CAIR complains of incident at Damascus ES

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Note that that CAIR official who commented on this is Zainab Chaudry, the person on the hate crime commission that made antisemitic comments
https://foxbaltimore.com/amp/news/local/growing-calls-to-remove-islamic-group-from-md-hate-crime-commission-over-directors-abhorrent-remarks-gov-wes-moore-annapolis-cair-and-zainab-chaudry-israel-hamas

anti zionist is anti-semitic??

meh

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I'm wondering what the poem would need to say to justify a person heckling AND the administration doing nothing. Let's say the kid was calling for Jihad or murdering Jewish people. Should the admin just stand by while the kid gets heckled? Is heckling our official response to hate speech?

From the river to the sea...to the sea...to the sea...

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The big issue here isn't just that some bigot decided to engage in Islamophomic bullying, it's that the administration sat by and did nothing. There will always be bullies and bigots but when folks with power choose to side with them, then you have a court case on your hand.

what words did they read? Is it bullying if the readers were speaking words calling for the destruction of Israel? Why don’t they name the poem?

The poem was presumably vetted by the PTA or the administration. Further, you may not like CAIR but they are savvy political operators. They would not be setting this case alongside the attempted drowning of a Palestinian child in Texas if the poem were "calling for the destruction of Israel."

Does the PTA vet poems and readings from international night? I truly don’t know. Is the school by school? I have never heard of the PTA approving material for international night.

I doubt they would have time or personnel to vet anything being performed for international night. These programs are usually run by a small group of volunteers.

Correct, no one vets Interntional Night "talent". The volunteers are busy organizing everything.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm wondering what the poem would need to say to justify a person heckling AND the administration doing nothing. Let's say the kid was calling for Jihad or murdering Jewish people. Should the admin just stand by while the kid gets heckled? Is heckling our official response to hate speech?

From the river to the sea...to the sea...to the sea...

Many Middle East experts say that the phrase “from the river to the sea” is not calling for eliminating Jewish people from the area. It is not as politically charged as some folks have made it out to be.

[Anonymous]

Reading this thread is illuminating. Rampant Islamophobia. Amazing how so many people are rushing to defend the heckling adult over a 2nd grader without much information.
Until we know more, I am fully on the side of the 2nd grader over the shrieking adult

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Reading this thread is illuminating. Rampant Islamophobia. Amazing how so many people are rushing to defend the heckling adult over a 2nd grader without much information.
Until we know more, I am fully on the side of the 2nd grader over the shrieking adult

Fully on the side of gossip as there has been no investigation.

[Anonymous]

What about the Texas incident where some crazy adult tried to drown a small Muslim child? I wonder what the child did to provoke the adult? That is what these reflexive Israel supporters are probably saying

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Reading this thread is illuminating. Rampant Islamophobia. Amazing how so many people are rushing to defend the heckling adult over a 2nd grader without much information.
Until we know more, I am fully on the side of the 2nd grader over the shrieking adult

lack of support for Gaza and Hamas is not Islamophobia, just as lack of support for the Israeli government’s actions is not anti-semitism. This attitude is why most Americans in general aren’t sympathetic with either side in this war, who both want to kill eachother for religious reasons. Trying to drag the conflict into an elementary school is a cynical manipulation of kids and is not appropriate, and not going to win any converts among their parents.

[Anonymous]

I would need to know what was said in the poem. As a teacher, I couldn't imagine a scenario where heckling a 2nd grader is okay, but I do think that the lack of details in the complaint is concerning.

I also want to understand what the principal heard- if it was full-on heckling, I just can't imagine that the principal would just have to issue an apology unless it just wasn't that bad.

I'm shocked that this did not make it to DCUM prior to the complaint. I would also guess there is video of this, so I think it is strange that the video is not in the complaint and has not been shared.

Something just seems off.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I would need to know what was said in the poem. As a teacher, I couldn't imagine a scenario where heckling a 2nd grader is okay, but I do think that the lack of details in the complaint is concerning.

I also want to understand what the principal heard- if it was full-on heckling, I just can't imagine that the principal would just have to issue an apology unless it just wasn't that bad.

I'm shocked that this did not make it to DCUM prior to the complaint. I would also guess there is video of this, so I think it is strange that the video is not in the complaint and has not been shared.

Something just seems off.

Something seems off because CAIR likes to play the victim and blow situations out of proportion.

I don't think it was right to heckle a little kid if that really happened and the principal should have intervened. No matter what they said. But the gaps in the information shared make me skeptical that it was as bad as they say.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Reading this thread is illuminating. Rampant Islamophobia. Amazing how so many people are rushing to defend the heckling adult over a 2nd grader without much information.
Until we know more, I am fully on the side of the 2nd grader over the shrieking adult

lack of support for Gaza and Hamas is not Islamophobia, just as lack of support for the Israeli government’s actions is not anti-semitism. This attitude is why most Americans in general aren’t sympathetic with either side in this war, who both want to kill eachother for religious reasons. Trying to drag the conflict into an elementary school is a cynical manipulation of kids and is not appropriate, and not going to win any converts among their parents.

None of it is about religious reasons. It's all about land, power, money, and the painful losses over generations.

[Anonymous]

This is my son we are talking about...as a parent would u want any of our children going through this as an all American Palestinian family..I am monitoring all comments believe me..

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:This is my son we are talking about...as a parent would u want any of our children going through this as an all American Palestinian family..I am monitoring all comments believe me..

I am truly sorry this happened to your son. Can you clarify what poem was read and what the heckler said? We all want to support, but CAIR is tough to trust.

[Anonymous]

Post the poem.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:This is my son we are talking about...as a parent would u want any of our children going through this as an all American Palestinian family..I am monitoring all comments believe me..

Monitoring them for what? This is an anonymous chat room. It has no connection to the school system or the county.