This random -let me give you a crap ton of details without giving you details is a very stupid response. Just say - My friends did this and I have no idea whatsoever if the kid is impacted or not. Or better yet, dont comment. |
I think both of those are both fine, but will admit that we chose a name for our DD that has both feminine and more androgynous options for nicknames because we wanted a name that would suit whatever person they became. It was something we thought about because we both have short, androgynous names (like both of our names are fairly commonly used for both genders) and that impacted us growing up. I wouldn't see it caused problems, but for instance I always wished I'd had a more feminine name because I'm pretty feminine, and my DH always wished he'd had a more standard "boy" name. We're not screwed up by it, but it's a preference. So when we named our DD, we made sure to choose a clearly feminine name, but picked one that has a common, more masculine, nickname in case she would feel more comfortable using that. And we like both versions of the name. |
There is a girl on that Indian matchmaking show named Shital and she talks about all the grief she got. |
| My husband really wanted to name our son Tucker. Anything that rhymes with "f**ker" was a no-go for me. |
|
One of my kids has a name that can be pronounced two ways - like Naomi as Nay-omi or Ny- omi.
It currently bothers him because he doesn’t like to correct people but has a very clear preference for one of the pronunciations. He’s asked us to call him James instead. I hope he gets over it. I love his real name. |
I have a friend named Thea who has this issue (she pronounces it Thee-ah, but she gets Thay-ah and Tay-ah as well). I don't think it's hugely upsetting to her, but not ideal. She told me once that it's mainly only annoying when people try to argue with her about it, and explain that she's pronouncing her own name wrong. Which does sound annoying but also: who does that? |
Our kids attend a very diverse HS and each year, at graduation, I am awed by one teacher who flies, properly and respectfully through them. Turns out, when they come to pick up their grad ceremony tickets, he asks for it sloooowly, makes phonetic notes for himself, and even records the ones he struggles with if he's not already had them for the core subject he teaches. To see kids who've had their names butchered for years....have it spoken like it should be for their moment of glory is
|
I grew up with a Matthew Perry. |
|
DS's name is an animal. So far the worst that has happened is some minor confusion among certain younger kids in daycare/preschool.
He's in ES now and thinks his name rocks. It also suits him perfectly! |
|
I have a very common name spelled slightly uniquely. It’s nothing but an annoyance. My kids have traditional but not super popular names with one established spelling.
|
|
MIL's name reminded me of luncheon meat. She wanted me to give it to my DD and I put my foot down. Even though nobody in her generation would probably make fun of her name, i wasn't too sure about the 21st century. We went with her very common middle name instead.
|
At my college graduation, they mispronounced my friend's very common Norwegian name, even though she'd included the phonetic spelling. It was almost as if they'd done it deliberately. Thank you for making the effort to get everyone's names right! |
| I legally changed my name in college and dropped my middle name. I never liked my first or middle name and they sounded awful together. I use a more updated version of my original name. |
|
We named our daughter 'Marlo'. Overall, it suits her and is fine, but here are some "problems" we have encountered:
1. Spanish speakers who have not met her assume she is a boy because the name ends with 'o.' 2. There is a kid in her class named 'Marco' and it sometimes leads to misunderstandings. 3. Sometimes people call her "Margot." 4. Rhymes with 'Larlo'. |
Pam? Maloney? Quiver First? |