Feeling so guilty - Found out friend lied about break-up reason

Anonymous
Let it go. She suffered enough. You are doing it for you, not her.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Good for Jane. I'm so happy for her that she escaped an abusive relationship.

If you weren't very close friends, I would let it go. She didn't reach out to any of you - she made a clean break because that's what she wanted and needed to do.

I don't think you need to feel guilty - if you had known, obviously you would have reacted much differently.
Like Jane, you were also fooled into believing this guy was a decent human being.

Has he gotten into rehab or worked his issues out? I don't think I could continue to be friends with him.



While I'd appreciate an apology from my XH's family, one from his friends isn't as needed. They were his victims, too, in a way. He manipulated them to think I was this poor little thing he rescued from poverty who turned ungrateful as soon as I was financially independent. I would never think they knew about the abuse and remained silent. His family is another story.
Anonymous
Reach out, keep it simple, don't expect a reply. I think it's the right thing to do.
ThatBetch
Member Offline
Definitely message her. All the PPs saying "it's in the past" are jerks. Yes, it's in the past, but it still happened, and you were still part of the suck.

Own your part of the suck.

Don't put any kind of expectation on her (you may want to lead with "I want you to know that I don't expect any sort of reply..."), but definitely take responsibility for being a judgmental jerk who believed a (bullshit) one-sided account and shunned someone without even bothering to check facts.

She may never reply. Don't poke at her, don't pester her. But there is no wrong time to apologize, without strings, for having screwed up.
Anonymous
ThatBetch wrote:Definitely message her. All the PPs saying "it's in the past" are jerks. Yes, it's in the past, but it still happened, and you were still part of the suck.

Own your part of the suck.

Don't put any kind of expectation on her (you may want to lead with "I want you to know that I don't expect any sort of reply..."), but definitely take responsibility for being a judgmental jerk who believed a (bullshit) one-sided account and shunned someone without even bothering to check facts.

She may never reply. Don't poke at her, don't pester her. But there is no wrong time to apologize, without strings, for having screwed up.


I agree. He basically gaslighted her. I think a message that conveys you are sorry, but that you do not expect a response from her would be a lovely gesture.

It's these little acts of kindness that go a long way.
Anonymous
I would leave her alone. If I were her, I would not want to hear from you at this point if you were really John's friend and not mine in the first place, and I had put the whole incident behind me. When I was in college, I was sexually assaulted by a friend and it broke up our friend group. When one of the women who went to "his" side emailed me 7 years later and apologized, I found it irritating. She was always more this guy's friend than mine, and hearing from her just brought back horrible memories.
Anonymous
If I were Jane I would really appreciate the apology, even though it's years late.
Anonymous
Jane knew that you all thought she broke off the wedding b/c she cheated and never bothered to try to convince any of you otherwise. This sounds to me like a woman who wants to be left alone. She broke all ties quickly and completely which was smart.

I would not contact her. If she cared what you all thought, she would have filled you all in back when this all happened.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:If I were Jane I would really appreciate the apology, even though it's years late.


+1 Me, too.
Anonymous
I would reach out and keep it short and sweet.

Hi Jane,
I don't know if you remember me - I was one of John's friends who knew him since middle school. Anyway, he just confessed the real reason the wedding was called off and I wanted to reach out to you and apologize. For not knowing my long-time friend would do this, for not picking up on any signs you may have been giving out. I see that you're married now, and I don't want to disrupt your life. I just wanted to let you know the truth came out now, and I 100% respect your decision three years ago.
Best,
Laura"
Anonymous
As the victim in an abusive relationship, I would appreciate an apology all these years later. Just don't try a sob story on me that tries to paint yourself as if only you had known you would have been supportive of me.

Acknowledge that you made a conscious choice to throw our friendship away and choose you friend without finding out my side of the story.

One of the most corrosive things about abuse is the secrecy of it and the gas lighting (when the abuser makes you try to feel as if it is your fault the relationship isn't working and that what he is doing is not abusive). If you came to me and said you had just found out about the abuse, and you are so sorry that you didn't support me and sorrier still that you didn't even bother to ask how I was, I would appreciate it, even all these years later.

I wouldn't be friends with you because your track record of friendship judgment sucks, but it would help me in some small way to know that another person knows the reality of the situation. I certainly will never get that acknowledgement from my abuser.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I would let sleeping dogs lie. She has moved on and she's happy, that's what matters. Chalk this up as a lesson to consider the source and not take everything your friends say at face value.


This.

Your friend is a dick. Dump him.
Anonymous
Any chance someone came and broke one of John's legs for him before the breakup?
I knew someone like this. Though I was only 12 it wasn't difficult to put 2 & 2 together. John had an abusive father and was afraid to even go into his house of for others to meet his father there, John was engaged and dating a beautiful woman and they seemed very happy until one day John showed up with a broken leg (I never believed the 'he fell in the shower' story - not even at 12)and the engagement was off.

Not his real name but doesn't matter..

He was a great guy - who needed serious counseling to get through life apparently. Or, no intimate relationships. Thanks, dad!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:As the victim in an abusive relationship, I would appreciate an apology all these years later. Just don't try a sob story on me that tries to paint yourself as if only you had known you would have been supportive of me.

Acknowledge that you made a conscious choice to throw our friendship away and choose you friend without finding out my side of the story.

One of the most corrosive things about abuse is the secrecy of it and the gas lighting (when the abuser makes you try to feel as if it is your fault the relationship isn't working and that what he is doing is not abusive). If you came to me and said you had just found out about the abuse, and you are so sorry that you didn't support me and sorrier still that you didn't even bother to ask how I was, I would appreciate it, even all these years later.

I wouldn't be friends with you because your track record of friendship judgment sucks, but it would help me in some small way to know that another person knows the reality of the situation. I certainly will never get that acknowledgement from my abuser.


All of this, except I would consider being friends if we had otherwise been close. Though, probably not close friends.

In any case, OP, I think you should reach out, but just once and don't push it. Send a message so she isn't put on the spot by a phone call.
Anonymous
If you'd like to post john's name and address, that would be great. He deserves the shame, and a serious ass kicking.
post reply Forum Index » Relationship Discussion (non-explicit)
Message Quick Reply
Go to: