An Iranian’s perspective

Anonymous
Ali khameini already has one foot in the grave. He’s 86. Wouldn’t it make sense for the Iranians to wait out his death? A regime change war right now seems pointless.
Anonymous
honest question for the OP - if the Iranian regime is somehow overthrown or dislodged as part of this action, what type of government do you envision taking its place?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Well, Israel has been crying about Iran being close to nuclear ability since 2012 or 2015 or something. I think it was 2018 they were gonna have it in a couple wks! They were talking about it and then the next thing you know, it's a pre-emptive strike. Sorry but I question what shadiness is going on that Trump made a deal about with Israel because it's not about nuclear weapons.


Wrong, they were even crying about it in the late 1970s and early 80s.

https://x.com/KenOKeefe1TJP/status/1933076807261061184/photo/1


I remember the threat of nuclear weapons being stated by Israel very shortly after the revolution
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Well, Israel has been crying about Iran being close to nuclear ability since 2012 or 2015 or something. I think it was 2018 they were gonna have it in a couple wks! They were talking about it and then the next thing you know, it's a pre-emptive strike. Sorry but I question what shadiness is going on that Trump made a deal about with Israel because it's not about nuclear weapons.


Wrong, they were even crying about it in the late 1970s and early 80s.

https://x.com/KenOKeefe1TJP/status/1933076807261061184/photo/1


I remember the threat of nuclear weapons being stated by Israel very shortly after the revolution


They also said the same about Saddam. Egypt actually was first to explore a nuke program in the 60s and Israel assassinated some French scientists helping Nasser with that.

Israel developed their own nuclear facilities (that JFK didn’t want them to have) throughout the 70s and 80s so it seems like a smokescreen or diversion tactic by pointing fingers at Iran and Iraq instead.

Reagan and Bush Sr. Did not fall into the neocon and Israeli firsters trap that much (I recall a tense relationship between Israel and those presidents). Certainly, a tense relationship btwn Israel and the Clinton and Obama WH. I remember there was anger in Israel over Hillary giving the Palestinian First Lady a kiss and longer hug than the Israeli First Lady (yes this was an actual news story).


Bush Jr. Was a Texan born again Evangelical and he really believed Iraq was a biblical crusade. At one point, he was referencing Gog and Magog. He brought the neocon cabal to strength in the Republican Party
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Well, Israel has been crying about Iran being close to nuclear ability since 2012 or 2015 or something. I think it was 2018 they were gonna have it in a couple wks! They were talking about it and then the next thing you know, it's a pre-emptive strike. Sorry but I question what shadiness is going on that Trump made a deal about with Israel because it's not about nuclear weapons.


Wrong, they were even crying about it in the late 1970s and early 80s.

https://x.com/KenOKeefe1TJP/status/1933076807261061184/photo/1


I remember the threat of nuclear weapons being stated by Israel very shortly after the revolution


They also said the same about Saddam. Egypt actually was first to explore a nuke program in the 60s and Israel assassinated some French scientists helping Nasser with that.

Israel developed their own nuclear facilities (that JFK didn’t want them to have) throughout the 70s and 80s so it seems like a smokescreen or diversion tactic by pointing fingers at Iran and Iraq instead.

Reagan and Bush Sr. Did not fall into the neocon and Israeli firsters trap that much (I recall a tense relationship between Israel and those presidents). Certainly, a tense relationship btwn Israel and the Clinton and Obama WH. I remember there was anger in Israel over Hillary giving the Palestinian First Lady a kiss and longer hug than the Israeli First Lady (yes this was an actual news story).


Bush Jr. Was a Texan born again Evangelical and he really believed Iraq was a biblical crusade. At one point, he was referencing Gog and Magog. He brought the neocon cabal to strength in the Republican Party


Interesting, thank you for sharing. As they say with Israel time and time again - every accusation is a confession.
Anonymous
It's hard to forget the US involvement in the last regime change in Iran--bringing the shah to power.
Now, Israel (with US backing, who are we kidding) wants regime change--somehow--kill ALL the ayatollahs?--and THEN what?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:honest question for the OP - if the Iranian regime is somehow overthrown or dislodged as part of this action, what type of government do you envision taking its place?


My hope is for free elections/democracy and beyond that I don’t think anyone can say. Maybe it will be much better, maybe only slightly better. But it certainly can’t be worse. I genuinely don’t see how it could get worse unless something like the Taliban takes over, and I just don’t see that happening for a variety of reasons (pretty much zero Iranians want that and there is really no precedent for it in Iran).
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:honest question for the OP - if the Iranian regime is somehow overthrown or dislodged as part of this action, what type of government do you envision taking its place?


My hope is for free elections/democracy and beyond that I don’t think anyone can say. Maybe it will be much better, maybe only slightly better. But it certainly can’t be worse. I genuinely don’t see how it could get worse unless something like the Taliban takes over, and I just don’t see that happening for a variety of reasons (pretty much zero Iranians want that and there is really no precedent for it in Iran).


No precedent? No precedent?

What do you call the past 45 years???
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:honest question for the OP - if the Iranian regime is somehow overthrown or dislodged as part of this action, what type of government do you envision taking its place?


My hope is for free elections/democracy and beyond that I don’t think anyone can say. Maybe it will be much better, maybe only slightly better. But it certainly can’t be worse. I genuinely don’t see how it could get worse unless something like the Taliban takes over, and I just don’t see that happening for a variety of reasons (pretty much zero Iranians want that and there is really no precedent for it in Iran).


No precedent? No precedent?

What do you call the past 45 years???


Certainly there is precedent for Islamism/theocracy. What I meant was that there is no precedent for a Taliban-style government. There is a lot of daylight between the current Iranian regime (as terrible as they are) and the Taliban.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Someone really wants to prove they’re Iranian


Exactly. Except ALL the Iranians I know call themselves Persian.


DP. Same. But also, there's a reason for that...


I can promise you Iranians are not going around calling themselves “Persian” except to Americans (and even then, only to shield themselves from potential bigotry).


DP. Hold on. There are a couple of Iranian families at my swimming pool. They refer to themselves and Iran as Persia/Persians all the time.

It's a thing of pride, given their rich history. But what the hell do you know.


Again, TO AMERICANS. Amongst themselves, Iranians do not typically refer to themselves as Persians. There is no real equivalent word in Farsi.


DP (Iranian). This is correct. If you don't believe the PP, type "He is Persian" in Google translate, which returns this:
او ایرانی است
The middle word is "Irahni."
Anonymous
Dear World. You are welcome

-Isreal
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Dear World. You are welcome

-Isreal


This is funny because the people responsible for whatever danger ACTUALLY exists are expecting gratitude for using OUR treasure, talents, and ingenuity to capitalize on THEIR superiority agenda.
Anonymous
No, we don't want this war.
Anonymous
Even the Brits did not colonize Iran
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Dear World. You are welcome

-Isreal


Dear Israel. You are welcome

-American taxpayers
post reply Forum Index » Political Discussion
Message Quick Reply
Go to: