Cheaper alternatives for an engagement ring?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
| +1 to the people who said go vintage or estate. You'll save about 50% or more. |
Anonymous
Anonymous
|
what about trying to find someone selling their engagement ring online?
|
Anonymous
|
That first one is beautiful! |
Anonymous
| My engagement ring is yellow sapphire with diamond trim. It's quite a big stone. Cost about 2.5K. |
Anonymous
She'll find out when she gets the ring fitted for her finger and her matching wedding band and appraised for insurance. OP, honestly you've got some good suggestions, but if you can't afford $1500 for an engagement ring (or god forbid can afford it but don't think it's worth it), maybe you should rethink the whole process. The wedding itself is going to cost at about $5,000 bargain basement. I hate to bring up money when discussing a romantic life event, but really you and your future fiance should discuss finances and the future now ... not put it off til later. You may be on the same page, but you may not be. |
Anonymous
| PP here: I meant to say "at least about $5000" |
ThatSmileyFaceGuy
Member Offline
Member Offline
|
You can go with her birthstone too (unless she was born in April)
Or different metals and you can tell people it represents two people coming together as one. |
Anonymous
waitwaitwait - why do you think someone who's decided to spend $1k on an engagement ring hasn't discussed finances with her life mate? if we're going to make assumptions here, i'd make the assumption that this is someone with a solid head on her shoulders vis-a-vis money rather than the alternative. |
Anonymous
I believe the "she" is the OP. So she's fine with it. |
Anonymous
| pp again, beating dead horses: also, let's not forget that $1k is a lot of money. not in the crazy wedding industry world. but in the real world. good for op for knowing what makes sense for her. |
Anonymous
| I love my emerald-cut sapphire engagement ring. Got it custom-made from Bario Neal in Philly--they do gorgeous work, and will work with you to find the design you want! I think it was right around $1K total. |
Anonymous
| We are definitely not jewelry people, but i got married later in life and really wanted a ring. DH proposed in a place verrry special to me - and after he proposed i went to a shop that sold jewelry that reflected the style of the area. I took a long time and selected a very nice ring - it fit well, and it has both silver and gold so it's a nice match with the wedding band. It has no stone so i never worry about it for any reason. It has a fertility symbol on it as part of the design, which is fun and significant for marriage. It's a little chunky so i do remove it occasionally - like when it's really hot out. Every time i look at it i remember our lives in that place, long before DCs. It is definitely NOT a traditional engagement ring, but it's sooo special to me. Good luck OP - i'm so grateful I have this experience, and I hope you find yours! |
Anonymous
Hi, I'm the OP, and I'm actually the "she".  We are actually planning on spending about $5,000 on the wedding. We will be getting married in Congressional Cemetary in a small ceremony, with a family friend officiating, then we will be having a catered BBQ reception afterward at our house (we've been together for a very long time, and already own a home together).
Thanks so everyone for their suggestions! My current top contenders are a herkimer diamond quartz, or a black diamond. |