Honors classes generally have a GPA minimum or a teacher recommendation requirement. It’s the school who generally sets gatekeeping; these aren’t honors or real intensified courses, they have the same curriculum. They are just a charade to pacify parents who are concerned with how under engaged their smart students are in school. |
This thread veered from the allegedly unmet needs of people’s SpEd students to the allegedly unmet needs of people’s gifted students 🤦♀️. I feel sorry for our school community that we cant see past the end of our own noses. Is everyone just going to complete the principal survey with a laundry list of what their particular child supposedly needs? |
Kids mandated by law to have their needs met (SOL requirements etc for accreditation), and kids with IEP or squeaky wheel parents are the only ones that will get any attention from the teachers and principal. Thats the reality of our overcrowded and overtaxed school; if you aren't advocating for your student, they will coast along without anyone checking in on them. If you are a wealthy family, and do a bunch of travel sports and know the career path for your child doesn't need strong academics, its a great fit as they can put the time into their sport and thrive there. Thats the mainstream APS parent. Parents who truly valued academics left for FFX or maybe private long ago. |
BS. The superiority of FFX county at the elementary level is really questionable. Larger class sizes and an inferior reading curriculum. But depending on where in the county wealthier cohort. Probably a wash. And no a high quality private schools are not going to be equivalent to public schools with a possible exception for a place like TJ |
DP. This is the dumbest logic I have ever seen. You can’t say something is outside of the norm without even knowing what the disability is or what the request was! You don’t even know why KM disagreed it could’ve been she wanted more testing or any number of other reasons not directly related to what the request was. |
Taylor has k-3 with 27/28 students so maybe in some idealized APS the classes are smaller than FCPS. FCPS gives homework and holds higher expectations for academic products. APS elementary is very focused on leveling the lower end in preparation for middle school, and that’s it. The parents actively campaign against homework in fact. |
If the request would be that identifying and not in the standard IEP accommodations list it is by definition outside the normal accommodations. But PP just like to be coy about what they were asking and throw unsupported complaints about KM. |
The irony of this whole fight over gifted kids actually getting services is that every North Arlington parent thinks their kid is gifted and even if they recognize that their kid isn’t they definitely don’t want them in any non gifted cohort. So gifted doesn’t actually mean anything within the parlance of APS, particularly at schools like Taylor and Jamestown, Nottingham, etc.
If it’s any consolidation, if you can afford to live in these districts, then it’s true that most of the kids are really bright in one way or another with very engaged educated parents and so your child’s peer group by definition is smart and that’s actually way more important to their educational path than 1 hour or whatever of special gifted services. Spending all your time with other bright motivated kids — even if the classroom lessons are boring sometimes — served my children now at elite schools just fine. |
My early elem kid has never been in a class with more than 20 kids. So very much in the real, non-idealized world that isn’t the case. There’s also just the added chaos of FCPS elementary schools having a larger total number of kids. There is very weak to nonexistent evidence of the effectiveness of homework for children in elementary school. Which is also why most of the better regarded private elementary schools tend not to have it for young children. So I’m not sure why you view that as a plus. |
What school? |
Any of the ones with small classes on this report: https://www.apsva.us/wp-content/uploads/sites/57/2025/01/Class-Size-Report-SY-24.25.pdf Taylor had zero K-3 classes with 27-28 kids this year, so either PP is lying or the report is wrong. |
IEPs are about much more than accommodations so you're wrong again. And even for an accommodation, there may be a specific accommodation that a student needed that was denied so it could be identifying. You are mixing up so much and I dont have time or patience to explain it to you. You think just because you did a little research now you're an expert. You have no idea what you're talking about but yet you want to lay blame on families when you have no idea what they have been through. You are CLUELESS. |
Hi KM |
What exactly do you mean besides accommodations? Do you mean services like coaching? There’s all the same thing. |
Oh boy. I love how you think you know it all - so much so that you are so very sure I did something wrong and not KM - when you know ZERO. ZILCH. NADA. Sit down. Have a seat. Listen to the people who have been through this instead of just dismissing them. You may learn something! |