It’s a pain in the butt. Kids may not see it in time. Want to be able to send a quick text. |
You need help. |
| Then ban all personal devices at school. Because a kid using their MacBook will have all of the media and texting. |
Good kids shouldn’t be punished. They should be allowed to send texts to parents at lunch period. |
But why? |
Why? Why do they need to text parents? Cut the cord. They're fine without being in contact with you during the school day. |
| Here’s my prediction. This is not going to be enforced at all. Come back in November and ask us how it’s going and it’s going to be the exact same as this year. This is a great law for people who have spent zero time in schools. It’s completely not enforceable for HS. The same amount of kids will have dummy phones. Teachers and admin will get lax on rules. Most kids will keep them off and away and it won’t be an issue. Over time, we will go on about our lives, try to get back to actually teaching students, and there will be a new hot topic. - HS teacher |
+1 they cannot enforce this at lunch. It’s bs. |
Oh girl, You have no idea what your child is doing on his phone, or what his friends are showing him on their phones. That goes for girls, too. |
| Lots of teens on tonight. |
|
Great! I hope the school offices staff up to handle all of the “messages” that need to get to the kids - like ride home with Susie today because I got stuck at work.
Messages are called into the office and then delivered to the classroom back in my day of FCPS. Can’t wait for how FCPS handles this change |
Our giant school has a dozen “office assistant” TAs who run around delivering notes once in a blue moon but most just sit in the corner scrolling on their laptop for the period. They have plenty of bandwidth to deliver messages. They made it work 20 years ago, they can make it work again next year. |
They can stand in that room and use them briefly, then must lock them back up to leave the room and go to lunch. |
I posted that this is all made by people who have never been in schools. This won’t happen. They might actually try to buy lockboxes or pouches, because they like to waste money. Middle and HS students will put in a fake phone, just like they do now for the militant teachers who collect them, and keep their real phone. No one will be patrolling the cafeteria looking for cell phones. There are much bigger issues in a school. -hs teacher again |
Schools either have universal rules and values (about presence, phones, accountability for following policy) or kids and teens don’t take them seriously because adult being huge hypocrites is extremely obvious to kids— particularly teens. Plenty of workplaces don’t allow phones so this isn’t about teachers not being treated like adults. |