist of kids from Prince William County, with a few Fairfax and Loudoun players mixed in, and there are very, very few Vienna-based players, FYI.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The boys teams consist of kids from Prince William County, with a few Fairfax and Loudoun players mixed in, and there are very, very few Vienna-based players, FYI.

Well considering it was announced to VYS families after VDA tryouts concluded, that's not a big surprise. Let's allow it to play out a couple years before casting judgement on it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The boys teams consist of kids from Prince William County, with a few Fairfax and Loudoun players mixed in, and there are very, very few Vienna-based players, FYI.

Well considering it was announced to VYS families after VDA tryouts concluded, that's not a big surprise. Let's allow it to play out a couple years before casting judgement on it.

I was thinking Vienna would get involved mid-way only if they were able to place a few players. Why else lend out their fields to players coming from PW County.

[Anonymous]

Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

That is because there is essentially nothing in it for VYS.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

That is because there is essentially nothing in it for VYS.

VDA isn't as much an idea as it is a club a separate club that plays in the DA. I imagine if you had a son that was advanced you'd be trying to get in the roster since McLean's and Loudoun's DA teams are only for U12 and VDA is from U12 to U17.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

So this is just my perspective, but if there was a DA option, the interest would be coming from myself and my child, not necessarily from my club. While a Club could say they have best interests of each of their player's in mind, no youth club has enough bandwidth to ensure every player is playing at appropriately challenging level. They also can't know if the if parent/child have playing on a college team as goal, if it is then DA is path to ensure recruitment. I'm only saying a club doesn't have to approach me about how to different programs available for my player, I'm going to do research on my own. I'm now saying my way of thinking is the only way or the correct way; nonetheless your statement is a little confusing to me.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

That is because there is essentially nothing in it for VYS.

VDA isn't as much an idea as it is a club a separate club that plays in the DA. I imagine if you had a son that was advanced you'd be trying to get in the roster since McLean's and Loudoun's DA teams are only for U12 and VDA is from U12 to U17.

Well the idea being that the partner clubs in VDA offer a player pool for VDA to get first dibs on and draw from. The problem is, VDA is more aligned with PWSI and there is no real cohesive development plan that VDA has with any of the partner clubs.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The boys teams consist of kids from Prince William County, with a few Fairfax and Loudoun players mixed in, and there are very, very few Vienna-based players, FYI.

Well considering it was announced to VYS families after VDA tryouts concluded, that's not a big surprise. Let's allow it to play out a couple years before casting judgement on it.

If you really want to join a DA, why didn't you try out on your own? You actually need VYS to contact you and say it's OK? I'm I confused here?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

What do you expect VYS and VDA to "do with it"? VYS is simply offering up some field space that might work out for a game or two and perhaps a practice location. If you want to play DA then you must still contact the appropriate coach at VDA and tryout. If you make VDA you are no longer affiliated with VYS and you are a VDA player from that moment on.

So the only thing you need to know now are:

1. Does your kid want to play VDA?
2. Are you willing to drive to Howison for practice?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

What do you expect VYS and VDA to "do with it"? VYS is simply offering up some field space that might work out for a game or two and perhaps a practice location. If you want to play DA then you must still contact the appropriate coach at VDA and tryout. If you make VDA you are no longer affiliated with VYS and you are a VDA player from that moment on.

So the only thing you need to know now are:

1. Does your kid want to play VDA?
2. Are you willing to drive to Howison for practice?

I thought they would discuss what it means for the club, they might suggest top players try out, and actually mention it as a next step option since they are affiliated. Instead they have it on their website like it means something and do nothing with it with respect to players. Completely pointless. Yes, if we want to play DA, we will try out for an actual DA team.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

What do you expect VYS and VDA to "do with it"? VYS is simply offering up some field space that might work out for a game or two and perhaps a practice location. If you want to play DA then you must still contact the appropriate coach at VDA and tryout. If you make VDA you are no longer affiliated with VYS and you are a VDA player from that moment on.

So the only thing you need to know now are:

1. Does your kid want to play VDA?
2. Are you willing to drive to Howison for practice?

I thought they would discuss what it means for the club, they might suggest top players try out, and actually mention it as a next step option since they are affiliated. Instead they have it on their website like it means something and do nothing with it with respect to players. Completely pointless. Yes, if we want to play DA, we will try out for an actual DA team.

Well, the reality of the arrangement is pretty much what I have laid out. And yes, for the most part it is pointless. It does nothing for VYS other than provide a token carrot but make no mistake, VDA is a separate club and program and must be treated as such. Occasionally some VDA coaches may come to some games or practices and ask about a kid or two who stand out but that is about it.

At best they may have some intra club practices where they take a longer look at the overall player pool between VSA, PWSI and VYS but that is about it in terms of any formal gathering.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Yeah the VDA is an interesting idea but it will take another year or so to see what they do with it. My child is on the top
VYS team and they haven't mentioned a thing about it to any of us.

What do you expect VYS and VDA to "do with it"? VYS is simply offering up some field space that might work out for a game or two and perhaps a practice location. If you want to play DA then you must still contact the appropriate coach at VDA and tryout. If you make VDA you are no longer affiliated with VYS and you are a VDA player from that moment on.

So the only thing you need to know now are:

1. Does your kid want to play VDA?
2. Are you willing to drive to Howison for practice?

I thought they would discuss what it means for the club, they might suggest top players try out, and actually mention it as a next step option since they are affiliated. Instead they have it on their website like it means something and do nothing with it with respect to players. Completely pointless. Yes, if we want to play DA, we will try out for an actual DA team.

And then complain that only VYS Board Member's kids got an offer to tryout? Don't want to pile on, but if you haven't given it much thought, nothing wrong with saying "I'm not going to search for any more options unless my DC club asks me to do so". If my son played baseball, I wouldn't have the slightest clue about what is good, isn't good, for my son, and my goals would be to travel the fewest miles and pay the least amount.