How to not answer a question

Anonymous
I just traveled a long distance twice in 2 months to visit ill parent and sibling keeps texting me when I am coming back to help. Parent does not need around the clock care. Keeps texting me saying they want to make a schedule. I was just there. Not sure when I am going back. Parent has a lot of help - big family. How can I answer these direct texts asking “are you coming up tomorrow?” and “when are you coming back?”
Anonymous
You should answer the question. "I don't have plans to come back right now."

If you're willing to call your parent on a regular basis, like on Sundays, tell them you'll do that. If your sibling is doing stuff like cleaning and repairs and you can afford to pay for someone else to do it, do that. If your sibling is trying to plan a vacation and know someone is available for your parent during that time, maybe you can work with them on that.

Honestly there is a huge space between "round the clock care" and "twice in two months" so it does sound like you sibling is asking for help. You can say no but it's courteous to say it clearly so they know they can't plan on you helping.
jsmith123
Member Offline
OP I think in this case you need to be direct, even if the answer is one that your siblings won't like.

"I have no plans to come back at this time."

But, are you sure that you're not putting an undue burden on them by doing this? If you are, consider other ways you can help (maybe by putting $ towards some part-time in-home care if you can).
Anonymous
jsmith123 wrote:OP I think in this case you need to be direct, even if the answer is one that your siblings won't like.

"I have no plans to come back at this time."

But, are you sure that you're not putting an undue burden on them by doing this? If you are, consider other ways you can help (maybe by putting $ towards some part-time in-home care if you can).


Thank you. I do give money and I have groceries delivered plus I pay for her house. Problem is other siblings always come when I come not to see me but because they have something nearby and I end up having to stay in a hotel and pay for the hotel even though I pay for the house. They don’t wear masks or social distance.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I just traveled a long distance twice in 2 months to visit ill parent and sibling keeps texting me when I am coming back to help. Parent does not need around the clock care. Keeps texting me saying they want to make a schedule. I was just there. Not sure when I am going back. Parent has a lot of help - big family. How can I answer these direct texts asking “are you coming up tomorrow?” and “when are you coming back?”


"I don't have any plans right now. I'll let you know when I do. In the meantime, I'm doing XXXX [sending groceries, hiring a cleaning service, or whatever else you can reasonably do] to help out."
Anonymous
It sounds like there is a disconnect between what your parents' needs are and what you feel is your responsibility to your parents and your siblings. That may be why you're getting pressure from one of your siblings.

Do you know what your parent's needs are and do you know how much of a burden your sib is carrying?

It doesn't seem unreasonable for one sibling to pressure another if one sibling is bearing 99% of the burden of caring for aging parents. You need to have a clear conversation with your siblings about what your parents need and what each person (including you) is doing to help meet that need. (Your hotel bill is not part of that equation btw.) Then you should work with your sibling to set up a list of responsibilities and a visiting schedule.

You need to do your part OP. No one gets a pass.
Anonymous
This isn't about answering a question. It's about figuring out how to get your parents' needs met, everyone doing their part and everyone knowing what they can expect from the others. It is not fair to be vague or not to provide a schedule or a list of things they can expect you to take care of. Throwing money at it isn't enough, especially if you are in better financial shape than your siblings.

In my family two of us lived far away and three lived in the same town. Also I had some SILs who lived in the town. My sibling who didn't live near, didn't help at all. We knew he wouldn't and it was better that we knew even if it was a jerk thing to do. I took care of everything financial - making sure insurance was up to date, medical bills paid, taxes done, etc. I also took care of everything medical - making sure appointments were set, rides were arranged, that information was conveyed to the doctors (they didn't talk to me, but did take information from me), etc. And, I took care of all quality of life issues - I went up every 4-6 weeks and took her shopping, to the grocery store (she loved to go grocery shopping) and out to eat. I took her on trips. I picked her grandkids up for visits. I took her to all events - weddings, funerals, etc. One of my siblings took care of all repairs and putting together anything that needed to be put together and also check ins at least weekly. Another checked in daily and a third did all of the driving, which was huge because despite serious medical issues, my mom worked until her death. One of them also took care of the groceries, but at this point, I don't remember which one anymore. This worked for so many years because everything was covered and everyone knew what to expect. If one of us could not fulfill our part, we arranged for another to cover it.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:This isn't about answering a question. It's about figuring out how to get your parents' needs met, everyone doing their part and everyone knowing what they can expect from the others. It is not fair to be vague or not to provide a schedule or a list of things they can expect you to take care of. Throwing money at it isn't enough, especially if you are in better financial shape than your siblings.

