If every child went to their by right middle school, we would have 3 schools as good as Hardy overnight. If they continued onto Eastern, it would be second only to Wilson. The demographics are in place already. People just need to show up. And yes I understand why people haven't shown up. But frankly it all gets down to a cohort. Wilson and Deal aren't magic, they just have a cohort to support more advanced things. Splitting CH up into 3 MS reduces those cohorts and contributes to where we are today. |
Why keep talking this way? Families just aren't turning up in large numbers - the cohort just isn't forming in our Hill middle schools. The cohort is forming at Washington Latin, BASIS and possibly Two Rivers, DCI, Creative Minds etc. It will form at Washington Latin II starting next year. When are Capitol Hil parents going to start organizing to vote our politicians who don't support a viable 6th-12th grade path in Ward 6, including Charles Allen? Five years more of this won't be enough to change the middle school calculus. More like 10 or 15 for middle school and 20-25 for Eastern/high school. Sad. |
In a different time, pre the big gentrification push. No one is in charge now - Bowser just isn't very interested in DCPS or keeping high SES families in the City. I'm not buying that CH middle schools will be flooded with gentrifiers' children in 5-10 years, not when "turn key" homegrown charters like Latin are opening second campuses. |
The only thing Latin has going for it is demographics and the ability to kick people out. That is not to say it is a bad school but assume that Latin II looks more like the second and less like the NW roots of Latin I, I don't see it being a cure all. |
This is just not true. What Latin has going for it is adults in charge who have expertise, experience, vision and flexibility in their curriculum offerings, graduation policies, college counseling, budgeting etc. Latin can offer robust geography, history and government classes in middle school. DCPS middle schools have very little of all this and it shows. Latin is not a perfect school, but given its decade-long track record of taking all comers and educating well-rounded students and graduating them into post-secondary programs and valuable scholarships; it is certainly not only demographics at play here |
not "only" but largely. Once demographics are factored Latin's MS achievement numbers are pretty underwhelming |
You're painting with too broad a brush when considering "results." The PARCC doesn't test geography, history, government, classics/Latin...it tests math and English, nothing more.
|
Like it or not it's the yard stick everyone uses on here. i suspect YY is better at teaching Mandarin than any other DC public but it's not exactly foundational. |
Not quite everybody. We opt out of the silly PARCC. We really just look at demographics when picking DC public schools (% of high SES families. % of Asian families because we're Asian). |
Inane comment as PARCC mostly aligns with your given criteria. Some schools just underperform with or without minuscule Asian representation |
This is true. And non-white achievement has declined over the last several years. Non-white students had better achievement scores when the school was less wealthy and less white. |
Right, so you won't send your CH 5th grader to WL if they crack the lottery? You'd prefer Eliot-Hine, Jefferson Academy or Stuart Hobson?
Sheesh, it's not as though we have the world of choice on the public MS shopping front here EotP. We have neighbors who would have bailed for the burbs after many years on the Hill if their oldest sib hadn't cracked the WL or BASIS lottery. There are scores of middle and high schools in this City where non-whites don't perform very well. At least we have a few where most enrolled students do. |
And by most, I assume you mean white. So what do you do if your child is black? |
Ignore the troll race-baiter above. |
Exactly. No CH parent is going to turn down a spot at Latin, Basis, or DCI. Period. We all know it. It’s where the higher performing peer groups are. What is sad is that EH, JA, and SH doesn’t even come close in peer group. The stats are dismal. And no, a few UMC families sending their kids to any of these schools is not going to cut it. |