Agree, but I don’t really get it. I mean do they hate the idea of disadvantaged kids going to TJ so much that they want to paint every successful TJ athlete as “undeserving” of being there? Ad it’s so odd, because there are so many talented athletes at TJ who are also equally academically talented. I’ve known quite a few of them over the years, and this is going back a number of years, so the troll can’t blame the newer admissions process which they seem to be so irritated about. |
People don't understand the serious effort that a student athlete puts into their sport starting from kindergarten years. |
It depends on the kid, the sport, and the level of talent. The many TJ kids I’ve known who have combined high level academics and high level sports have been great kids who have been successful in college and in the first few years after so far. Quite a few of them still involved in their sports, too! |
They have at least 9 commits this year, probably more. |
Each base school has over 25 commits |
+1 |
Well given the trolls that are saying either a TJ is a grindy nerd that studies all the time OR doesn't belong there, having any athletic recruits from TJ is amazing. Bc the "kids that don't belong there" certainly didn't come for the sports. Congrats to all the recruited athletes! |
That is not true for most schools. Please provide links. |
Yes, they do. |
Fairfax High School Celebrates 32 Student Athletes in NCAA Ceremony https://www.cityoffairfaxschools.org/apps/news/article/1773784 |
Need to be lowered to 2.2 at TJ as well, to keep it fair and equitable for all. |
This is a tremendous number and should be celebrated. But it's worth mentioning that only six of them will be attending schools that TJ students generally would even consider. Almost by definition, if you choose to attend TJ, you are prioritizing academics to a significant extent. That's not necessarily at the expense of athletics, as it's been demonstrated repeatedly that students can have a tremendous athletic experience at TJ that in many cases exceeds what they could get at their base school. But it shouldn't come as a surprise that these kids end up making their college decisions based on their ceilings as students rather than their ceilings as athletes. Every one of the top six tennis players on both the boys and girls side at TJ could play in college if they want to. Same is true of most of their top swimmers and many of their top runners. Heck, this year the boys basketball team could have sent 4-5 kids to play in college, and a couple of them were actually heavily recruited. But when these kids are getting into Princeton and Cornell and Harvard (in part because of their athletic success even though they're not recruited), they're going to go there. |
In terms of time commitment, sports at TJ tends to favor the academically advanced students, who often participate throughout all four years, but not as a potential athletic recruit. While many students try out sports during freshman year, quite a few quit by junior year. Some students give up on hopes of improving their GPA, but stay involved with sports for physical and recreational benefits. There are many academically average students who stay involved with sports to enhance their college application profiles.
If a student is serious about improving their chances as an athletic recruit, TJ as a stem school is not an ideal place to be in. Base schools have better options and offer academic flexibility with a lower minimum GPA requirement and lighter coursework. |
The entirety of the above is basically untrue and betrays a lack of understanding of the dynamics within TJ athletics. The above poster indicated that quite a few students quit by junior year - this is at the very least misleading. Athletic participation rates increase year over year at TJ as students recognize the advantages of being a part of the respective teams and witness their classmates navigating the process successfully. Some do quit - a huge chunk of that is self-selection out of the process because they either get cut for Varsity teams or assume they will get cut. Students of all academic levels at TJ have their college application profiles enhanced by participation in athletics - it's not just the "academically average" ones, whatever is meant by that. And it's patently untrue that students serious about improving their chances as an athletic recruit would be better served at a base school. Students choosing to attend TJ will almost always, especially in team sports, have a greater chance to compete at the Varsity level earlier at TJ than they would at their base school. This is yet another example of a parent who is probably trying to encourage people to decline their offers of admission in order to improve their child's chances of being recalled off of the waitlist. Take these posters with a grain of salt. |
The PP's writing is so stilted I suspect some troll ran things through ChatGTP for their own amusement. Why trolling about everyone dropping out of sports by junior year at TJ is so fun for some random person on the internet I cannot fathom. |