Not sure I understand your comment. Can you clarify what you mean? |
I find it hard to believe because of timing. What schools that would be a reach for a kid like this have released EA results? What, are you in at MIT and Michigan? Congrats but that’s two data points, not a trend. |
Why would you equate poor outcomes to a single test score? It’s true that schools aren’t deciding who do admit based on small 10 point SAT differences. It’s likely that there were other gaps in the application - blaming it on a test score is just the easiest way to avoid hurting your child’s feelings too much. |
The PP is saying the opposite: that his kid had a near-perfect test score, counselor said it wouldn’t matter, but they applied EA to a dozen T10 non-tech schools — and got into all of them. Some of us think this anecdote is a fabrication. |
Ahh, I see. It wasn’t worded terribly well. But I agree - a test score above the 25th percentile at a school will never make an application, unless they are a state flagship who care about them for scholarships . |
DS specified Economics and his friend applied for Engineering. We are in FCPS (not in TJ). Just a really wide range of activities nothing national. |
Or ask AI to adapt the 3-4 supplements you write to match other schools prompts, then sit down and spend 1 hour humanizing it back to your voice. Saved days. You can also pay someone to write them for you after you meet with them for 1-2 hours and sketch out your answers to each “type” of prompt. Cost is about $1200 an essay. |
Both of those methods sound highly unethical. I can't believe we're now paying $1200 for random adults to ghostwrite our children's essays. |
Yes to AI. That’s absolutely true if you’re willing to go that route. I genuinely think AI can be very helpful here as long as DC can edit carefully in their own voice and can eliminate the obvious/telltale signs (m-dash, multiple lists of three things, weave/tapestry metaphors etc.) My true hope is that continued improvements in AI will force schools to drop this supplant nonsense. Hopefully by the time DC2 applies!! |
$1000 generally in my area. |
How? When an adult wrote the essays, they don't have the kids' authentic voice. How did they fare? Got in T20s? |
Yes to T20. It's "editing". Keep kids' stories/hooks and create a much more detailed and vivid depiction of Why Major and Why School that goes much deeper beyond classes or professors or clubs. Hard to explain. Kid had a great draft. The final product was so much tighter, bespoke, and detailed. Unique to kid too. Sounded like DC bc it used her original, only better. Ask around in your circle. |
| $1000/essay? So Fall season can easily bring in 6 figures for a freelancer? |
And you paid $1000 per essay? How many in total? |
| There are “reach” schools and “out of reach” schools. Be smart. If you are not in top 10-20% of class, many schools are simply out of reach. If you apply to the top 10 or ivies as your reach school when you are only in top 1/2 of class, you are wasting your reaches. Reaches need to be realistic for your stats. |