It’s not a joke that someone is wasting research money on this, and that the media is reporting on it uncritically. Sadly, not a joke. |
PS I am not saying what specific things do/don’t cause asd. I’m saying if you read pregnancy books like brain health from birth they tell you avoid this, avoid that, but - It is not our fault that freaking everything around us is poison! and the burden shouldn’t be on us to go live in some imaginary bubble separate from the industrialized world! |
|
Why is this a waste? This is revolutionizing testing for Parkinson's. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/jacsau.2c00300 |
Yes - so we're all sort of doomed in a way. Ugh this type of gloom leads to conspiracies by the way. As soon as family asks "Are you sure he's XYZ, this country loves to DX kids" not to mention environmental factors...when is the science ever going to catch up. There was an interesting thread sometime ago on genetic testing and ASD. FYI - not all ASD kids have stomach issues or autoimmune...nor are all ASD born premature...my kid was born right at term, 9lbs, and has no stomach nor other health issues as of now - thankfully...so I don't know where these correlations are coming from? |
There are lots of illnesses that kids watch their parents struggle with. |
Yeah I agree with you honestly. There’s nothing we all can do. We’re just like people who lived before other medical breakthroughs and had to make do. It sucked to have an infection before penicillin! Ha. And I agree at a certain point it shows conspiracy theories. But I also can’t abide just putting our heads in the sand and rigidly saying nope, it’s impossible that any of this is connected and we shouldn’t even check. The fact is it’s unknown and that’s true for both sides. You can’t claim to know one way or the other. (Not directed at you specifically) |
Sorry but that’s just the truth |
No, it’s not. If you think that paper is “revolutionizing testing for Parkinson’s” you need to do some basic scientific literacy education. |
DP. Sure, in theory the idea that “we can just check any random theory! do the MRI scans!” sounds fine to a layperson. In reality, what results is a mess of useless science, inaccurately touted and reported, and lack of attention to the kind of research and investment that would actually help our kids. Much of this research gets funded because it is trendy in some way - MRI scans, genetics, “biomarkers”, microbiome, inflammation … |
Please show me the “truth” about “epigenetics” causing autism, and moreover, that supposed truth doing *anything at all* to help our kids. |
|
Just gonna leave this here for the credulous among us:
https://www.spectrumnews.org/news/brain-imaging-do-over-offers-clues-to-fields-replication-crisis/ |
Epigenetics is not a “cause”, it’s an explanation for the occurrence of many diseases and conditions, which could include autism. |
That explanation and $10,000 will get my kid a year’s worth of therapy and payments to the educational consultant. |
|
The historical perspective seems to be lacking here. There was a time not very long ago (1990s, when I was in school), when an autism diagnosis was extremely rare. It was only given to the very most impacted children, as in “Rain Man.” I volunteered at a residential school for autistic teens.
At that time, people may be surprised to hear, a much more common diagnosis was “mental r-tardation.” Huge numbers of kids were put into that category. Here is a document: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00040023.htm The kids haven’t changed. They are being labeled differently. |