In my family two of us lived far away and three lived in the same town. Also I had some SILs who lived in the town. My sibling who didn't live near, didn't help at all. We knew he wouldn't and it was better that we knew even if it was a jerk thing to do. I took care of everything financial - making sure insurance was up to date, medical bills paid, taxes done, etc. I also took care of everything medical - making sure appointments were set, rides were arranged, that information was conveyed to the doctors (they didn't talk to me, but did take information from me), etc. And, I took care of all quality of life issues - I went up every 4-6 weeks and took her shopping, to the grocery store (she loved to go grocery shopping) and out to eat. I took her on trips. I picked her grandkids up for visits. I took her to all events - weddings, funerals, etc. One of my siblings took care of all repairs and putting together anything that needed to be put together and also check ins at least weekly. Another checked in daily and a third did all of the driving, which was huge because despite serious medical issues, my mom worked until her death. One of them also took care of the groceries, but at this point, I don't remember which one anymore. This worked for so many years because everything was covered and everyone knew what to expect. If one of us could not fulfill our part, we arranged for another to cover it.


"Parent does not need around the clock care"
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:This isn't about answering a question. It's about figuring out how to get your parents' needs met, everyone doing their part and everyone knowing what they can expect from the others. It is not fair to be vague or not to provide a schedule or a list of things they can expect you to take care of. Throwing money at it isn't enough, especially if you are in better financial shape than your siblings.

In my family two of us lived far away and three lived in the same town. Also I had some SILs who lived in the town. My sibling who didn't live near, didn't help at all. We knew he wouldn't and it was better that we knew even if it was a jerk thing to do. I took care of everything financial - making sure insurance was up to date, medical bills paid, taxes done, etc. I also took care of everything medical - making sure appointments were set, rides were arranged, that information was conveyed to the doctors (they didn't talk to me, but did take information from me), etc. And, I took care of all quality of life issues - I went up every 4-6 weeks and took her shopping, to the grocery store (she loved to go grocery shopping) and out to eat. I took her on trips. I picked her grandkids up for visits. I took her to all events - weddings, funerals, etc. One of my siblings took care of all repairs and putting together anything that needed to be put together and also check ins at least weekly. Another checked in daily and a third did all of the driving, which was huge because despite serious medical issues, my mom worked until her death. One of them also took care of the groceries, but at this point, I don't remember which one anymore. This worked for so many years because everything was covered and everyone knew what to expect. If one of us could not fulfill our part, we arranged for another to cover it.


"Parent does not need around the clock care"


Clearly neither did mine since my mom worked until the day of her death.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:This isn't about answering a question. It's about figuring out how to get your parents' needs met, everyone doing their part and everyone knowing what they can expect from the others. It is not fair to be vague or not to provide a schedule or a list of things they can expect you to take care of. Throwing money at it isn't enough, especially if you are in better financial shape than your siblings.

In my family two of us lived far away and three lived in the same town. Also I had some SILs who lived in the town. My sibling who didn't live near, didn't help at all. We knew he wouldn't and it was better that we knew even if it was a jerk thing to do. I took care of everything financial - making sure insurance was up to date, medical bills paid, taxes done, etc. I also took care of everything medical - making sure appointments were set, rides were arranged, that information was conveyed to the doctors (they didn't talk to me, but did take information from me), etc. And, I took care of all quality of life issues - I went up every 4-6 weeks and took her shopping, to the grocery store (she loved to go grocery shopping) and out to eat. I took her on trips. I picked her grandkids up for visits. I took her to all events - weddings, funerals, etc. One of my siblings took care of all repairs and putting together anything that needed to be put together and also check ins at least weekly. Another checked in daily and a third did all of the driving, which was huge because despite serious medical issues, my mom worked until her death. One of them also took care of the groceries, but at this point, I don't remember which one anymore. This worked for so many years because everything was covered and everyone knew what to expect. If one of us could not fulfill our part, we arranged for another to cover it.


"Parent does not need around the clock care"


Clearly neither did mine since my mom worked until the day of her death.


DP. Bravo to the PP for understanding what it means to be a responsible child to an aging parent. OP you need to pay attention. The PP has demonstrated that even though her parent was working, she still found a way to help her mother and to be useful to her.

Step up, OP, and do what you need to do. It sounds like at least one of your siblings needs you to become more responsible.
Anonymous
Ask what kind of schedule Sibling is looking for. Reiterate that it is your understanding Parent does not need round-the-clock care and you are taking care of the bills and groceries. Suggest if there is a need for a schedule then maybe the family needs to set up a Google calendar so you can see where there are gaps as you’ll need to request leave time from work in advance.
Anonymous
Stop texting and pick up the phone.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:It sounds like there is a disconnect between what your parents' needs are and what you feel is your responsibility to your parents and your siblings. That may be why you're getting pressure from one of your siblings.

Do you know what your parent's needs are and do you know how much of a burden your sib is carrying?

It doesn't seem unreasonable for one sibling to pressure another if one sibling is bearing 99% of the burden of caring for aging parents. You need to have a clear conversation with your siblings about what your parents need and what each person (including you) is doing to help meet that need. (Your hotel bill is not part of that equation btw.) Then you should work with your sibling to set up a list of responsibilities and a visiting schedule.

