Pyle/Whitman or Westland/BCC cluster better fit?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
|
hi DCUM Parents:
I know both are excellent choices, but which one do you think might be a better fit for our family? Below the specs: Single Mom with two boys, entering Middle School in 2023/24 SY (entering 5th grade in August). One earner household, we usually live in condo buildings (rent or own), international background and travels frequently, educated, well-traveled etc. Kids are smart, do well at school. We spend the summers overseas. What's important: strong academics, but also attention to emotional development/ caring teachers and school administration, sports, arts, music, international/global issues, smart-ambitious kids, nice parents (meaning down to earth, not too snotty if that is possible). Diversity is great, but due to our lifestyle and circle, we know people from diverse backgrounds (socio-economic and racial). I know there is always compromise in these questions, but would be interested in your feedback and experiences. Private is not possible due to $$$$, so looking for the best fit within MCPS. Would prefer to pick between these school zones due to proximity to work/ DC. Thank you! |
Anonymous
| My info might be outdated — I live in DC now, but grew up in Bethesda and went to Whitman. It seems like Westland/B-CC is the obvious choice because of housing options. Other than the buildings near the Westbard Giant, I’m not sure there are really condos in the Whitman district. Downtown Bethesda would offer way more choices. And the IB program would be ideal for an international family, no? Good luck with your choice! |
Anonymous
| OP here - thank you, but I am aware of the housing options. I am asking for feedback on the schools. Thanks! |
Anonymous
| Neither. |
Anonymous
Ok, so any suggestions then? |
Anonymous
| I can only speak to BCC, with one kid who went through Westland when it was still overcrowded and one who went to Silver Creek. Both boys btw, one who's big into sports and one who is decidedly not. My kids have had a great experience - they have a diverse array of friends and have been very happy. Academics at any MCPS HS are going to be what you make of it, but it's been rigorous and set my oldest up for success at a very selective college. I don't get the sense of cutthroat competition/pressure/snobbery, but it's very possible that we just missed those cliques. Silver Creek has been a stronger MS from our experience than Westland was, but I think that was simply because Westland was so insanely overcrowded when my oldest attended. |
Anonymous
| We have our kids in Whitman but we're aware of BCC through friends, I don't know if either will make a difference to your kids but for you, I suspect BCC would be the more familiar option. |
Anonymous
| I think you would fit in better at BCC, and they have the IB program. Plus, your kids can walk into downtown Bethesda or metro easily to see friends. Whitman is generally more suburban. In East Bethesda, you’ll find a lovely community with many expats and singles as well as married and divorced families. |
Anonymous
| I think your family could be happy at a lot of schools, but I’ll recommend ours, which is the Bannockburn/Pyle/Whitman cluster. Bannockburn has a very welcoming, down to earth parent community and the school has caring teachers and administrators. All three schools have tons of international families. It’s very easy to get involved in sports at all levels in Bethesda, but if you name the sports of interest we can give you tailored advice. Pyle and Whitman both have excellent orchestra and band programs. |
Anonymous
She mentioned “not snotty” 
|
Anonymous
The Bannockburn, Cabin John, Glen Echo and Carderock communities aren’t snotty in the slightest. The areas along the river attract nature lovers. I know people claim that there are a lot of snotty people at Whitman, but that certainly hasn’t been our experience with two kids who have gone all the way through and another at Pyle. |
Anonymous
| OP here - thank you everyone. I just did not get the sense that there are a lot of single parents/ parents with more modest income at the Pyle/Whitman cluster....since as someone pointed out, not too many condo bldgs, mainly SFHs. |
Anonymous
|
We live in the Whitman catchment, have friends in the BCC area. Very similar but as another PP said, BCC is a bit more urban and is near downtown bethesda.
We love Whitman and know a variety of family types including single parents, international families, same sex families, etc |
Anonymous
We are the reverse— kids went to BCC, friends at Whitman and I’d agree they are very similar. BCC is a little bit less wealthy/more diverse (as you note more apt-living if that matters) and has the IB program but I think your family would do fine either way. |
Anonymous
| thank you everyone - OP here. |