Contact your state government representatives. They are the ones who passed this law. |
Coaches could just use email. The kids access school email from laptops. Problem solved. Coaches should never have been using social media and message apps to communicate with students anyway. |
They don’t have time to check email on their bulky laptop during lunch. What a stupid idea. They should be allowed to check their phone for texts or email at lunch. |
They are on their laptops and see their fcps email in almost all of their classes. They literally use it in class. They don't have to take additional time to check it during lunch. The childish, dismissive, and rude way that you responded to my comment is all the more reason that teenagers don't need any more time on their phones being exposed to the gross way that humans speak to each other through screens. They grow up learning that this is the way humans talk to each other, which is pretty sad. |
I have HS students who do school sports, club sports and have jobs. They can get these messages after school and still have time to adjust plans accordingly. |
That is false. Some classes they do not actually use laptops, like PE and possibly science during a lab. Also in a lot of math classes they do not automatically have their laptops out. Also band or orchestra. So no, they do not all have laptops open and roaring to go at the start of class in all of their classes and have time to check email. They could easily miss an email communication depending on when it is sent. In addition, some teachers make a point to say no other tabs can be open while they are working on stuff - you could get in serious trouble for checking email at that point. Kids should be able to use their phones during lunch. |
| I guess I have to buy my kid a dumb watch now because her smart watch won’t be allowed either. |
This. |
| yes to the person who mentioned pay phones. WE HAD THEM! kids made calls to their parents during lunch. Heck we could leave for lunch, we could go outside. We were treated like adults! |
|
Phones are being banned across the country, and more and more school districts are hearing from teachers and administrators just how serious the problem has become—students can’t concentrate or put their phones away during class. Teachers are stuck filling out forms, getting into confrontations, and losing valuable instruction time because of disruptive phone use. And that’s not even getting into the amount of cheating enabled by phones...that’s a whole other can of worms.
FCPS is doing what most districts are starting to do, what many private schools have long done, and what neuroscientists and psychologists broadly support: limiting phone use throughout the entire school day. It’s the right call! If you’re a parent complaining about this change, stop doomscrolling and actually read up on the issue. Do what’s right for your child and for others. Stop being the $#%-wad who refuses to understand the harm phones cause during the school day. |
| Kids sometimes use lunch time to study and need to watch videos on their phone - such as Heimler review videos for APUSH. It was incredibly helpful for my student to be able to use lunch time for a quick review. Often these videos are blocked on school computers. |
| I don’t support this unless we ban all screens, including laptops, for the entire day. |
My kid is at an away-for-the-day private. The kids interact in person all day. The school also uses laptops less (not never, but less) than FCPS in-class. It helps the overall environment so much. And there are solutions for each and every one of the issues raised here, from last minute sports changes to calling home. There really are. |
Heimler is not blocked on school computers. Sigh. Neither is most educational content. Good one! |
|
The people in this thread arguing for the phones are either teenagers or adults addicted to their screens.
This is a good thing. We messed people up with unfettered access to screens and we should embrace attempts to undo the damage. |