You need to do your part OP. No one gets a pass.


NP. The above is absolutely ridiculous. OP is paying for housing. That’s huge. OPs parents had a responsibility to provide for their own retirement, btw.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:This isn't about answering a question. It's about figuring out how to get your parents' needs met, everyone doing their part and everyone knowing what they can expect from the others. It is not fair to be vague or not to provide a schedule or a list of things they can expect you to take care of. Throwing money at it isn't enough, especially if you are in better financial shape than your siblings.

In my family two of us lived far away and three lived in the same town. Also I had some SILs who lived in the town. My sibling who didn't live near, didn't help at all. We knew he wouldn't and it was better that we knew even if it was a jerk thing to do. I took care of everything financial - making sure insurance was up to date, medical bills paid, taxes done, etc. I also took care of everything medical - making sure appointments were set, rides were arranged, that information was conveyed to the doctors (they didn't talk to me, but did take information from me), etc. And, I took care of all quality of life issues - I went up every 4-6 weeks and took her shopping, to the grocery store (she loved to go grocery shopping) and out to eat. I took her on trips. I picked her grandkids up for visits. I took her to all events - weddings, funerals, etc. One of my siblings took care of all repairs and putting together anything that needed to be put together and also check ins at least weekly. Another checked in daily and a third did all of the driving, which was huge because despite serious medical issues, my mom worked until her death. One of them also took care of the groceries, but at this point, I don't remember which one anymore. This worked for so many years because everything was covered and everyone knew what to expect. If one of us could not fulfill our part, we arranged for another to cover it.


"Parent does not need around the clock care"


Clearly neither did mine since my mom worked until the day of her death.


DP. Bravo to the PP for understanding what it means to be a responsible child to an aging parent. OP you need to pay attention. The PP has demonstrated that even though her parent was working, she still found a way to help her mother and to be useful to her.

Step up, OP, and do what you need to do. It sounds like at least one of your siblings needs you to become more responsible.


Also ridiculous. It’s usually the sibling that can’t actually pay for anything that makes the “you can’t just throw money at things” statement. All of this would be way harder if parents were homeless or they had to live at said sibling’s house.

OP, you’re doing great. Just answer truthfully that you’ve already been up recently and are contributing a great deal financially. Let the chips fall where they may. I hope your parents were good to you,
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:This isn't about answering a question. It's about figuring out how to get your parents' needs met, everyone doing their part and everyone knowing what they can expect from the others. It is not fair to be vague or not to provide a schedule or a list of things they can expect you to take care of. Throwing money at it isn't enough, especially if you are in better financial shape than your siblings.

In my family two of us lived far away and three lived in the same town. Also I had some SILs who lived in the town. My sibling who didn't live near, didn't help at all. We knew he wouldn't and it was better that we knew even if it was a jerk thing to do. I took care of everything financial - making sure insurance was up to date, medical bills paid, taxes done, etc. I also took care of everything medical - making sure appointments were set, rides were arranged, that information was conveyed to the doctors (they didn't talk to me, but did take information from me), etc. And, I took care of all quality of life issues - I went up every 4-6 weeks and took her shopping, to the grocery store (she loved to go grocery shopping) and out to eat. I took her on trips. I picked her grandkids up for visits. I took her to all events - weddings, funerals, etc. One of my siblings took care of all repairs and putting together anything that needed to be put together and also check ins at least weekly. Another checked in daily and a third did all of the driving, which was huge because despite serious medical issues, my mom worked until her death. One of them also took care of the groceries, but at this point, I don't remember which one anymore. This worked for so many years because everything was covered and everyone knew what to expect. If one of us could not fulfill our part, we arranged for another to cover it.


"Parent does not need around the clock care"


Clearly neither did mine since my mom worked until the day of her death.


DP. Bravo to the PP for understanding what it means to be a responsible child to an aging parent. OP you need to pay attention. The PP has demonstrated that even though her parent was working, she still found a way to help her mother and to be useful to her.

Step up, OP, and do what you need to do. It sounds like at least one of your siblings needs you to become more responsible.


Also ridiculous. It’s usually the sibling that can’t actually pay for anything that makes the “you can’t just throw money at things” statement. All of this would be way harder if parents were homeless or they had to live at said sibling’s house.

OP, you’re doing great. Just answer truthfully that you’ve already been up recently and are contributing a great deal financially. Let the chips fall where they may. I hope your parents were good to you,


"Pay for the house" doesn't have a lot of meaning for most parts of this country where housing is very inexpensive. The sibling is giving the gift of time which is the more precious commodity. It sounds like OP is the one willing to throw money ... but obviously she isn't throwing enough. So she needs to put up or shut up. Word.
post reply Forum Index » Family Relationships
Message Quick Reply
Go to: