As the kid of parents who spent huge sums of money to give us the best of a lot of things, I can assure you that pales compared to getting full acceptance, love and support from your parents. |
|
I didn't read all of these posts but object to the premise that your kids have "one shot" at life. You have one physical life, but life is about invention and reinvention. My favorite people are those who are constantly learning, adjusting, and growing in life.
Life isn't private kindergarten or bust. |
If you gave dino ones, your kid would have a better chance of ending up with a PhD in a STEM field. |
It's hard to see when it hits so close to home for many . . . . |
|
I tell them constantly that I want three things from them:
- Be able to take care of yourself financially - Do what makes you happy - Be kind There are caveats to each of the above things and it's up to them to figure out what their caveats are. Do you like expensive stuff? Then plan for a lucrative career that won't make you miserable. Are you easily frustrated, anxious? What can I do help you learn how to make number three easier, then? Because it's harder to be kind when you're stressed out. I have a cousin who moved to a remote country as a young 20-something and lived quite happily with only the things in her backpack for many years. She's now an adult with her own family and she lives a very unconventional lifestyle with very little. Her parents were always supportive of her finding her way, even though it was extremely contrary to what they had planned for her. I want my kids to feel the same kind of love and support to find their own means to become independent, self-sufficient, critical thinkers, whatever that might look like for them. |
| Your children have the ability to adapt to far more than you think. Do you really think that if something terrible happened, their lives would be ruined with no chance of moving forward? |
That could have been taught at home, with a tutor, during distance learning (you don't know that it wouldn't have), in first grade, etc. |
This, to me, this is a situation where a child truly only has one shot, and the parent has an ongoing fight to give it to them. |
Oh, so you're saying that they can't be happy if they separate, divorce or choose not to marry. That staying married, even if the other person does crazy or dishonest things over and over, that's the only way to be happy. Got it. |
Yep. |
This makes a lot more sense than 30k on a private preschool only to then go back to public. |
Yes this. I'm 39 and my whole is completely reinvented from my first go at it when I was 19. You can have any sort of life you want, and you can change what you want at any time. |
Disagree, strongly. My grandmother's era (70ish years ago), kindergarten didn't exist in a lot of places. When it did, it was focused on social skills and teaching what we consider preschool academics now. Kids learned to read in first grade (yes, my grandmother the hoarder has proof of her work and classmates'). My mother's era (50ish years ago), kindergarten was everywhere but not required, and it was still focused on social skills and preschool level academics... my grandmother was hired without a degree (school paid for her to take three community college classes) to teach Perception, the precursor to today's PE. My era (30ish years ago) had requirements for attending kindergarten in some areas, but it was still half day, and while some schools did three groupings for kids based on abilities coming in (mine did, and kids varied from not knowing the alphabet up to reading chapter books), others did not; that was also at the height of gifted and talented programs nationwide. Now? It's incredibly hard to find g&e programs, getting an IEP that actually works for the child is hard, teachers teach just to the middle, and kids are in full day kindergarten and expected to read if not before they start, at least by the time they get out. Some kids are ready to read at 4. Others won't have it click until 7-8, no matter what is done. That's why Montessori allows children to work at their own pace. It's why Waldorf doesn't teach reading until all the children should be ready. It's why most research says not to focus on whether a child can read (and not to pressure them!) until 7-8. |
I'm sorry to tell you, OP, but if you really want your kid to be successful you should have kept him in the private school from K-12. |
...and then you sent him to public school for 1st where all those kids had been home the previous year? Do you even hear yourself? You are insufferable. |