Fr. Kleinmann at St. Mary's Old Town

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:400 plus kids, no masks...no covid? You have to be out of your mind. Please say that in a crowd so others can raise their eyebrows on how ridiculous that sounds. I wonder which medical expert would agree with you. Your view is reckless, just as reckless as our Shepard leading the flock to follow that reckless path.

I was just listening to a segment on cbs news this morning and it was the opinion of the doctor they were interviewing that it is time to start the discussion on if we need to keep the mitigations such as masks and restrictions on gatherings in place or if it is time to move away from them. There are other doctors and scientists saying the same. You can check regular news sites for some other articles. It has nothing to do with being anti-vaxx. Remember that mask restrictions were dropped when things leveled off last year around this time. The we went back to masks when Delta came around so maybe that is just how it goes. Sometimes masks are needed, sometimes they aren't.

[Anonymous]

I'm ok with starting a conversation. However, unilaterally deciding not to wear a mask in front of students, many of whom are wearing masks is just poor leadership by a religious Shepard. I don't know why you are not understanding...coming back with a comment about CBS. Does CBS run BI or work with parents to allay concerns. We are not at the stage of just completely taking off masks. Is it worth the conversation, sure. This conversation should be held at a higher level than the priest at BI just not wearing a mask. We are talking about a so-called leader who is modeling appropriate behavior for young men and women. Sure, antivaxers and antimaskers are ready to go cold turkey and throw all of the COVID mitigation measures out the window because they are insane and don't want to be members of a civilized society who adheres to a social contract of the greater good. You are totally missing the point...this is about leadership and arrogance. What does his actions show to the more than half of the school who wears masks. Unfortunately, his leadership and actions are held to a higher standard. Father N should be teaching kids to be SELFLESS even when they may disagree. Let the health professionals be part of this conversation when unmasking.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Unfortunately, Father Noah Morey from Bishop Ireton, shows the same level of arrogance as Father Hathoway. Father Noah refuses to wear a face cover during a pandemic. Of course, it is his right outside of school to do as he wishes. But he should be setting the example for these kids. To thumb his nose at the reality of COVID 19, it's outrageous and arrogant, certainly not Jesus-like. If he doesn't want to be vaccinated, then fine. I don't know his status nor do I care. But at least participate in the social contract. I am tired of political priests who are not selfless and appear to be political priests instead of kind and loving members of society who set the example. Yes, masks prevent others from contracting COVID. This is such a small sacrifice that you will not unfortunately make. I'm sure Jesus would. If priests want to be viewed in the same light as Jesus, particularly during Transubstantiation, then they need to try to emulate the traits of Jesus...kind, selfless, member of the social contract and APOLITICAL!!! Very disappointed in Catholic priests - they are too political!

Agree! Father Hathaway is the antithesis of holy, as far as I'm concerned. and he's a money grubber. To shame families for not giving to the new school during a pandemic is incomprehensible. I don't know anyone who actually likes him.

[Anonymous]

Even though Father Noah is a poor example to high school kids at BI, he makes a great political statement by unilaterally deciding to not wear a face covering in the middle of a pandemic without the advice of medical professionals. He's a poor excuse for a leader. Just one student's opinion.

[Anonymous]

I don’t quite agree with describing Father Hathaway as money grubbing. However, he does seem to overly enjoy squeezing the last cent from each of us. The only real thing that bothers me is that he doesn’t seem overly kind which is what I would rather have in a priest versus an expert fund raiser. As for father Noah, I agree that it is a lapse in Christian judgment to arbitrarily not wear a mask in a school of vulnerable young adults who are looking at his every action for leadership. Probably poor judgment on his part but I am no judge. Even the repairmen at the dealership I went to yesterday were wearing masks. However, Father Noah is only guilty of being tone deaf at best and a poor example of a priest and leader at worst. But again, human being do not serve as judge. Our Lord and Savior will ultimately judge our behavior.