I have. South Arlington is exploding with kids. What I am worried about is that we will end up with a bifricated school system, worse than now. Seems like we're trying to get a UMC South high... |
I think its really misguided to assume that just declaring the new Career Center space a second HB, or any other choice program will somehow make people want to go there. Arlington Tech is already under-enrolled. There is an entire thread on this board about why people aren't signing up for Arlington Tech and the most common response is the lack of sports/arts/amenities. Why would an extra 2000 students volunteer to go there when they can't get 300 students to want to go there? Even with a different curriculum option?
And the thing that always gets ignored about HB is that they have facilities and amenities! If you look at HB they have a really strong performing arts focus and have facilities to match that. That new HB school will have field space, an indoor gym, art studio, big theatre, separate black box studio, drama room, orchestra room and a kiln room. The program has 5 dedicated stories for 700 students an enormously expensive brand new building. No wonder the wait list is a million years long. The current CIP plan for the Career Center is throw a new story on a dilapidated building and build 1 room that is both a gym and theater for over twice the number students. No fields, no anything else. No one is going to run to sign up for that no matter how many times they call it a second HB. Cause it won't be a 2nd HB. And just calling it STEM isn't going to trick families into sending their kids there either. Not without state of the art science or tech facilities (robotics rooms, science labs, ect.) I've even heard talk of making it a performing arts choice school. With no auditorium. Or rehearsal space. Again who is going to sign up for that? The school board/county are trying to build the cheapest lowest quality school they can get away with and pretending that people will choose to attend it is ridiculous. If they aren't forced to build a quality school, then overcrowding and lack of opportunities will impact every high school student when the neighborhood schools are overloaded and the Career Center is still empty. |
A choice program that only UMC South Arlington families choose into is the same result. At least a neighborhood school has the potential to absorb some of the affordable housing and low market housing communities away from Wakefield. |
What's your priority here, is it more important to have enough seats for all of our high school students or that the schools have more balanced diversity? Does diversity provide such a benefit that it won't matter if some of the students won't see it because they've been pushed into doing high school online from home? If they've had to put high schools on swing schedules so that at any given time a quarter of the student population is on break? If students pushed into expansion programs are effectively forced to drop extracurriculars because of the travel time involved in getting back to a base high school for those activities? These are the kinds of things being discussed to manage the high school capacity crisis if we don't get a fourth high school. I want our schools to be more diverse, but I don't see the benefit of that if we have to destroy the high school experience for a whole lot of kids to do that. After all, it's not the Yorktown kids who are going to be affected by this, they'll be fine. It'll be W-L getting a million trailers to take on extra kids. It'll be W-L and Wakefield students pushed into the expansion programs because they're physically closer. It'll be the lower-achieving students (who are disproportionately ED and/or racial minorities) who will be pushed into online programs while in-school space is reserved for AP and IB classes. |
But they don't have the money to do anything else, without cutting other needed construction. At least if it's choice, nobody is going to be forced to go to a ill-conceived "program." There are plenty of kids who are not college-bound, or who are maybe not liking to get into a traditional or elite four-year college. This is their program. |
There are not 2000+ students in Arlington who are going to willingly go to a non-college prep program. And that is the size the County needs the Career Center to be for the overcrowding to be alleviated. They are having a hard time getting 400 students to go to that program. Where are the other 1600 students going to come from? When no one signs up what will they do? Eventually Arlington is going to have to spend some amount of money to attract enough students (equally from all 3 other high schools) to make thier system work. Or make it a neighborhood school which also means spending money. The county has pursued population growth policies through its development, zoning and affordable housing powers. Now they (and we) are going to have to pay up for the consequences of those policies. |
They are having a hard time because they are barking up the wrong tree. They've been trying to sell Arl Tech to UMC families. It isn't happening. And yes, I think there will be 2,000 students in Arlington who are not going to wind up at a four-year college. They should be at the Career Center. It won't pull equally from all 3 HS, but boundaries can be redrawn. |
Um. No. Their program is Arlington Tech. And there are plenty of seats available! Seriously. This is so frustrating. Our options are a choice school, crowded into a small area that is shared with 4 schools where students have to go back to their overcrowded home school in order to play sports or be involved in drama or music (and which may not fill all the 2300 needed seats) or a comprehensive high school with adequate amenities (not talking anything crazy here - track, 2 fields, a theater that doesn’t act as a gym, a cafeteria) that wstudents will want to go to and not seem like they are getting less than. I wouldn’t send my kids to a less than school, even if they weren’t interested in a traditional program. Do those kids deserve a subpar experience? |
The elementary school sits on four acres of its own. The middle school sits on well over 30 acres. The Career center site is 12 acres. Yorktown sits on 11+ acres (plus the adjacent Greenbrier Park facilities). TJMS/Community Center and the new elementary school sit on 12 acres (plus the 15 acres of adjacent parkland/facilities for a total of 27 acres). That's 2000 students on Yorktown's 11 acres; 1750 elementary and middle school students on 12 acres at TJ; up to 4,000 students being considered for the Career Center's 12 acres; and a mere 1000-ish students on 32 plus acres at Kenmore (not counting Carlin Springs students and their four acres). So, you are suggesting that we can't put a high school or anything else on 36+ acres of land because there is already a middle school and an elementary school (which are separated by about 30 acres)?!?!? |
How about K-8 immersion and open 600 seats at Claremont for neighborhood, or if you must, Montessori? Open up a few hundred plus middle seats at Gunston in the process by relocating 6-8 immersion with the new immersion location at Kenmore. |
Yes. That is what the SB and CB are saying. Welcome to the conversation. Now move on. |
Districted to it or not, it impacts the enrollment at all the other high schools and programs. So it does impact you. But no, you don't have to get involved. We will all decide your fate for you. |
Libby's 6 am - 11 pm school day is not what you are interpreting it to mean. She has been promoting this idea for years - extend the "school day" for SHIFTS so that the facility can accommodate more students and schedules can accommodate different students' needs, like those who need to work part-time or whatever. I don't agree with that approach AT ALL. But it is not what you here, and a number of others "out there" in the community are making it out to be. Another option is A, B, C, D school sessions where you have a year-round calendar with students starting at different quarters. The building is used all year long, the students still get their long break but just not necessarily June-September. As we gear-up for the new profile of a high school graduate and students need to take internships, this offers an excellent way to give them a full quarter to do an internship without all the students clamoring for them in the summer. Also gives businesses constant extra labor throughout the year. |
So what is it that they have planned for the site then? Surely they aren't just letting it sit there forever. Maybe it won't be a school, but it will be something. What is that something? |
Sure. Let’s outsource to the private sector.
Great idea. |